Pony Express Pizza

05/26/2026

05/18/2026

Hey everyone, just a heads up-we’re closing at 6 pm today! We’ll see you all tomorrow.

05/07/2026

🐎🔥 THOROUGHBRED THURSDAY 🔥🐎

You know the deal…
$2 OFF small Big Pony pizzas
$3 OFF medium
$4 OFF large

And if you still haven’t tried the Big Pony yet… imagine if a cheeseburger and a pizza had a beautiful, greasy little love story. 🍔🍕😂

Loaded up. Messy in the best way. Absolutely worth unbuttoning your jeans for.

Locally owned. Handmade dough daily. Still slinging pizzas like it’s 1984 🤘

📍 Pony Express Pizza

05/01/2026

Hey everyone, this Sunday, May 3rd we are going to OPEN at 3pm and close at 8pm to allow for some oven maintenance we need to perform. Thank you all for your understanding!

04/12/2026

It’s Sunday… you know what that means 👀🍞

Half-price breadsticks are calling your name—and honestly, ignoring them feels like a personal attack at this point.

🔥 Fresh, buttery, goodness
🔥 Enough to share… or not (we don’t judge)
🔥 The easiest dinner decision you’ll make all day

Whether you’re recovering from the weekend or avoiding cooking like the rest of us… we got you.

📍 Pony Express Pizza
⏰ Open & ready when you are

Don’t overthink it. Just grab the breadsticks 😌🐎🍕

04/08/2026

Word of mouth is everything for a small.
family owned restaurant like ours - Especially when purchasing the business meant changing owners after many years.
some customers are not aware that Pony Express is under new management and some customers have no idea we are even open! So if you are enjoying Pony Express Pizza under the new ownership, we would greatly appreciate it if you wouldn’t mind leaving a five star review on our Google page so all of Pony Express Pizza‘s customers old and new will know that we are here and we are better than ever!

(If we’ve added your newest favorite to the menu since changing ownership, share that in your review so customers will know we are a whole vibe & they’ll never have to call to see if we are open, just call & place an order! 😉)

https://share.google/lclqw5G9BzhYeotVG

03/29/2026

📣 Announcement from Pony Express Pizza

Pony Express Pizza will be closed Friday, April 3rd through Sunday, April 5th as we celebrate a family wedding and spend time together for Easter.

We will reopen at 11:00 AM on Monday, April 6th.

Thank you for your understanding, and we look forward to serving you soon! 🍕

03/29/2026

Therapy is expensive.
Breadsticks are $2.50.

It’s Sunday. You know what to do.

🔥 Half-price breadsticks.
🔥 No judgment.
🔥 Cheese sauce optional, but highly encouraged.