Lake Geneva Pie Co

Lake Geneva Pie Co Homemade pies and other goodies just like grandma used to make. Family owned and operated. Est 2001. We are serving soup and quiches daily.

Call for orders/questions 262.248.5100.
72 hours or more for orders
Lgpie.com
Mon, Tues, Thur, Fri 6:30AM-6:00PM
Sat 6:30AM-3:00PM
Closed Wed & Sun We also have a selection of fruit pies, cream pies, cheesecakes, AMAZING key lime pie as well as baked goodies including cookies, brownies, muffins and snack breads. Seasonal items subject to change.

Today we have vegetable beef barley soup.
07/18/2026

Today we have vegetable beef barley soup.

We know how much you all love our cookies! So we wanted to try something new! Butterscotch Oatmeal Cookies! We’re offeri...
07/17/2026

We know how much you all love our cookies! So we wanted to try something new!

Butterscotch Oatmeal Cookies!

We’re offering them in our Take & Bake option ONLY, until supplies last!

Stop in and pick some up now!

Call the shop with any inquiries; (262) 248-5100

With how hot it’s been who wouldn’t want a cold smoothie to cool them down! We have different flavored smoothies mixes f...
07/16/2026

With how hot it’s been who wouldn’t want a cold smoothie to cool them down! We have different flavored smoothies mixes for you to take home! All you need to do is add some ice, a little water or a little somethin somethin, mix and blend, then BOOM delicious smoothie!

Call the shop with any inquiries; (262) 248-5100

07/16/2026

Today we have minestrone soup.

Back in stock our 4” Sample platters! This time including; French Silk, Plain Cheesecake, Chocolate Chip Cheesecake and ...
07/14/2026

Back in stock our 4” Sample platters! This time including; French Silk, Plain Cheesecake, Chocolate Chip Cheesecake and our Famous Key Lime!!

Stop in to pick one up today! Perfect treat for the family! Either try them all or have your own individual dessert!

Call the shop with any inquiries; (262) 248-5100

Spotlight drink of the week! A blue raspberry lemonade!!Call the shop with any inquiries; (262) 248-5100
07/14/2026

Spotlight drink of the week! A blue raspberry lemonade!!

Call the shop with any inquiries; (262) 248-5100

Today we have chicken noodle soup.
07/13/2026

Today we have chicken noodle soup.

Today we have broccoli cheddar soup.
07/09/2026

Today we have broccoli cheddar soup.

Drink Spotlight of the week! A dirty chai tea! Call the shop with any questions or concerns (262) 248-5100
07/07/2026

Drink Spotlight of the week! A dirty chai tea!

Call the shop with any questions or concerns (262) 248-5100

Address

150 E Geneva Square
Lake Geneva, WI
53147

Telephone

+12622485100

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Lake Geneva Pie Co posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category