TeeJay’s Sweet Tooth

03/22/2025

We will be open today DRIVE THRU ONLY 3pm-8pm (while supplies last)

FLAVORS:

Cookie Dough
LemOreo
Vanilla
Banana Cream Pie
Strawberry
Cookies & Cream
Pink Lemonade Sorbet
Espresso Brownie Swirl
Birthday Batter Cookie Monster
Caramel Crunch
Butter Pecan

The following items will be available:

Scoops
Pints
Quarts
Brownie Sundaes

03/20/2025

Dear Valued Customers,

It is with a heavy heart that we announce the closure of TeeJay’s Sweet Tooth. After much consideration, we have made the difficult decision to close our doors, and we want to take a moment to express our deepest gratitude to each and every one of you who has supported us over the years.

Your loyalty and trust have meant the world to us, and we are incredibly grateful for the opportunity to serve you. The decision to close has not been an easy one, but we believe it is the right step for us at this time. We will provide one last day of limited service Saturday March 22nd.

Thank you again for your support, and we will always cherish the memories of the time we spent together. If you have any questions or concerns, please do not hesitate to reach out.

Warm regards,
Taylor & Jerome
TeeJay’s Sweet Tooth

12/13/2024

Holiday Shakes available while supplies last ‼️🎄🎅🏽🤶🏽

G I N G E R B R E A D

S U G A R C O O K I E

P E P P E R M I N T S T I C K

12/01/2023

We have been nominated for best milkshakes in the city!! Cast your vote today!!!

Welcome to Indianapolis Monthly’s Best of the City Readers’ Choice ballot! From December 1 to December 31, you, the voters, will select your local favorites!

10/22/2023

GUESS WHO MADE THE LIST!!

Here are 10 outrageous sweet treats from the best dessert spots in the US, from popcorn sundaes to towers of waffles, ice cream, cheesecake, donuts, and more.

10/06/2023

“Let’s breeew another batch!”
-Winifred Sanderson

Witch’s Brew Shakes Now Available until 10/31

10/03/2023

Fall Favorites: Pumpkin Roll Sundae
🍨 🍰 🎃

Add pecans or caramel for an indulging treat 🤤

Home of Indy’s ONLY donut and Fruity Pebble Krispie ice cream sandwich!!

08/04/2023

TODAY WE TURN 5‼️
Join us in celebrating with $5 specials ALL DAY
• Cloud Cone
• Strawberry Shortcake Sundae
• Ice Cream Flights
• Donut Sandwich
• Donut Sundae
• Fruity Pebble Treat

05/20/2023

02/03/2023

Feel like falling in love? ❤️😍🥰

Available for a limited time

• Cupid’s Treat
• Chocolate Covered Strawberry Milkshake

09/14/2022

Fall is around the corner 🍁🍂
•
•
Our Caramel Apple Pie Milkshake is NOW AVAILABLE ; Apple pie ice cream with caramel drizzle and a peanut edible rim