Sugarwitch Ice Cream Sandwiches

Sugarwitch Ice Cream Sandwiches We make small-batch, from-scratch ice cream sandwiches & novelties in historic Carondelet, STL!
(1)

Find us us in historic Carondelet Friday-Monday for ice cream, coffee, and more!

Morning brew ☕️ with a side of ice cream? I mean, we do it all the time 😏 but why not have it all in one? That’s what Pr...
06/13/2026

Morning brew ☕️ with a side of ice cream? I mean, we do it all the time 😏 but why not have it all in one? That’s what Priya’s for!

cold brew IC (studded with crunchy toffee pieces) + a toffee brownie, Priya is a summer favorite of ours: it’s the ultimate cool down/perk up ‘witch! 🌞🤸‍♀️

And if you’re looking for a gentle start to your Saturday, we’ve got a Raspberry Cream London Fog with your name on it.🪻💞🫖 Available at the cafe starting at 9 am, pick-up or delivery!

Look out, here comes the MINT MONSTER 👹🌱🍫🤪🌈 Congrats to Noa, the winner of our &joystl design-a-‘witch contest! This ra...
06/12/2026

Look out, here comes the MINT MONSTER 👹🌱🍫🤪🌈

Congrats to Noa, the winner of our &joystl design-a-‘witch contest! This rainbow sprinkle, mint IC, and M&M brownie ‘witch is available
💚 this weekend only 💚 at the cafe, so come unleash your inner ice cream beast 😛🍦and sink your teeth into this one, while it lasts!

PS: a big thanks to ALL of the wonderful young people who entered our contest 🎨💛 and to our Sugarwitch Tracy for making the magic happen at our tent + choosing our winning ‘witch! 🪄And a BIG shout-out to the incredible Pride & Joy team that make this event a reality—we’re already counting down the days ’til next year! 🦄

Summer heat, seasonal fruit, and a one-of-a-kind ‘witch. It’s time for The Weird Sisters! 🤎🩷🤍TWS sold out last week, and...
06/11/2026

Summer heat, seasonal fruit, and a one-of-a-kind ‘witch. It’s time for The Weird Sisters! 🤎🩷🤍

TWS sold out last week, and it’s not hard to see why if ya swipe 😍 Made with loads of local strawberries 🍓🍓🍓 (& a lil sour cream 🤏) and sandwiched between our chewy blondie and fudgy brownie, our take on a neopolitan is built different 🌀 ‘cause it’s simply built better! 💁✨

Try it out this weekend 🧙‍♀️🍫🧙‍♀️🎀🧙‍♀️❕alongside the rest of our June menu. We’re restocked and ready for another weekend with you! 🌈💖

Introducing… ✈️🏝️☀️The Sugarwitch Summer Passport! Since we’re out and about just SO much this summer, we’ve decided to...
06/09/2026

Introducing… ✈️🏝️☀️The Sugarwitch Summer Passport!

Since we’re out and about just SO much this summer, we’ve decided to roll out a fun little incentive 🤭 to see more of you witches, eat more ice cream, and *gasp* get a FREE URSULA PIN ??? 🫨🪼🪸🌊🍭🫧

Simply visit us for a treat at all 5 of these spots, and be sure to get a stamp when you do! (We have cards available for pick-up at each location!) ➡️➡️

-Tuesday Tower Grove Farmers' Market (which just so happens to be going on right now 👀)
-Saturday TGFM
-a Sunday Market The Boulevard Farmers' Market (next one is 6/21)
-an event (catch us at Green Living Fest at the Missouri Botanical Garden on July 11th!)
-AND the cafe, of course! 😋

The last Tuesday Market of the season is September 29th, so you have until then to get your passport fully stamped! ⭐️😊🛩️ Then just swing by the shop to show off your completed card and get your pin!! 🧜 Happy travels!

Your Voice, Your Choice 📣🗳️ There’s only 8 days left to VOTE GAY ICE CREAM THIS PRIDE SEASON! 🦄🍨🌈🍦🏳️‍⚧️ We’re counting o...
06/09/2026

Your Voice, Your Choice 📣🗳️ There’s only 8 days left to VOTE GAY ICE CREAM THIS PRIDE SEASON! 🦄🍨🌈🍦🏳️‍⚧️

We’re counting on YOU 🫵 to Build a Brighter Tomorrow 🪩 (…filled with rainbows and glitter and iced coffee and cute lil treats 💖) by setting your phone alarm to vote DAILY (😅 lol we know) for St. Louis Magazine’s A-List 🥇🍦🌟

And hey, we know it’s a long shot, but… how bananas would it be if we won? 🧙‍♀️😝🫶

FINE . . . we made dot cake 😝🙄🥳 We love switching up our trifle flavors, and rainbow sprinkles are *kind of* our thing 💁...
06/07/2026

FINE . . . we made dot cake 😝🙄🥳

We love switching up our trifle flavors, and rainbow sprinkles are *kind of* our thing 💁🌈 so we had to give it a go! Check out that layering action ➡️ and come give these a taste today from 1-8pm today! 🍰🥄🌀

(PS: Catch us at The Boulevard today with cold brew & ‘witches from 9-1! 👋)

You could say we have an OBSESSION with pistachio 🫣 and you’d be right. Pistachio Charm Bars are back, and they’re so g...
06/06/2026

You could say we have an OBSESSION with pistachio 🫣 and you’d be right.

Pistachio Charm Bars are back, and they’re so good, you might wish for them to never leave the shop EVER again 😮‍💨 but be careful what you wish for… 👀

Also returning: Van Stachio cookies!!! And a new Bev: our Pistachio Raspberry Latte 🌸 Don’t let them get away without trying them this month! 😉❌🚪

Whoops, sorry—dunno what came over us!! Anyways 😅 we’ve peeled the duct tape off the door and it’s wide open for ya until 10 😚 love ya! 💚💚💚

🍓🏵️🥭 ROYGBIV 🥑🌀🍇 Strawberry saffron + mango dahi scoops, blue spirulina meringues, toasted pistachios, purple coneflower...
06/05/2026

🍓🏵️🥭 ROYGBIV 🥑🌀🍇

Strawberry saffron + mango dahi scoops, blue spirulina meringues, toasted pistachios, purple coneflowers + marigold sugar, and blackberry whip. 🌈🍨☀️ Fruity, light, and perfectly refreshing for this hot & humid Friday!

Available all June long! Come taste the rainbow 🦄 from 3-10 tonight!

Oops, looks like we dropped something 🍒🥭🥝🫐🍇🍉… dw, it’s only our JUNE MENU!!!!! Keeping it colorful with Saffy 💜 zesty wi...
06/04/2026

Oops, looks like we dropped something 🍒🥭🥝🫐🍇🍉… dw, it’s only our JUNE MENU!!!!!

Keeping it colorful with Saffy 💜 zesty with Howl 🍋‍🟩 caffeinated with our cold brew Priya ☕️ and seasonal with local strawberries in The Weird Sisters 🍓🍓🍓 All hail the Churro Queen Cone 👑 and DUH, we’re going for maximum 🌈rainbow🌈 with our Funfetti Taco & our ROYGBIV Sundae (pics dropping soon! 🤭)

Trying to get fresh and fruity with us this weekend? Then order ahead while these bbs are ripe for the picking 🫳🍦🌳 We’re restocked and ready for you tmr!!

You know summer’s finally here when the menu update starts looking like 🫣➡️It’s the last day for our May Menu, and we’re...
05/31/2026

You know summer’s finally here when the menu update starts looking like 🫣➡️

It’s the last day for our May Menu, and we’re nearly out of our seasonal ‘witches!! 😵 We’ve got a smidge of our banana-caramel & gingersnap Candeloro left in our freezers, alongside BOTH our seasonal waffles 🐝🍓 and alllll your core favorites 🙂‍↕️🧙‍♀️💫

Add in our May bevs, and you’ve got plenty of tasty reasons to stop by this Sunday 😋🩵🩷 Open from 1-8!

Address

7726 Virginia Avenue
Lemay, MO
63111

Opening Hours

Thursday 3pm - 10pm
Friday 3pm - 10pm
Saturday 9am - 10pm
Sunday 1pm - 8pm

Telephone

+15732340042

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sugarwitch Ice Cream Sandwiches posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Sugarwitch Ice Cream Sandwiches:

Shortcuts

Share

Category