Fish Tales Market and Eatery

Fish Tales Market and Eatery Welcome to Fish Tales Market and Eatery in Marathon, a “local’s favorite” where you will find fresh Seafood, Fish & Steaks, plus homecooked meals.

Fish Tales is the oldest Fish Market & Restaurant in Marathon. Locally, family & veteran owned. take out and curbside pickup available

09/30/2026

🎵Tell us what you want, what you really really want🎶📢

We love being a part of the Marathon community for the past 29 years❤️ and we want Fish Tales Market to have everything you need! 🌊
From fresh seafood🦞🦐🐟 and premium steaks/meats to local treats and pantry staples—what are we missing that you’d love to see on our shelves?

It's almost time to open on MONDAY⏳️
Let us know what you would love to have available this year at the your local Market❔️

Looks like Teter has been put to work!🦴😆Alex and Teter want Fish Tales to open so bad, they are working as a team! 🪟 Lo...
09/27/2026

Looks like Teter has been put to work!🦴

😆Alex and Teter want Fish Tales to open so bad, they are working as a team! 🪟 Looking great guys! 😎

Thank you for making everything perfect for our grand re-opening on Monday, October 5th❤️

The entire team at Fish Tales says:Thank you!Thank you!Thank you!Thank you! See you October 5th ❤️
09/25/2026

The entire team at Fish Tales says:

Thank you!
Thank you!
Thank you!
Thank you!

See you October 5th ❤️

💀🎩 Teter got a little upgrade! 😂Looks like somebody decided he needed a new TETER hat, and honestly… he’s pulling it of...
09/25/2026

💀🎩 Teter got a little upgrade! 😂

Looks like somebody decided he needed a new TETER hat, and honestly… he’s pulling it off. 😎💀

New digs, same old bones. 😂🦴

👀🎩

**WHAT IN THE WORLD IS TETER UP TO?! 😂💀**It all started innocently enough…Back in August, when we closed for our seasona...
09/21/2026

**WHAT IN THE WORLD IS TETER UP TO?! 😂💀**

It all started innocently enough…

Back in August, when we closed for our seasonal shutdown, a customer put a skeleton in a chair out front with a sign that said:

**“Waiting for this place to open in October. I’m already starving.”**

Cute, right? 😂

Well… apparently, our customers weren’t satisfied with just a skeleton.

First came the the clothes. 👕
Then the hat. 🧢
Then the life jacket. 🦺
Then the shoes. 👟
A fishing pole. 🎣
And of course, a b**r 🍺 😂

And somewhere along the way, somebody decided he needed a name…and gave him a hat with the name......

**TETER.**

And just like that, he became a local celebrity. 😂

Every time we turn around, Teter has been given a new accessory, a new outfit, or a whole new personality.

So we figured it was time to share **Teter’s evolution** with everybody!

Swipe through the pictures and watch this hungry fella go from a lonely skeleton waiting on us to reopen… to the best-dressed member of our restaurant family. 😂

And now we have to ask…

**WHAT SHOULD TEETER GET NEXT?!** 👀

Drop your ideas in the comments or feel free to add what you would like. Because at this point, **Teeter belongs to y’all!** ❤️💀

Keep an eye out! As the count down begins...... till opening. As Teter will be doing a count down😂.

😂 Our customers sure are creative! Messages we get from customers.... letting us know October 5th can't get here soon en...
09/20/2026

😂 Our customers sure are creative! Messages we get from customers.... letting us know October 5th can't get here soon enough! We agree😂 See you soon!

"How it feels waiting for October 5th"

🎉 **WE ARE HONORED TO BE NOMINATED FOR 14 CATEGORIES!** 🎉Wow, Marathon — you came through **BIG TIME!** ❤️💙We are incred...
08/24/2026

🎉 **WE ARE HONORED TO BE NOMINATED FOR 14 CATEGORIES!** 🎉

Wow, Marathon — you came through **BIG TIME!** ❤️💙

We are incredibly grateful to our amazing customers, friends, family, and everyone who took the time to nominate **Fish Tales Market & Eatery** for the **Best of Marathon 2026**! 🐟🦞

We’ve been **family owned and operated in Marathon for almost 30 years**, and it means so much to us to have your support year after year. ❤️

Now we need your help again! 🙌
**Please vote for Fish Tales in all 14 categories!**

Every vote means the world to our family and our entire Fish Tales team. Thank you for supporting a local, family-owned business and HELPING US CONTINUE DOING WHAT WE LOVE! ❤️

**THANK YOU, MARATHON!** 🌴🐟🦞

🙌😂 When it's only been 2 weeks & our customers are already dying💀😂. Someone has already starved to death.....We miss you...
08/21/2026

🙌😂 When it's only been 2 weeks & our customers are already dying💀😂.
Someone has already starved to death.....

We miss you & will see you soon❤️

Temporarily Closed 🚫For Our Annual Summer Shutdown/ Vacation ✈️🏖🏕🏝🏞Thanks to all our friends, family & customers for a f...
08/10/2026

Temporarily Closed 🚫For Our Annual Summer Shutdown/ Vacation ✈️🏖🏕🏝🏞

Thanks to all our friends, family & customers for a fantastic season. We will miss you all until we return on Monday,
October 5️⃣

Our annual Oktoberfest 🇩🇪 will be kicking off when we return, as well as our everyday amazing menu. See you soon.

08/07/2026

🚨LAST NIGHT TO HAVE DINNER @ FISH TALES & GET YOUR FILL😎 We are open until 7:30pm & have some amazing Dinner Specials.....

FRESH-MADE TO ORDER: Regular/Decaf Coffee & Espresso
FRESH SQUEEZED LIME-ADE

1/2 # STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $13.95 OR
WHOLE POUND STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $25.95

HOMEMADE FISH SPREAD $14.95
FRESH FRIED GREEN TOMOATOES W/ SIDE JOHNNY DRESSING $12.95
FRIED WISCONSIN CHEESECURDS W/ SIRRACHA MAYO $12.95

NEW: SURFSIDE VODKA ICED TEA- ISLAMORADA CITRUS ALE – TORPEDO IPA -COCONUT KEY LIME ALE -IPA VOODOO RANGER JUICY HAZE - SWEET WATER HAZY IPA NUTRL VODKA SELTZER WATERMELON - NUTRL VODKA SELTZER PINEAPPLE
FAMOSA B**R FROM GUATEMALA

HOMEMADE SOUP & CHOWDERS:
RED CONCH CHOWDER N.E. CLAM CHOWDER CRAWDAD CHOWDER
SIDE CHOICES:
COLESLAW FRENCH FRIES NEW POTATOES POTATO SALAD
GREEN BEANS APPLE SAUCE BLACK BEANS & RICE

SPECIALTY SIDE: PORK COLLARD GREENS $5.95

DINNER SPECIALS
12OZ RIBEYE STEAK PLATTER WITH (5) FRIED SHRIMP & CHOICE OF SIDE $32.95

OUR SMOKED PORK CHOP W/ MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS….. $21.95

HOMEMADE MEATLOAF W/ MASHED POTATO/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS…. $18.95

LIGHTLY FRIED OR GRILLED GROUPER MARSALA WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $24.95
(Fried or Grilled Grouper Topped With Mushroom Gravy Sauce)

GROUPER SANDWICH Grilled OR Blackened & SIDE $21.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE…. $25.95

COBIA FISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $19.95 PLATTER $25.95

SWORDFISH PLATTER Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE… $25.95

JOHNNY SALAD TOPPED w/ OUR PRIME FILET MIGNON TIPS…. $23.95

FRIED GROUPER FINGER PLATTER & SIDE… $21.95

FRIED GREEN TOMATO SNAPPER SANDWICH W/ CHOICE OF SIDE $21.95
(Fried Snapper Topped W/ Fried Green Tomato & Johnny Sauce)

FRIED ROYAL RED SHRIMP PLATTER & SIDE… $19.95

BUFFALO SHRIMP WRAP WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $19.95

SHRIMP PO BOY WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $18.95
(Fried Shrimp, Topped With Coleslaw On A Hoagie Roll)

STEAK NIGHT!!!
16 OZ RIBEYE STEAK PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE…. $34.95

8OZ PRIME FILET MIGNON STEAK & CHOICE OF SIDE… $39.95

WAGYU BURGER Topped W/ Maple Bacon Jam & Blue Cheese Sauce & SIDE… $18.95

HOGFISH SANDWICH Grilled, Blackened OR Fried & SIDE $21.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE.... $25.95

HOMEMADE SHRIMP BURGER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE… $19.95

FRESH BAKED COOKIES: CHOCOLATE CHIP or SAMOA

STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE A LA MODE
CHOCOLATE CREAM PIE
BANANA CREAM PIE
JOHNNY’S HOMEMADE KEY LIME PIE

GERMAN B**RS ON TAP
Paulaner Hefeweizen Erdinger Dunkel Hacker Pschorr Oktoberfest

B**RS ON TAP
Coors Light Draft Iguana Bait Yuengling

PINOT GRIGIO CHARDONNAY CABERNET

MOSCATO WHITE ZINFINDEL

Address

11711 Overseas Highway
Marathon, FL
33050

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 7:30pm
Tuesday 11am - 7:30pm
Wednesday 11am - 7:30pm
Thursday 11am - 7:30pm
Friday 11am - 7:30pm
Saturday 11am - 3pm

Telephone

+13057439196

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Fish Tales Market and Eatery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Fish Tales Market and Eatery:

Shortcuts

Share

Category