Bro. Yoder’s Authentic Italian-Style Pizza

Bro. Yoder’s Authentic Italian-Style Pizza I’m Mike (Bro. Yoder). I’m formerly Amish. I grew up in a home where great homemade cooking & baking was the everyday norm. Even PIZZA!
(1)

I’m fulfilling a dream of opening a pizza shop. I guarantee you fresh homemade dough and ingredients every time!

*** SOLD OUT FOR TODAY! ***Thank you everyone!!🙏❤️The line was all along the front of the store this morning at 8:30.Ble...
07/19/2026

*** SOLD OUT FOR TODAY! ***

Thank you everyone!!🙏❤️
The line was all along the front of the store this morning at 8:30.
Bless you all for your loyalty!
I hope your taste-buds thanked you too!😉

**** SIDE NOTE ****
I finally have my Maple Glaze the way I want it! Some folks came back in to tell me it’s the best maple glazed roll they’ve ever had. So next week I’ll be increasing the number of Maple trays I make!😊

See you starting again next Wednesday at 9AM!

❤️Bro Yoder

07/19/2026

Good Sunday Morning Everyone!

DOORS OPEN AT 9AM’

I’ll have about 75 rolls in this morning’s bake.
LIMIT FOUR (4) ORIGINAL ROLLS PER CUSTOMER.
LIMIT ONE (1) MAPLE

I’ll have another 75 rolls at the 10:30AM bake! ALSO LIMIT (4) ROLLS PER CUSTOMER.

Thanks!

❤️Bro Yoder

07/18/2026

It was another SOLD OUT DAY!!
See you tomorrow, Sunday, at 9AM!!😊

07/18/2026

Saturday Morning….
LIMIT 4 ROLLS PER CUSTOMER THIS MORNING!

07/17/2026

Good Evening Everyone!

Friday 7/17, 7:45pm….

Just finished making 250 POUNDS of my CR dough for tomorrow, so there will be plenty of rolls tomorrow!!

Doors open at 9AM….

And yes, I have MAPLE tomorrow and Sunday, as well as my original homemade Vanilla Buttercream!!
😋😋😋

❤️Bro Yoder

SOLD OUT FOR TODAY!Thanks to all!!See you tomorrow (Saturday) morning starting at 9AM!❤️Bro Yoder
07/17/2026

SOLD OUT FOR TODAY!
Thanks to all!!
See you tomorrow (Saturday) morning starting at 9AM!

❤️Bro Yoder

07/17/2026

It’s shaping up to be an early sell-out day! 96 rolls coming out of the oven by 9AM!
COME EARLY!!😊

There will be a 2nd bake at 10:30AM!

07/16/2026

It was another SOLD OUT day today at Bro Yoders!
Thanks to all!!
I’m a little late to post this, sorry.
I made tomorrow’s dough earlier and then came home, sat down, and took a nap! 😊

See you again tomorrow starting at 9AM!
I’ll have MAPLE again this Saturday & Sunday!😊

❤️Bro Yoder

SOLD OUT FOR THE DAY!THANK YOU!!!❤️See you tomorrow (Thursday) starting at 9AM.
07/15/2026

SOLD OUT FOR THE DAY!
THANK YOU!!!❤️
See you tomorrow (Thursday) starting at 9AM.

07/15/2026

The last 2 trays for the day just came out of the oven!! First come, first serve!

Address

3108 W Lake Road
Erie, PA

Telephone

+18148382113

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Bro. Yoder’s Authentic Italian-Style Pizza posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category