Captain's Choice Restaurant

Captain's Choice Restaurant It combines casual tradition and friendly service for the best in “Down East” dining! You’re invited to enjoy cool sea breezes as you relax on our outdoor deck.

CAPTAIN’S CHOICE RESTAURANT
FOR GREAT “DOWN EAST” DINING

Situated at the center of picturesque Harkers Island, along Cape Lookout National Seashore, Captain’s Choice Restaurant was established May 16, 1986. Then come on in and experience the history of the area depicted through coastal wall hangings, shore birds, framed Decoy Festival posters from years gone by, and Harkers Island work boat mod

els locally crafted by Stevie Lewis. Each authentic porthole window is adorned with genuine fishnet fabric, while a large ship’s wheel accents the buffet. Owners and operators of Captain’s Choice Restaurant, Steve and Gail Lancaster, take pride in providing hungry guests with carefully prepared meals that even Grandma would be proud to call her own! Nightly specials are offered, with a full menu available anytime. We specialize in fresh seafood (local when available), our own original recipe prime rib, rib eye steaks and fresh homemade desserts. Captain’s Choice offers weekday lunch specials, including sandwiches, burgers, soups, chowders, and garden fresh salad bar, along with light meals featuring seafood and country cooking. In addition, a variety of delicious complimentary homemade desserts are offered during lunch. A special children’s menu is available for lunch and dinner. Weekends are always special at Captain’s Choice. The “all you care to eat” seafood buffets on Friday and Saturday evenings are spectacular, but if you prefer country cooking, our Sunday lunch buffet will suit your fancy! We offer country cooking, as well as a trio of fried seafood, peel and eat shrimp, garden fresh salad bar, and scrumptious desserts. Be sure to sample our irresistible “Down East” clam chowder, once featured in “Our State” magazine. Serving top quality food, with prompt and courteous service is our main objective. Stop by for a visit. You’ll always be welcomed with a warm smile, a kind word, and we’ll always have a fresh pot of coffee on…..for guests just like you!

https://www.facebook.com/127354310633860/posts/2541332105902723/?sfnsn=mo
12/18/2019

https://www.facebook.com/127354310633860/posts/2541332105902723/?sfnsn=mo

‘Twas the week before Christmas
and all along the coast,
the fishermen were not home
but out on the boats.

The gear was all set
with the greatest of care
and hopes that fish
would soon show up there.

The crew was not nestled
warm in their bunks
But up on the deck
Busting their humps!

Visions of full holds
danced in their heads
And they dreamed of home
and nice warm beds.

Through wind and snow
they hauled and they packed.
Finally it was time
to steam on back.

At the dock they delivered
their bounty for sale,
so that at holiday parties
we all will eat well!

As the crew secured the lines
ready to head home out of sight,
the captain exclaimed,
“Merry Christmas to all!
Enjoy your seafood dinners tonight!”

- Lauren Salter

Thanks to Captain Cecil Jones at Fulcher’s Point Pride Seafood for the picture.

Today is a sad day for the Captain's Choice family, the Lancaster family, and for Harkers Island.  Last night, our dear ...
07/22/2019

Today is a sad day for the Captain's Choice family, the Lancaster family, and for Harkers Island. Last night, our dear friend, Mr. Frank Moore passed away.

Mr. Frank was loved by many, but no more than by us. For years he had an honored position at our "breakfast round table" every Saturday. When it got to a point that he wasn't able to drive, one of us would call on Friday night and ask if he wanted to come to breakfast on Saturday morning. Steve or our/his friends from New Bern, Phil & Linda White, would pick him up and bring him. He was surely missed as time passed and those trips became less & less frequent.

A blessed soul that will be forever remembered.

We love you, Mr. Frank - The Lancaster's & all of your Captain's Choice family.

07/09/2019

What do we say right now? Friday night, July 5th, fire took our restaurant...our life.

A person's life is made up of many different aspects. It is made up of experiences, of friends, of family, and of passion. Our lives have been filled with friends that we see every month, every week, and in some cases every day. Our family goes well beyond the father, mother, and son who own and operate this business. For us, family means all of our employees & many of our guests who are so much more than just customers.

We would like to thank every person who has supported us through our 17 years on Harkers Island. No matter if you visited us one time while on vacation, or five times a week because you live within eyesight...thank you. But no one has supported us more than our caring employees. We have employed some seriously special people these past 17 years. To all of you, past and present, thank you & we love you.

Guthrie, Barnes, Musgrave, Lancaster. The Captain's Choice Restaurant has a storied history. Thank you to our predecessors who helped make CCR what it is. We, the Lancaster family, thank you for your efforts and for setting us up for success.

We would like to personally thank Seaside Galley for their compassionate words. We have been for many years, and will continue to be.

In the past few days we have seen dozens of Facebook posts about the fire, and have been overwhelmed by literally thousands of positive comments. Those comments coupled with the hundreds of private messages, texts, phone calls, and personal visits have humbled us beyond anything we would have ever imagined.

We are down, but it's too early to count us out.

07/03/2019

Wednesday, July 3rd

We will not be open for lunch.

However, we WILL be open at 4pm and offering our seafood buffet beginning at 5pm. Come enjoy the best buffet in Carteret County!

Hope you're all ready for a wonderful 4th!

06/16/2019

HAPPY FATHER'S DAY !!!

We're open for breakfast so come on down!

Our Lunch Buffet today will include BARBECUE and BEEF TIPS (along with our usual turkey, fried chicken, and shrimp).

We will also be featuring our Seafood Buffet tonight starting at 5pm.

So treat your father to a wonderful meal...we're here all day!

GailandSteve Lancaster
Jay Lancaster

HAPPY  FATHER'S  DAY !!!This year, for Father's Day, we will be featuring our very own Eastern North Carolina style Barb...
06/14/2019

HAPPY FATHER'S DAY !!!

This year, for Father's Day, we will be featuring our very own Eastern North Carolina style Barbecue on our Sunday Lunch Buffet! You know your Daddy loves him some barbecue...so come get some of the best. We'll be looking for you!

GailandSteve Lancaster
Jay Lancaster

Peel & Eat ShrimpIt's all about those North Carolina shrimp!Available by the pound & 1/2 pound, as well as on our seafoo...
05/31/2019

Peel & Eat Shrimp

It's all about those North Carolina shrimp!

Available by the pound & 1/2 pound, as well as on our seafood buffet (while they last).

I know you want some...we'll see you when you get here!

GailandSteve Lancaster
Jay Lancaster

Today is about remembering, and honoring, those who made the ultimate sacrifice and gave their lives for our country...f...
05/27/2019

Today is about remembering, and honoring, those who made the ultimate sacrifice and gave their lives for our country...for your liberty...for our freedom.

So no matter what you are doing today, stop for at least a minute and give thanks to them.

Today is THEIR day.

This happy crowd wishes you a blessed Memorial Day.Our Breakfast Buffet starts at 7am!Lunch Buffet at 11am & Seafood Buf...
05/26/2019

This happy crowd wishes you a blessed Memorial Day.

Our Breakfast Buffet starts at 7am!

Lunch Buffet at 11am & Seafood Buffet at 5pm today. Full menu available all day.

Start your day right by spending it at the Captains Choice.

GailandSteve Lancaster
Jay Lancaster
Janice Fulcher
Kim Guthrie
Tabitha Starr Taylor

MEMORIAL DAY WEEKENDWelcome to Harkers Island !!!Saturday, and all weekend long, we have LOCAL Shrimp, Mahi, Wahoo, Sea ...
05/25/2019

MEMORIAL DAY WEEKEND

Welcome to Harkers Island !!!

Saturday, and all weekend long, we have LOCAL Shrimp, Mahi, Wahoo, Sea Mullet, and Bluefish. We also have Sea Scallops from New Bedford, Mass.

SUNDAY WE WILL HAVE A BREAKFAST BUFFET from 7am-10am. Our full menu will also be available.

Sunday we will feature a Lunch Buffet that would make your Grandma cry. Saturday & Sunday night we will have a Seafood Buffet beginning at 5pm both days.

We hope everyone has a happy & safe Memorial Day Weekend. Above all, keep in mind why we have Memorial Day to begin with. Remember those that made the ultimate sacrifice for our freedoms.

GailandSteve Lancaster
Jay Lancaster

05/23/2019

Friday breakfast has returned!

Our current breakfast a schedule is as follows:

- Friday 8am-10:30am
- Saturday 7am-10:30am (buffet available)
- Sunday 7am-10:30am

GailandSteve Lancaster
Jay Lancaster

Address

977 Island Road
Harkers Island, NC
28531

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Captain's Choice Restaurant posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Captain's Choice Restaurant:

Share