Cosentino's Ristorante

Cosentino's Ristorante Family owned business since 1996, Serving Classic Italian Cuisine In 1978 Marylou “Nonna” and Joe “Uncle Joe” Cosentino started a restaurant from scratch.

The result was “Uncle Joe’s” which has grown from a one room pizzeria with a small assortment of pizza and subs to a full service restaurant. Uncle Joe’s “Geneva’s Oldest Pizzeria” has a fine selection of pizza, pasta, subs, salads and wings. In 1996 Joe and Marylou purchased the former Josephine’s and Alice’s restaurant and recreated it as Nonna Cosentino’s Trattoria. They continued serving the s

ame homemade tomato sauce, hand rolled meatballs and fresh Italian bread made in the Uncle Joe’s bakery. Opening Nonna’s gave them the opportunity to provide more of the same quality, consistency and friendly atmosphere that they were known for and a wider variety of Italian cuisine. In 1991 Joe and Marylou’s oldest of six children Bill and his wife Nancy left their hometown of Geneva for Virginia Beach, VA. Bill continued his career as a civilian firefighter for the United States Government, which began at the Seneca Army Depot in 1984. They had a son Dominick and were offered an extraordinary opportunity to work at the Naval Air Station Sigonella, Sicily. Bill, Nancy and Dominick lived in Motta Sant’ Anastasia for five years. During their time there they formed a love for the families and friends they met as well as the Italian culture. After returning to the United States, Bill retired after 30 years of service as Assistant Fire Chief and decided to come home to Geneva and venture into the restaurant business to carry on the family tradition that Joe and Marylou started so many years ago. Today, the name has changed a bit but our customers can still expect the same quality and consistency. We welcome you and hope you find Cosentino’s Ristorante to be a delicious experience for you and your family. Mangia Bene! Thank you from Bill, Nancy, Dominick
And the
Staff at Cosentino’s

We cook with fresh ingredients as the baseline for every plate. Simple choices, consistent flavor-Italian dishes made wi...
09/02/2026

We cook with fresh ingredients as the baseline for every plate. Simple choices, consistent flavor-Italian dishes made with care. Join us at 1 Railroad Place, Geneva, NY for a meal that shows the difference freshness makes. Book a table: https://wix.to/tq6qfKv 🍅🍝

🍽️ THURSDAY — WHAT’S ON YOUR PLATE? 🍝It’s Thursday, and we want to know… WHAT’S ON YOUR PLATE TONIGHT? 😋❤️ Cosentino’s R...
08/27/2026

🍽️ THURSDAY — WHAT’S ON YOUR PLATE? 🍝

It’s Thursday, and we want to know… WHAT’S ON YOUR PLATE TONIGHT? 😋

❤️ Cosentino’s Ristorante

Bring your well-behaved pup to our sunny patio for a relaxed dinner at Cosentino’s. We serve classic Italian dishes made...
08/21/2026

Bring your well-behaved pup to our sunny patio for a relaxed dinner at Cosentino’s. We serve classic Italian dishes made with fresh ingredients and family-care you can taste. Join us at 1 Railroad Place, Geneva, NY - dogs welcome. Reserve a table today: https://wix.to/sl2rXb6 🐾🍝

Our family has welcomed diners to Geneva since 1996, serving recipes passed down with care. Come taste the tradition at ...
08/19/2026

Our family has welcomed diners to Geneva since 1996, serving recipes passed down with care. Come taste the tradition at Cosentino’s Ristorante - warm service, familiar flavors, and plates made to feel like home. Reserve a table today: https://wix.to/UN72DZF 🍝🏡

08/16/2026
🌟 Employee Recognition: Most Improved — Anthony! 🌟Today, we’re excited to celebrate Anthony as our Most Improved Employe...
08/15/2026

🌟 Employee Recognition: Most Improved — Anthony! 🌟

Today, we’re excited to celebrate Anthony as our Most Improved Employee! 🎉👏

This recognition is about so much more than improvement — it’s about effort, determination, and the willingness to keep learning and growing. Anthony has put in the work, taken on challenges, and continued to push himself to become better each day.

We’ve had the privilege of watching that growth firsthand, and we couldn’t be more proud of how far he has come. ❤️

Anthony, thank you for your hard work, your dedication, and for continuing to show up and give your best. Your progress has not gone unnoticed, and we’re excited to see all that you’ll accomplish moving forward!

Congratulations, Anthony! You’ve earned this recognition, and we’re so happy to celebrate you! 🏆🎉

08/14/2026
🌟 Employee Spotlight: Casey Heatherly — Cosentino's Ristorante Hospitality Lead 🌟We are proud to recognize Casey Heather...
08/13/2026

🌟 Employee Spotlight: Casey Heatherly — Cosentino's Ristorante Hospitality Lead 🌟

We are proud to recognize Casey Heatherly as one of the people who truly represents the best of the Finger Lakes hospitality community! ❤️

Casey is an exceptional lead server and someone we know we can always count on. She consistently steps up when needed, takes the lead, and goes above and beyond to make sure our guests and our team are taken care of.

What makes Casey so special is the genuine care she shows every customer who walks through our doors. She treats our guests with kindness, respect, and warmth as if they were part of her own family. That personal touch doesn't go unnoticed. In fact, customers regularly request Casey by name, which says so much about the impression she leaves on everyone she serves.

Casey takes great pride in what she does. She pays attention to the quality of both our food and service and always works to make sure we meet the standards we set for our restaurant. She doesn't wait to be asked when something needs to be done, Casey steps up and gets it done.

As a lead server, she is also a wonderful example for those around her. She is dependable, hardworking, caring, and always willing to help her team.

Casey is more than an employee she is a big part of what makes Cosentino's Ristorante special. We are incredibly grateful for everything she does and for the care she puts into every shift, every customer, and every member of our team.

❤️ Thank you, Casey, for all that you do! We are lucky to have you!

Casey Heatherly

There’s always a place for you at our table in the heart of Geneva. We serve steady, home-style Italian food with a warm...
08/05/2026

There’s always a place for you at our table in the heart of Geneva. We serve steady, home-style Italian food with a warm, family welcome-whether it’s your first visit or your hundredth. Come by today and feel right at home. https://wix.to/QXaCve1

A heartfelt thank you to our amazing customers! ❤️We are incredibly honored and grateful to have been voted Best Italian...
07/30/2026

A heartfelt thank you to our amazing customers! ❤️
We are incredibly honored and grateful to have been voted Best Italian Restaurant once again! Your continued support, loyalty, and kind words mean the world to us.

Thank you for making Cosentino's Ristorante a part of your family traditions, celebrations, and special moments. We couldn't have achieved this without each and every one of you.

From all of us at Cosentino's Ristorante... Grazie mille! 🇮🇹🍝 We look forward to serving you for many years to come!

Address

1 Railroad Place
Geneva, NY
14456

Opening Hours

Wednesday 4pm - 9pm
Thursday 4pm - 9pm
Friday 4pm - 9pm
Saturday 4pm - 9pm
Sunday 4pm - 9pm

Telephone

+13157891638

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Cosentino's Ristorante posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share