Goodfellas Pizzeria

Goodfellas Pizzeria Late-night NY-style pizza & hidden bourbon speakeasy with rare whiskey flights in KY, IN, OH, and TN! Goodfellas has been serving pizza by the slice since 2005.

Our pizza is gigantic, 22 inches, serving a true New York style pizza by the slice. Our dough is made fresh daily, hand tossed and baked off on the stone. Entertaining our guests is part of our service, tossing the dough and performing dough tricks to great energetic music is always a crowd pleaser. We are Late Night Pizza ROCKSTARS ! Stop by late night and see why! Locations in Kentucky, Ohio, Indiana, Tennessee, & More to come!

07/13/2026

Much better. 🙂‍↕️🍕 1/2 off 12" pies every Monday.

Music City, your next slice is waiting. 🍕🎸
07/13/2026

Music City, your next slice is waiting. 🍕🎸

One's a classic. One's got a kick. Which side are you on? 👇
07/09/2026

One's a classic. One's got a kick.
Which side are you on? 👇

A pairing that never misses. 🍕🥃 Join us every Wednesday for $5 Old Fashioneds. Wiseguy Lounge
07/08/2026

A pairing that never misses. 🍕🥃 Join us every Wednesday for $5 Old Fashioneds. Wiseguy Lounge

07/08/2026

What's the first thing you order every single time?

We've seen the headlines, so let's clear the air. Goodfellas isn't leaving downtown Lexington.After 20 incredible years ...
07/06/2026

We've seen the headlines, so let's clear the air. Goodfellas isn't leaving downtown Lexington.

After 20 incredible years on Mill Street, we’re moving just around the corner to a new home that gives us something you've been asking for for years.

🍕 A full dining room with plenty of seating.
🥃 A hidden Wiseguy Lounge downstairs.
❤️ The same New York-style pizza that's been part of Lexington since 2006.

Mill Street has been more than an address. It's where Goodfellas was born. It's where countless late nights, first dates, celebrations, and giant slices became part of Lexington's story. We couldn't have done any of it without this community, and we're incredibly grateful for the last 20 years.

Now it's time for the next chapter. Here's your first sneak peek at what's to come. We can't wait to share more as construction moves along.

Lexington, thank you for growing with us. Stay tuned... we've got something special cooking. 🍕

The reception called. It wanted pizza. 🍕Congratulations to the happy couple, and thanks for letting Goodfellas be part o...
07/02/2026

The reception called. It wanted pizza. 🍕

Congratulations to the happy couple, and thanks for letting Goodfellas be part of your big day. Giant slices, happy guests, and one less thing to worry about. That's what we're here for.

Due to a power issue, Mainstrasse will be closed until it's restored. We apologize for the inconvenience and look forwar...
07/02/2026

Due to a power issue, Mainstrasse will be closed until it's restored. We apologize for the inconvenience and look forward to serving you hot slices and cold pours again soon!

07/02/2026

Holiday weekend forecast: Pizza, patio, repeat. 🇺🇸🍕

Address

110 North Mill Street
Lexington, KY
40507

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 10pm
Tuesday 11am - 10pm
Wednesday 11am - 10pm
Thursday 11am - 1am
Friday 11am - 3am
Saturday 11am - 3am
Sunday 11am - 10pm

Website

,

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Goodfellas Pizzeria posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category