Bagel Plaza

Bagel Plaza Bagel Plaza is the oldest bagel place on the south shore, serving up all original recipes and sandwiches made from scratch to the residents of Merrick, NY.

We were established in 1962 when bagels were a novelty, and we’ve kept up our top quality preparations to create the best New York bagels around. Bagel Plaza has 56 different bagels, bialys, and Challahs made from scratch daily. We carry a full line of smoked fish as well as flavored 15 different cream cheeses, and over 20 different salads, all made with Kosher ingredients. And make sure to ask about our soup of the day! Have a big event coming up, such as a Bar or Bat Mizvah? We cater! So let us take care of the meal for your event to ease any stress. Your complete satisfaction is our top priority. Let our friendly and welcoming staff help you create a one of a kind bagel sandwich, or recommend the perfect bagel and cream cheese combination to satisfy your bagel cravings. Come grab a bite today!

09/25/2026

πŸ₯―✨ Two classics. One seriously satisfying sandwich. πŸ’™

Meet the Nova Lox Egg Salad Sandwich β€” silky, hand-sliced Nova lox paired with creamy, homemade egg salad, piled onto a fresh-baked bagel. 🐟πŸ₯š

It’s rich, savory, creamy, and packed with the classic Bagel Plaza flavor you know and love.

One bite and you’ll see why this combo just works.🀀

πŸ“ 1704 Merrick Rd, Merrick, NY
πŸ“ž (516) 378-3455
🌐 bagelplaza.com

09/23/2026

WHAT BROUGHT YOU HERE? πŸ‘€πŸ₯―

The bagels?
The nova?
The iced coffee?
The rugelach?

Or… all of the above? πŸ˜‚

Be honest… what’s your Bagel Plaza weakness? πŸ‘‡

πŸ’¬ Tell us in the comments!
πŸ“² Tag the friend who’s ALWAYS down for a Bagel Plaza run. πŸ₯―πŸ˜‚

πŸ“ 1704 Merrick Rd, Merrick, NY
πŸ“ž (516) 378-3455
🌐 bagelplaza.com

G’Mar Tov from our Bagel Plaza family to yours! πŸ’™From Sam, Yana and everyone at Bagel Plaza, we want to wish everyone ob...
09/20/2026

G’Mar Tov from our Bagel Plaza family to yours! πŸ’™

From Sam, Yana and everyone at Bagel Plaza, we want to wish everyone observing Yom Kippur an easy and meaningful fast. Thank you for including us at your break-fast table and allowing us to be part of your family traditions. πŸ₯―

Shabbat Shalom from all of us at Bagel Plaza. πŸ•―οΈπŸ’™As we welcome Shabbat and prepare for Yom Kippur beginning Sunday eveni...
09/18/2026

Shabbat Shalom from all of us at Bagel Plaza. πŸ•―οΈπŸ’™

As we welcome Shabbat and prepare for Yom Kippur beginning Sunday evening, we wish everyone observing an easy and meaningful fast. May this sacred time bring reflection, peace, and renewal.

Shabbat Shalom & G’mar Chatima Tova. ✑️

πŸ“ 1704 Merrick Rd, Merrick, NY
πŸ“ž (516) 378-3455
🌐 bagelplaza.com

🚨πŸ₯― TODAY’S THE DAY! LAST CALL FOR YOM KIPPUR BREAK-FAST! πŸ₯―🚨Today β€” Wednesday, September 16th β€” is the FINAL DAY to place...
09/16/2026

🚨πŸ₯― TODAY’S THE DAY! LAST CALL FOR YOM KIPPUR BREAK-FAST! πŸ₯―🚨

Today β€” Wednesday, September 16th β€” is the FINAL DAY to place your Yom Kippur Break-Fast package order!

If you’ve been meaning to order, this is your last chance! ⏰ Don’t wait β€” call Bagel Plaza today and reserve your favorite package for your Break-Fast gathering. πŸ’™

🐟 Deluxe Fish Platter
6–8 guests: $300 | 9–12 guests: $380
πŸ₯— Salad Platter
10–12: $140 | 12–15: $175 | 15–18: $210 | 18–22: $245

πŸ₯’ Healthy Combo Platter
7–10 guests: $269

πŸͺ Cookie Platter
10–18: $50 | 18–24: $65 | 24–30: $85 | 30–40: $110

πŸ₯― All platters include your choice of Bagels & Bialys.

πŸ“… ORDER DEADLINE: TODAY β€” SEPTEMBER 16TH
πŸ“¦ PICKUP: SUNDAY, SEPTEMBER 20TH BEFORE 2 PM
🚫 NO DELIVERIES DURING THE HOLIDAY

Please note: Platters cannot be customized, and there is a $175 minimum on all other orders.
🚨 DON’T MISS IT β€” CALL TODAY TO PLACE YOUR ORDER!

πŸ“ž (516) 378-3455
πŸ“ 1704 Merrick Rd, Merrick, NY
🌐 http://bagelplaza.com

09/14/2026

✨πŸ₯― YOM KIPPUR PACKAGE REMINDER! πŸ₯―✨

Planning your Break-Fast? Don’t wait β€” Wednesday, September 16th is the last day to place your order! πŸ’™

Make your Yom Kippur gathering easy with one of our fresh, beautifully arranged Break-Fast platters:

🐟 DELUXE FISH PLATTER
Hand-sliced nova, sable, baked salmon & filet of whitefish, served with plain, vegetable & scallion cream cheeses, lettuce, olives & cherry tomatoes.
Small (6–8 guests) – $300 | Large (9–12 guests) – $380

πŸ₯— SALAD PLATTER
An assortment of egg, tuna, vegetable tuna, whitefish, baked & poached salmon, beautifully decorated with fresh sliced vegetables.
10–12 guests – $140 | 12–15 guests – $175 | 15–18 guests – $210 | 18–22 guests – $245

πŸ₯’ HEALTHY COMBO PLATTER
Homemade egg salad, vegetable tuna, chunky whitefish, poached salmon, plain & vegetable cream cheese, and thinly hand-sliced nova.
7–10 guests – $269

πŸͺ COOKIE PLATTER
An assortment of gourmet cookies and homemade rugelach β€” the perfect sweet addition to your Break-Fast table.
10–18 guests – $50 | 18–24 guests – $65 | 24–30 guests – $85 | 30–40 guests – $110

πŸ₯― All platters include your choice of Bagels & Bialys.

πŸ“… IMPORTANT YOM KIPPUR DATES
⏰ Order deadline: Wednesday, September 16th
πŸ“¦ Pickup: Sunday, September 20th before 2 PM
🚫 No deliveries will be available during the holiday.

Please note: Due to the overwhelming volume of orders, platters cannot be customized, and there is a $175 minimum on all other orders.

✨ Don’t wait until the last minute β€” call today to reserve your Break-Fast platter!

πŸ“ 1704 Merrick Rd, Merrick, NY
πŸ“ž (516) 378-3455
🌐 bagelplaza.com

🍎🍯 Shana Tova from all of us at Bagel Plaza!As Rosh Hashanah begins tonight, we wish our entire community a happy, healt...
09/11/2026

🍎🍯 Shana Tova from all of us at Bagel Plaza!

As Rosh Hashanah begins tonight, we wish our entire community a happy, healthy and sweet New Year.

We’re grateful and proud to serve the Jewish community for another year and to be part of the traditions and celebrations that bring families together.
May the year ahead be filled with health, happiness, peace and plenty of sweet moments. ❀️

Shana Tova U’Metuka! 🍎🍯πŸ₯―

09/09/2026

✨ Make Your Yom Kippur Break-Fast Easy & Delicious ✨

Planning your Yom Kippur Break-Fast? Let Bagel Plaza help make your gathering a little easier with fresh, beautifully arranged platters made for sharing with family and friends. πŸ₯―

Take a look at four of our popular Break-Fast favorites:
🐟 Deluxe Fish Platter – Hand-sliced nova, sable, baked salmon, and a filet of whitefish, served with plain, vegetable & scallion cream cheeses on a bed of lettuce with olives and cherry tomatoes.
Small (6–8 guests) – $300 | Large (9–12 guests) – $380
πŸ₯— Salad Platter – An assortment of our popular salads, including egg, tuna, vegetable tuna, whitefish, baked & poached salmon, beautifully decorated with fresh sliced vegetables.
10–12 guests – $140 | 12–15 guests – $175 | 15–18 guests – $210 | 18–22 guests – $245
πŸ₯’ Healthy Combo Platter – Homemade egg salad, vegetable tuna, chunky whitefish, poached salmon, plain & vegetable cream cheese, and thinly hand-sliced nova.
7–10 guests – $269
πŸͺ Cookie Platter – An assortment of gourmet cookies and our homemade rugelach, perfect for adding something sweet to your Break-Fast table.
10–18 guests – $50 | 18–24 guests – $65 | 24–30 guests – $85 | 30–40 guests – $110

πŸ₯― All platters include your choice of Bagels & Bialys.

πŸ“… Important Yom Kippur Dates:
The last day to place orders is Wednesday, September 16th.
Pickups are Sunday, September 20th before 2 PM.
🚫 No deliveries will be available during the holiday.

Please note: Due to the overwhelming volume of orders, platters cannot be customized, and there is a $175 minimum on all other orders.

Make your Break-Fast one to remember with Bagel Plaza’s fresh, traditional favorites. Call us today to reserve your platter!

πŸ“ 1704 Merrick Rd, Merrick, NY
πŸ“ž (516) 378-3455
🌐 bagelplaza.com

09/08/2026

Rosh Hashanah is coming! 🍞

Make your holiday table complete with Bagel Plaza’s Round Challah, baked golden brown right on the premises.

Available in Plain, Sesame, Poppy, and Raisin β€” $11 each.

Stop by Bagel Plaza and pick up your Round Challah for Rosh Hashanah!
πŸ“ 1704 Merrick Rd, Merrick, NY
πŸ“ž (516) 378-3455
🌐 bagelplaza.com

09/03/2026

Come taste why Bagel Plaza is the undisputed champion of Long Island Rugelach. πŸ†

When it comes to Rugelach on Long Island, there’s really only one answer: Bagel Plaza. Flaky, sweet, and apparently capable of making people lose all sense of portion control. πŸ˜‚

Stop by Bagel Plaza and grab a dozen (or 14β€”you do you)!
πŸ“ 1704 Merrick Rd, Merrick, NY
πŸ“ž (516) 378-3455
🌐 bagelplaza.com

Address

1704 Merrick Road
Merrick, NY
11566

Opening Hours

Monday 6am - 2pm
Tuesday 6am - 2pm
Wednesday 6am - 2pm
Thursday 6am - 2pm
Friday 6am - 2pm
Saturday 6am - 2pm
Sunday 6am - 2pm

Telephone

+15163783455

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Bagel Plaza posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Bagel Plaza:

Shortcuts

Share