Salvatore’s Tomato Pies- Livingston

Salvatore’s Tomato Pies- Livingston Casual & modern Farm-to-Table restaurant/bar in downtown Madison, specializing in brick oven Trenton, NJ style pizza & locally-sourced dishes. Why Salvatore's?

Reservations, walk-ins, takeout, delivery, catering, groups up to 12, and kid-friendly. What makes a "Tomato Pie" different? It's pizza rooted in Chambersburg, Trenton, NJ's Little Italy, and it is made "backwards". There's less cheese, a bit of char, and crunch while retaining a good chew, and scratch-made sauce swirled on top. This is how pizzas were made when my family immigrated to the United States, before they were adulterated by large commercial pizza chains using heavily processed ingredients. Though the style comes from Trenton, our pizzas are made with as many locally sourced ingredients as possible. Many of our specials revolve around items we find at farmers markets, or what is available in season. Unfortunately, the phrase "We use the finest ingredients" has become so over-used it is nearly meaningless. The best ingredients don't come off the back of a Sysco truck from Mexico. We also have a rotating inventory of locally brewed craft b**r. Italian food has always been local in nature. This is why there are so many regional variations around the country. When Italians came to the United States, they used what was available locally to make things that seemed familiar. My hometown was once redolent with storefronts proudly displaying neon signs reading "Tomato Pies". Legend has it that the word Pizza supplanted "Tomato Pies" simply because it was less expensive to produce the signs with fewer letters. Trenton is still home to the oldest continually operating Tomato Pie (Pizza) Joint in the country. We're bringing Salvatore's Tomato Pies to life to celebrate the old traditions and share them with a new generation. It is the name of my 4-year-old son. This restaurant is about creating something tangible for him while honoring my family history. Our tomato pies are created by drawing upon my upbringing in an Italian-American home, where good food was always the centerpiece of every family gathering.

Fall is on the horizon, and with it, our features. This week, treat yourself to our featured shared plate; fried Garden ...
09/11/2026

Fall is on the horizon, and with it, our features. This week, treat yourself to our featured shared plate; fried Garden to Be Brussel sprouts, crispy panchetta, bleu cheese, a maple Dijon vinaigrette, topped with fresh Home Grown microgreens. Then settle into a beautiful late summer pie; it gets mozzarella, Vitruvian Farm kale, roasted Keewayden Farm delicata and red kuri squash, topped with a beet and pepita pesto, and fresh chèvre. Try them alongside a glass of w**e on our all new all Italian w**e list! ̀vre 🍁 **e **e **elovers🇮🇹🍷❤️ **etasting **elover **es

We have some excellent seasonal features on offer this week. Peaches and Melons are peak at the Farmers Market right now...
08/28/2026

We have some excellent seasonal features on offer this week. Peaches and Melons are peak at the Farmers Market right now, and we have some great Farmers Market veggies to show off as well. Check out our Grilled Peach Bruschetta, or the Peach Pie (it’s a pizza) both highlighting Door County peaches from Barnard Farms. Looking for pasta? We give you Bucatini with Romesco featuring fresh eggplant from Squashington Farm. Take a trip to Italy with our Melon and Prosciutto featuring a melange of melons from Olden Organics and Alsum Farm. Wash it all down with a Mezcal Peach Smash! ‼️

Salvatore’s on Livingston will be closed tonight 8/25 for a private event. We will reopen tomorrow at 4pm!
08/25/2026

Salvatore’s on Livingston will be closed tonight 8/25 for a private event. We will reopen tomorrow at 4pm!

Wednesday Night is Date Night at Salvatore’s on Livingston. You’ll share an appetizer, an entree or 16” pie, a bottle of...
08/12/2026

Wednesday Night is Date Night at Salvatore’s on Livingston. You’ll share an appetizer, an entree or 16” pie, a bottle of white or red house w**e, and dessert, and it’s just $60 bucks. ♥️ ♥️ 🍕 **etime **eoclock **etasting **elover

Are you ready for more live music at Breese Stevens Field? To celebrate some of the upcoming concerts coming to our neig...
08/04/2026

Are you ready for more live music at Breese Stevens Field? To celebrate some of the upcoming concerts coming to our neighborhood, we’ve teamed up with @ fpclive to treat one lucky winner to a dinner & a show prize pack.

🎶 Like this post, tag + share with your concert buddy

🎤 share and Follow Salvatore's Tomato Pies, FPC Live, and Breese Stevens Field

➡️ Winner will be chosen 8/7 for 🎟️ 2 GA tickets to see Train with Ba*****ed Ladies and Matt Nathanson on Aug 8

🍕

We call it ¡Holé Olé! Our featured pie gets mozzarella, Colby, chorizo, roasted Alsum sweet corn and fingerlings, and ho...
08/01/2026

We call it ¡Holé Olé! Our featured pie gets mozzarella, Colby, chorizo, roasted Alsum sweet corn and fingerlings, and house pickled onions and jalapeños, then it’s topped with chipotle aioli and cilantro. 🍕

Welcome to the weekend! We’ve got some excellent features lined up for you. Come check out our Calabrese Sweet Corn; gri...
07/24/2026

Welcome to the weekend! We’ve got some excellent features lined up for you. Come check out our Calabrese Sweet Corn; grilled Alsum sweet corn, Calabrese butter, Hooks 2 year cheddar, onion ash salt, and Calabrese peppers. We have another awesome featured shared plate; fresh burrata and blueberries, with grilled Stalzy’s bread. There’s a featured pie too, sautéed shrimp, bacon, Alsum sweet corn (noticing a theme here?!) hot pepper melange, and truffle oil.

I hope your lover looks at your the the way we’re looking at this spread. Two delicious shared plates; our Campari stick...
07/17/2026

I hope your lover looks at your the the way we’re looking at this spread. Two delicious shared plates; our Campari sticky ribs, and our featured garlic Parmesan fried dough balls. The pizza is a classic, Sal’s Supreme. Make us a part of your weekend itinerary! 10 N. Livingston. order online
www.salvatorestomatopies.com

Chef Patrick put this seasonal  burrata together just for you. Creamy Burrata with strawberries, two ways- Cooked down a...
06/19/2026

Chef Patrick put this seasonal burrata together just for you.

Creamy Burrata with strawberries, two ways- Cooked down and jammy with honey and balsamic, and topped with fresh marinated greenbarnfarmmarket strawberries, fresh basil, evoo. Grilled Stalzys bread.

It’s great to share! Available starting Saturday while strawberries are in season.

After days of rain and terrible weather, come celebrate nice summer weather on the patio with us!  fresh ingredients fro...
06/12/2026

After days of rain and terrible weather, come celebrate nice summer weather on the patio with us! fresh ingredients from Wisconsin family farms, fun plates to share, and craft pizza. What’s more to like?

See you soon.

Address

10 N Livingston Street, Ste 101
Madison, WI
53703

Opening Hours

Tuesday 4pm - 9pm
Wednesday 4pm - 9pm
Thursday 4pm - 9pm
Friday 4pm - 10pm
Saturday 11am - 10pm
Sunday 4pm - 9pm

Telephone

+16083058885

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Salvatore’s Tomato Pies- Livingston posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share