Pony Express Pizza

Pony Express Pizza Contact information, map and directions, contact form, opening hours, services, ratings, photos, videos and announcements from Pony Express Pizza, Pizza Place, 343 3rd Street, Henderson, KY.

We have been been proudly serving our community for over 30 years, earning a reputation for our iconic breadsticks paired w/ our famous cheese sauce & our great hot ham & cheese sandwich.

09/24/2026

Tonight’s family meeting agenda:

“What do y’all want for dinner?”

Person #1: “I don’t care.”
Person #2: “Anything.”
Person #3: “Not that.”
Person #4: “I literally just said I don’t know.”
Person #5: has already decided on pizza 🍕😂

Skip the argument.

Pony Express it is. 🐴💨

Pizza, sandwiches, wings, breadsticks and enough options to keep everybody happy… or at least quiet while they’re eating. 😌

09/23/2026

🚨 PIZZA EMERGENCY 🚨

Symptoms may include:
🍕 Thinking about pizza all day
🍕 Opening the fridge 6 times and finding nothing
🍕 Saying “I’m not that hungry” and then eating 4 slices
🍕 Suddenly needing breadsticks for emotional support

Good news: we know a place. 😏🐴

📍 Pony Express Pizza
270-826-2770
☎️ Call us and let us handle dinner!

11-4 daily. Our carry out lunch special a small one topping pizza and drink $6.75, 6 wings and a drink $7.75 or our spec...
09/23/2026

11-4 daily. Our carry out lunch special a small one topping pizza and drink $6.75, 6 wings and a drink $7.75 or our speciality potato and drink $9.99.

09/05/2026

Just a reminder that we will be closed tomorrow Sunday September 6th & Monday September 7th for the Labor Day Holiday weekend.
We hope everyone has a safe and happy holiday!! We will reopen Tuesday September 8th at 11 AM!!

🍕 MONDAY = MOZZARELLA MONDAY at Pony Express Pizza! 🧀🐴Mondays are hard enough… dinner doesn’t have to be. 😌Stop by and g...
08/24/2026

🍕 MONDAY = MOZZARELLA MONDAY at Pony Express Pizza! 🧀🐴

Mondays are hard enough… dinner doesn’t have to be. 😌

Stop by and grab some Mozzarella Rolls and don’t forget — Mondays mean 1 FREE topping is included! 🙂

Start the week with something cheesy, hot, and actually worth looking forward to. 😂

📍 343 3rd St. Henderson, KY 42420
📞 (270) 826-2770
Call us or go online and let Pony handle Monday night dinner! 🐴💨

08/23/2026

Hello everyone, we wanted to let you know that we will be closed September 6 & 7 for Labor Day! We will return to our normal schedule on September 8th. Thank you all and have a wonderful holiday weekend 🙂

08/20/2026

It’s Thursday, which means you’ve officially made it far enough into the week to reward yourself with pizza. 🍕😂

No cooking. No dishes. No “what does everybody want for dinner?” argument for the 47th time.

Just call Pony Express Pizza and let us handle it. 🐴🍕❤️

Because some days, dinner just needs to show up at your door.

08/12/2026

Check out our newest menu item 😋

08/12/2026

Back to school shopping got ya down? Save $5 on $30 when you call us and mention BACKPACK!! $5 OFF THRU 8/31

05/07/2026

🐎🔥 THOROUGHBRED THURSDAY 🔥🐎

You know the deal…
$2 OFF small Big Pony pizzas
$3 OFF medium
$4 OFF large

And if you still haven’t tried the Big Pony yet… imagine if a cheeseburger and a pizza had a beautiful, greasy little love story. 🍔🍕😂

Loaded up. Messy in the best way. Absolutely worth unbuttoning your jeans for.

Locally owned. Handmade dough daily. Still slinging pizzas like it’s 1984 🤘

📍 Pony Express Pizza

Address

343 3rd Street
Henderson, KY
42420

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 8pm
Tuesday 11am - 8pm
Wednesday 11am - 8pm
Thursday 11am - 10pm
Friday 11am - 10pm
Saturday 11am - 10pm
Sunday 11am - 8pm

Telephone

+12708262770

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Pony Express Pizza posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Pony Express Pizza:

Shortcuts

Share

Category