Mattheessen's

Mattheessen's Family-owned dessert parlor here in the heart of Key West. Giant cookies, homemade key lime pie, and delicious, high-quality ice cream. Giant cookies. Fudge.
(543)

Colorful trays of fresh, delicious ice cream. Coffee. Key Lime Pie. All those tasty treats and more await within the doors of Mattheesen’s. Founded in 1993, our family owned and operated parlor has three locations here in Key West. With fresh, quality ingredients, and a passion for everything we bake, there’s no wrong choice from our case of concoctions. We offer up a family-friendly atmosphere, and are also open late for when midnight cravings hit. Homemade. Fresh. Delicious.

02/04/2026
Whole pies in stock for Thanksgiving at all three Key West locations and Nashville!
11/25/2025

Whole pies in stock for Thanksgiving at all three Key West locations and Nashville!

06/03/2025

Mattheessens is a family owned business in Key West for the past 32 years. They have supported many local charities and fundraisers for many years. Please consider voting for them in this year’s Bubba Awards. .com

Qualifying categories include:
Best Key Lime Pie
Best Ice Cream
Best Desserts
Best Family Owned Business
Thank you! 🍪🍦❤️

Address

419 Duval Street
Key West, FL
33040

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 12am
Tuesday 9am - 12am
Wednesday 9am - 12am
Thursday 9am - 12am
Friday 9am - 12am
Saturday 9am - 12am
Sunday 9am - 12am

Telephone

+13059235418

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Mattheessen's posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Mattheessen's:

Shortcuts

Share