09/09/2026
If you’ve never eaten at Galleria before, start with these four.
The Sicilian pizza is the classic New York-style starting point, the spicy rigatoni brings fried chicken cutlet, burrata, hot honey, and vodka sauce that belongs on everything, and the chicken cutlet Parmesan hits different because the cutlets are fried in beef tallow. Then there’s the Philly cheesesteak — marinated ribeye, provolone whiz, grilled onions, and a semolina hero done in a way nobody else on Long Island is doing.
This is Galleria in four orders: pizza, vodka sauce, beef-tallow cutlets, and a sandwich that actually deserves the hype.