Libby's Gourmet Ice Cream

Libby's Gourmet Ice Cream Home made ice cream made right in our shop using our own recipes. Matt Sanders has been making homemade ice cream since he was 14 years old.
(632)

He began making the ice cream with his father, Jim Sanders, for family get togethers. Over the years Matt has perfected his own recipe. No internet searches, no cookbook recipe, this is his own delicious creation. To date Matt (and Libby) have 30 different flavors of ice cream to offer with more being developed. We offer sweet and savory, gourmet ice creams.

09/17/2021

Hello, everybody!
It’s been a couple years since I abruptly closed the shop. This will be a long post. But, if you stick with it and read it all, I think you’ll like the ending.
I have suffered from mental illness for most of my 42 years of life. Childhood trauma and abuse created a sickness in me that had destroyed much of who I was as a person. I have spent the last 2 years trying to heal and repair my broken sanity. I thank my wife so much for allowing me to do so. It’s because of her, because of her love and support, that I haven’t long left this wretched earth.
I love my wife. Not because I want to. No, because I’m compelled to. Forced like the tides to rise with the moon. I cannot stop loving her any more than breathing; and you can only hold your breath for so long.
This love, this true and absolute love that I now know exists, far outshines what I thought love was before.
With my newfound knowledge of love I compared it to John 3:16, and really, all of the book of John whether the Apostle or Lennon.
And Love is all you need.
God IS love. Jesus says he loves us, the Bible tells me so. I believe it’s impossible for the pure and perfect love of God, Who died for us while we were yet sinners, to conditionally condemn us afterwards. My imperfect love for my wife still allows for her to be her. Not judge her or her choices but accept her as she is. An individual living her own life with her own problems. Things that I could never understand but accept anyhow. I have to after all. How can I not? Like me, love compels her to offer me the same forgiveness, gives her the same sense of wholeness and rightness that I feel. How easy it would be if we all followed a God of love like that. Or even just set our minds to do it, whether by faith or just because we exist as humans together. To not condemn one another for their beliefs or lack thereof. To be excited to see others in love no matter who or what they are. I know there are millions out there who know love like ours and all over the world. We are all human. We all break. We all bleed. The triggers may not be the same, nor the intensity the same degree. But pain is pain. Sad is sad. Fear is fear. Lonely is lonely. And love is love. If we all hurt the same then why is it so hard to to not love each other the same way we wish we were loved ourselves? Knowing full well how grateful I am of my wife’s acceptance of my broken self, I cannot and will not follow a God who does not love. I believe any true God will love anyone who also loves all others. It is, after all, the greatest commandment sayeth the Lord. I’m just a 42 year old broken human; broken like the rest of you as we all have our battles and demons. Seeing as there are around 10k of you who like this page, imagine if just this group loved everyone for who they were and stopped judging. Imagine what it would feel like to have 10k people accept you for you. No strings attached. What a world we would have if every single human loved each other. The unabashed love and acceptance of my wonderful wife, just one person, is almost unbearable. I can’t fathom a whole planet loving me. But I’m willing to give the world a try.
I love you all and I appreciated your support of our little shop. I know this wasn’t an answer to what happened to Libby’s Ice Cream, but I leave you with this…My own personal recipe to make in your own home and share with those around you. Yep, the exact same frozen milk you enjoyed in downtown Jasper.
It is a gift freely given and I really hope you enjoy.
Have an awesome day!!
-Matt

4-cups sugar
4 1/2- tsp vanilla
1/2- tsp salt
2- 12 oz cans of evaporated milk
1- quart of heavy whipping cream
1/2- gallon of milk
8- 8 eggs (use pasteurized eggs if you’d like to be safe)

Mix it all together then freeze!!

Pro tip: whisk the eggs first and they’ll blend better as you add the rest of the ingredients.

Happy Hour!!!!Today from 3:00-5:00 we will be having our Happy Hour! Buy 2 pints get 1 free, buy 4 pints get 2 free, etc...
02/03/2019

Happy Hour!!!!
Today from 3:00-5:00 we will be having our Happy Hour!
Buy 2 pints get 1 free, buy 4 pints get 2 free, etc etc !!!!!

We will be closing early today, 5:00pm, so that our awesome staff can spend time with family and friends.

Today’s flavors are:

Butter Pecan
Cookies nCream
Black n Tan
Banana Pudding
Mint Chocolate Chip
Birthday Cake
Cookie Dough
Cookie Monster
Coconut
Work In Progress
Cool Beans
Strawberry
Chocolate
Vanilla
Lactose Free Coconut

Go sports teams!! 🥴

Gift Card Sale!!!Today pick up $25 in gift cards for only $20. Spend $40 and get $50etc etc!!  Also my favorite holiday ...
11/24/2018

Gift Card Sale!!!
Today pick up $25 in gift cards for only $20. Spend $40 and get $50etc etc!!

Also my favorite holiday flavor, Rum Raisin is out today as well!! :))

Pumpkin freshly made and ready today!! 🎃
10/20/2018

Pumpkin freshly made and ready today!! 🎃

!!HAPPY HOUR!!Today from 3:00-5:00pm but 2 pints get 1 FREE!!Today’s flavors are:Red VelvetVanillaCherry CordialChocolat...
09/08/2018

!!HAPPY HOUR!!

Today from 3:00-5:00pm but 2 pints get 1 FREE!!

Today’s flavors are:
Red Velvet
Vanilla
Cherry Cordial
Chocolate
Banana Pudding
Rainbow Sherbet
Pistachio
Cinnamon Roll
Root Beer Float
Birthday Cake
Mad Batter
Strawberry
Cookie Monster
Cookie Dough
Black N Tab
Dill Pickle
Butter Pecan
Java Chip
Candy Grape
Mint Chocolate Chip
Lemonade
Fruity Pebbles
Cookies n Cream
Maple Bacon
Grasshopper

Enjoy the day!!!!! 😍😍

Today’s home made flavors are:Vanilla Chocolate Cherry CordialRoot Beer FloatCinnamon RollBirthday CakeStrawberry Cookie...
08/30/2018

Today’s home made flavors are:
Vanilla
Chocolate
Cherry Cordial
Root Beer Float
Cinnamon Roll
Birthday Cake
Strawberry
Cookie Monster
Mad Batter
Cookie Dough
Black n Tan
Dill Pickle
Grass Hopper
Butter Pecan
Candy Grape
Lemonade
Fruity Pebbles
Mint Chocolate Chip
Work In Progress
Cookies n Cream
Coconut
Pistachio

Have an amazing day!!!! 😍😍

I wonder. I eat.

German Chocolate Cake is out today!!In case you were wondering. 😉🇩🇪 🇩🇪 🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪Today’s other flavors:Vanilla R...
08/01/2018

German Chocolate Cake is out today!!
In case you were wondering. 😉
🇩🇪 🇩🇪 🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪

Today’s other flavors:
Vanilla
Rainbow sherbert
Chocolate
Baked beans
Caramel latte
Cherry cordial
Cinnamon roll
Birthday cake
Cookie dough
Birthday cake
Mint chocolate chip
Nutter butter
Dill pickle
Grasshopper
Peach
Butter pecan
Black n tan
Fruity pebbles
Work in progress
Blue ribbon blonde
Cool beans
Dreamsicle
Cookies n cream
Strawberry

Pickle Ice Cream!!It’s been years since I’ve made and honestly it’s been the most requested flavor that I wouldn’t make ...
07/27/2018

Pickle Ice Cream!!
It’s been years since I’ve made and honestly it’s been the most requested flavor that I wouldn’t make again. 😂

Today’s other homemade flavors are:
Nutter Butter
Rainbow sherbert
Vanilla
Chocolate
Mad batter
Baked beans
Cherry cordial
Cinnamon roll
Birthday cake
Blue ribbon blonde
Cookie Monster
Peach
Popcorn
Dill pickle
Grass hopper
Butter pecan
Banana pudding
Black n tan
Fruity pebbles
Work in progress
Dreamsicle
Cookies n cream
Rice Krispie treats
Cool beans
Strawberry

Peach Ice Cream!!This is one of my personal favorites and definitely my favorite fruit flavored ice cream!I can only buy...
07/14/2018

Peach Ice Cream!!

This is one of my personal favorites and definitely my favorite fruit flavored ice cream!

I can only buy these fresh peaches from The Produce Patch for a limited time so come get it while it’s cold!!

Rice Krispie Treat and Blue Ribbon Blondie ice creams are here today!!Also out on this gorgeous day are:Rainbow sherbert...
07/13/2018

Rice Krispie Treat and Blue Ribbon Blondie ice creams are here today!!

Also out on this gorgeous day are:
Rainbow sherbert
Vanilla
Chocolate
Mad batter
Baked beans
Cinnamon roll
Cherry cordial
Blue ribbon blonde
Birthday cake
Cookies n cream
Cookie Monster
Popcorn
Root beer float
Cookie dough
Grasshopper
Butter pecan
Mint chocolate chip
Banana pudding
Work in progress
Coconut
Rice Krispie treats
Key lime pie
Cool beans
Black n tan
Strawberry
SUGAR FREE Johnny Cashew
DAIRY FREE Johnny Cashew

Happy Independence Day!! 🇺🇸🇺🇸Yesterday the winners of a Habitat For Humanity charitable auction designed, created, and n...
07/04/2018

Happy Independence Day!! 🇺🇸🇺🇸

Yesterday the winners of a Habitat For Humanity charitable auction designed, created, and named their very own flavor. Come and try their creation “Flipping Delish” which is strawberry and pineapple.

We are open today until 5:00.
Have a fun and safe day!!

Ahhh how we missed the smell of freshly baked waffles!!Chocolate and Vanilla Waffle Bowls are now available!!Also out to...
07/01/2018

Ahhh how we missed the smell of freshly baked waffles!!

Chocolate and Vanilla Waffle Bowls are now available!!

Also out today are Banana Pudding, Key Lime Pie, and Fruity Pebbles ice creams. 😎
Enjoy your Sunday!!

Address

609 Main Street
Jasper, IN
47546

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 9pm
Tuesday 11am - 9pm
Wednesday 11am - 9pm
Thursday 11am - 9pm
Friday 11am - 11pm
Saturday 11am - 11pm
Sunday 12pm - 9pm

Telephone

+18124812025

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Libby's Gourmet Ice Cream posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share

Category