Papa's Ice Cream Cottage

Papa's Ice Cream Cottage We are a simple but delicious ice cream shop that serves traditional homemade ice cream treats.

The King is back! The King Sundae is our Father’s Day specialty sundae ONLY being served tomorrow for Father’s Day!! Thi...
06/20/2026

The King is back! The King Sundae is our Father’s Day specialty sundae ONLY being served tomorrow for Father’s Day!! This is the third time this sundae is being offered and we ALWAYS run out before the day is through. Vanilla soft serve with peanut butter sauce, a whole banana AND homemade candied bacon, topped with whipped cream!!

06/19/2026

Mannings Menu

Chocolate Peanut Butter
Blueberry
Lemon Crème Brûlée Yogurt
Peanut Butter Crunch Yogurt

🍭 Something sweet just landed at Papa’s! 🍭We’re excited to introduce our brand-new Cotton Candy Soft Serve! It’s colorfu...
06/18/2026

🍭 Something sweet just landed at Papa’s! 🍭

We’re excited to introduce our brand-new Cotton Candy Soft Serve! It’s colorful, creamy, and tastes just like the cotton candy you loved as a kid. Roll or sprinkle on Cotton Candy Crunch topping for an added POP of flavor!Available now while supplies last!

06/17/2026

Mannings Menu

Mint Chocolate Chip
Black Raspberry
Peanut Butter Crunch Yogurt

06/13/2026

Mannings Menu

Sassy Cow 🐮
Rocky Road
Raspberry Swirl Yogurt

💙🍦COOKIE MONSTER HAS RETURNED🍦💙Our wildly popular Cookie Monster Yogurt is back! Creamy blue soft serve loaded with cook...
06/13/2026

💙🍦COOKIE MONSTER HAS RETURNED🍦💙
Our wildly popular Cookie Monster Yogurt is back! Creamy blue soft serve loaded with cookie flavor that’s sure to bring out the kid in everyone.
The specialty yogurt sundae is loaded with crushed Oreos, cookie dough bites, hot fudge and whipped cream 🍪🍦 See you at the window!

06/12/2026

Last call for Pink Lemonade Sorbet🍋
Stop down tonight only and get yours for a $1 off!

06/11/2026

*Updated*
Mannings Menu

Apple Crisp 🍎
French Coconut Custard 🥥 - sold out
Rocky Road
Raspberry Swirl Yogurt

Sugar Free hard ice cream

Strawberry 🍓
Butter Pecan

Vegan - Dairy Free hard ice cream

Berry Supreme

06/09/2026

Mannings Menu

Chocolate Marshmallow - sold out
French Coconut Custard 🥥
Caramel Critter
Strawberry Yogurt 🍓

The Peach Dole Whip has tied with Peanut Butter Yogurt with selling out the fastest…3 days!! We will be trying to obtai...
06/06/2026

The Peach Dole Whip has tied with Peanut Butter Yogurt with selling out the fastest…3 days!!
We will be trying to obtain more but for now let’s move onward to another NEW FLAVOR for us!

🩷🍋Pink Lemonade Sorbet 🍋🩷
Let this delicious sorbet help bring back memories of a summertime lemonade stand. Tangy and tart combined with sweet and creamy…a sorbet you probably haven’t tried but really should!

Address

1800 Fair Avenue
Honesdale, PA
18431

Opening Hours

Monday 12pm - 9pm
Tuesday 12pm - 9pm
Wednesday 12pm - 9pm
Thursday 12pm - 9pm
Friday 12pm - 9pm
Saturday 12pm - 9pm
Sunday 12pm - 9pm

Telephone

+15706164449

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Papa's Ice Cream Cottage posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Papa's Ice Cream Cottage:

Shortcuts

Share

Category