10/09/2026
👀
Silver Grill Cafe opened in 1933. It's the oldest restaurant in Fort Collins. And the thing it's famous for? A cinnamon roll.
Not just any cinnamon roll. The recipe came out of a 1969 Better Homes & Gardens cookbook. The owner put it on the menu in 1986 and sales jumped 50% the next year. Esquire later put the place on its list of restaurants America couldn't afford to lose.
A cookbook cinnamon roll. That's the legend. That's more or less the whole business model.
I ranked it #1 in Fort Collins, ahead of a serious raw-bar oyster place and the Old Town margarita institution. Because here's what I think: any town can open a good restaurant. Almost nobody can make a single cinnamon roll famous for 40 years.
Jax Fish House people are going to disagree with me. Loudly.