Big Papa's Creamery

06/16/2026

America's 250th Anniversary deserves a celebration to remember! Join us July 2–4 for Lancaster's Independence Day Carnival featuring live entertainment, carnival rides, games, delicious food vendors, family-friendly fun, and more. ✨🎡

📆 July 2-4, 2026
🕙 Various Times
📍 W Main St & Cayuga Creek Park

Gather your friends and neighbors as we celebrate 250 years of freedom, community, and American spirit right here in the Village of Lancaster. It's a hometown tradition you won't want to miss! 🎆🎠

06/16/2026

06/15/2026

🎉🍦 HAPPY BIRTHDAY BIG PAPA🍦🎉

Kole is the man behind the flavors, smiles and everything that is Big Papa’s Creamery. Today we’re celebrating him the best way possible - making ice cream & scooping 2 private events. Please join us in wishing him the Happiest Birthday!

His pick - 2 scoops of Pineapple Upside Down in a waffle cone

06/13/2026

Say hello to our first sorbet’s of the season 🥳

🌟 BLUE RASPBERRY 🌟

🌟STRAWBERRY WATERMELON 🌟

All natural & made with fresh fruit puree - this refreshing treat is the perfect way to cool down on a hot summer day

06/12/2026

Goin’ crazy for cookies over here - introducing 3 new flavors to our lineup:

🍪 PB COOKIE MONSTER
- our signature peanut butter base with Oreos & globs of our homemade cookie dough folded in

🍪 SALTY COOKIE
- Salted Caramel Crunch meets Cookies & Cream. Two fan faves mixed together.

🍪 OREO CHEESECAKE
- our signature cheesecake base with cookies & cream swirled in

Get a large & try all 3 - on a homemade waffle cone of course 💁🏼‍♀️

See ya soon! 🍦🩵✨

06/07/2026

The moment everyone has been waiting for!! We picked the giveaway winners - We had over 600 entries - crazy!! All winners have been contacted - congratulations & thank you for all your support! 🫶🏻🍦🩵

06/07/2026

A huge ✨ THANK YOU ✨ to everyone who came out to celebrate our shops 1st birthday yesterday! We’re blown away with the amount of people who showed up to party with us! This past year has flown by and we are so grateful to be apart of such an amazing community. Year 1 down - many more to come! 🫶🏻🍦🩵

06/06/2026

Food & Drink

06/06/2026

06/06/2026

‼️‼️‼️ TODAYS THE DAY ‼️‼️‼️

Happy 1 year to us! Crazy how fast time flies when you’re living your dream 🥹

We’re celebrating all day with the following deals:

🍦 $1 CONE / DISH

🍦B2G1 COOKIE SANDWICHES

🍦 RAFFLE FOR FREE ICE CREAM FOR THE REMAINDER OF THE 2026 SEASON

🍦 FREE T-SHIRT GIVEAWAYS

We’ll be open noon - 10pm today
(or until we sell out 😉)

Please note - limit 1 cone per person. $1 cone/dish promo is standard 1 scoop. Waffle cones, toppings & additional scoops will be an extra charge. Dairy free IS included in promo. ☺️

Cheers to 1 year! 🫶🏻🍦🩵

See ya soon!!