Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs

Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs In the Bread & Crust We Trust

Best Sub Sandwich – 2 Years Running” Idaho Falls Magazine Dining Awards We prepare the best, freshest dough daily.

Toppings come and go, and your selection is probably terrific, but that’s not where the goodness comes in a pizza or a sub. The dough is the difference; it’s the start to your culinary masterpiece. At Papa Kelsey’s, your unique, delicious pizza or sub starts early in the morning, before many of the other shops have even opened the door. So, whether dining in, delivery or take out, discover what makes Papa Kelsey different from the start.

09/23/2026

🎉 TUESDAY TRIVIA WINNER ANNOUNCEMENT! 🎉

Congratulations to Courtney Swore, our Papa Kelsey’s Tuesday Trivia winner! 🏆🍕

Courtney knew that the Papa Kelsey’s Mesa, Arizona location opened in 1992 (Answer: C) — and she’s taking home a FREE Half Sub on our fresh‑baked bread!

Thanks to everyone who joined in this week’s trivia fun. Keep those guesses coming — we’ll have another question next Tuesday!

🍕 PAPA KELSEY’S TUESDAY TRIVIA! 🍕Papa Kelsey’s has been serving up fresh-made bread, hot subs, and pizza in more places ...
09/22/2026

🍕 PAPA KELSEY’S TUESDAY TRIVIA! 🍕

Papa Kelsey’s has been serving up fresh-made bread, hot subs, and pizza in more places than just Idaho!

What year did the Papa Kelsey’s location in Mesa, Arizona open? 🌵🍕

A. 1986
B. 1989
C. 1992
D. 1996

Drop your answer in the comments for a chance to win a FREE 8-inch Sandwich from Papa Kelsey's Idaho Falls! 👇

We’ll reveal the correct answer—and pick one lucky winner—from everyone who guesses correctly! 🎉

Hint: They’ve been serving Mesa for more than 30 years!

🌯🚓 Starting the morning right at Papa Kelsey’s!A big thank‑you to the Idaho Falls Police Department for stopping in toda...
09/19/2026

🌯🚓 Starting the morning right at Papa Kelsey’s!

A big thank‑you to the Idaho Falls Police Department for stopping in today and kicking off their morning with our fresh, hot breakfast burritos. We appreciate their continued service and dedication to keeping our community safe every single day.

If you’re out and about this morning, swing by Papa Kelsey’s and grab a breakfast burrito of your own — made fresh, fast, and delicious!

Papa Kelsey’s Pizza & Subs — Idaho Falls
🥪 Three-Time Best Sandwich Winner! 🏆🏆🏆

🥣 PAPA KELSEY’S SOUP POLL! 🥪We’re thinking about adding soups to pair with your favorite Papa Kelsey’s sub, and we want ...
09/17/2026

🥣 PAPA KELSEY’S SOUP POLL! 🥪

We’re thinking about adding soups to pair with your favorite Papa Kelsey’s sub, and we want YOUR vote!

If we were to offer soup, which one would you choose?

A. 🍗 Chicken & Wild Rice
B. 🥔 Creamy Potato
C. 🍜 Chicken Noodle
D. 🥕 Vegetable Beef & Barley
E. 🤔 None of the Above — tell us what you’d rather have!

👇 Drop your letter in the comments! And if you picked E, tell us which soup Papa Kelsey’s needs to make!

Soup + a fresh Papa Kelsey’s sub… sounds like a pretty great combination! 🥣

09/16/2026

🎉 PEPPERONI COUNTING CONTEST WINNER! 🎉

We’ve got a champion! The total number of pepperonis in the box was 202, and Melissa Remoir Cain came in with an impressive guess of 201 — without going over!

👏 Congratulations, Melissa!
You’ve won a FREE Medium Pepperoni Pizza from Papa Kelsey’s Idaho Falls!

Want more Tuesday Trivia and fun contests?
Make sure you’re following Papa Kelsey’s for more chances to win delicious prizes! 🍕🔥

🍕 PAPA KELSEY’S TUESDAY TRIVIA! 🍕Okay, Papa Kelsey’s fans… HOW GOOD IS YOUR GUESS? 👀Take a close look at this box FULL o...
09/15/2026

🍕 PAPA KELSEY’S TUESDAY TRIVIA! 🍕

Okay, Papa Kelsey’s fans… HOW GOOD IS YOUR GUESS? 👀

Take a close look at this box FULL of pepperoni! 🍕🍕🍕

Tuesday Trivia Question:
👉 How many individual pepperoni slices are in this box?

🎯 Closest guess WITHOUT GOING OVER wins a FREE MEDIUM PEPPERONI PIZZA!

To enter:
🍕 Comment your guess below
🍕 One guess per person
🍕 Tag a friend who thinks they can beat your guess!

We’ll reveal the actual number—and our winner—after the contest!

Ready… set… COUNT! 🔢🍕

Please don’t give away the answer if you happen to know it. 😉

Papa Kelsey’s Pizza & Subs — Idaho Falls
Rising Early, Rising Above, Made Fresh Every Day!

09/11/2026

🇺🇸 WE WILL NEVER FORGET. 🇺🇸

Today, Papa Kelsey’s pauses to remember the lives lost on September 11, 2001, and to honor the heroes who courageously stepped forward when our nation needed them most.

We remember the first responders, the families, and all those whose lives were forever changed.

May we also remember how, in the days that followed, we came together as one nation and one community—supporting our neighbors and standing side by side.

Today, we remember. We honor. We are grateful. ❤️🤍💙

God bless America. 🇺🇸

— Your friends at Papa Kelsey’s Pizza & Subs

”

09/09/2026

🎉 TUESDAY TRIVIA WINNER! 🎉

Thanks to everyone who played along with our Papa Kelsey’s Tuesday Trivia!

The question was:
🍕 Where did Danny and Alisa Klassen move from to open Papa Kelsey’s in Idaho Falls?

🥁 Drumroll please…

✅ The correct answer was B!

🎟️🎡 Congratulations to Zack Ellis! You’re the winner of FOUR FREE TICKETS to the Eastern Idaho State Fair. You can pick up at our 17th street location.

Thanks for knowing your Papa Kelsey’s history—and we hope you have an awesome time at the fair! 🎢🌭🎠

Keep following us for more Tuesday Trivia, fun prizes, and a little Papa Kelsey’s history along the way! 🍕🥪

🎡🍕 TUESDAY TRIVIA — WIN 4 EASTERN IDAHO STATE FAIR TICKETS! 🎟️🎟️🎟️🎟️Let’s see how well you know your Papa Kelsey’s histo...
09/08/2026

🎡🍕 TUESDAY TRIVIA — WIN 4 EASTERN IDAHO STATE FAIR TICKETS! 🎟️🎟️🎟️🎟️

Let’s see how well you know your Papa Kelsey’s history!

In 1991, Danny and Alisa Klassen moved to Idaho Falls to open the first Papa Kelsey’s in Idaho Falls.

What city and state did they move from?

A. Logan, Utah
B. Springville, Utah
C. Jackson, Michigan
D. Pocatello, Idaho

👇 Comment your answer below for your chance to win FOUR tickets to the Eastern Idaho State Fair!

🎟️ BONUS: Tag the three people you’d take to the fair!

We’ll randomly choose one winner from the correct answers.

Good luck, and thanks for supporting Papa Kelsey’s Pizza & Subs for 35 years! 🍕🥪

🍕🥪 PAPA KELSEY’S POLL — VOTE & WIN! 🎉We want to know… How do YOU usually order your Papa Kelsey’s?🚗 A. DOORDASH🍴 B. UBER...
09/07/2026

🍕🥪 PAPA KELSEY’S POLL — VOTE & WIN! 🎉

We want to know… How do YOU usually order your Papa Kelsey’s?

🚗 A. DOORDASH
🍴 B. UBER EATS
💻 C. GOOGLE / PAPA KELSEY'S WEBSITE
📞 D. CALL US DIRECTLY
👋 E. WALK IN & ORDER (old school 😎)

👇 Comment A, B, C, D or E below!

🎁 BONUS: We’ll pick one lucky person from the comments to win a $10 Papa Kelsey’s Gift Card!

Want an extra little challenge? Tag the person you’d share your Papa Kelsey’s with! 🍕❤️

Let’s see which way is #1 with our customers!

Papa Kelsey’s Pizza & Subs — Idaho Falls

🥪 Three-Time Best Sandwich Winner! 🏆🏆🏆

Address

2285 E 17th Street
Idaho Falls, ID
83404

Opening Hours

Monday 7am - 9pm
Tuesday 7am - 9pm
Wednesday 7am - 9pm
Thursday 7am - 9pm
Friday 7am - 10pm
Saturday 7am - 10pm

Telephone

+12085233136

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category