Fifty37 Sweets

Fifty37 Sweets We offer homemade treats baked with love, faith, and a whole lot of butter! This little bakery started with a simple belief: Good things are meant to be shared.

Each batch is made with faith and a thankful heart- just the way homemade should be.

Packaged up these cuties today for a couple of orders going out this week 🥰
06/10/2026

Packaged up these cuties today for a couple of orders going out this week 🥰

This week, I’m working on Teacher Appreciation cookies!📝✏️ ☕️ 👩🏼‍🏫👨🏻‍🏫🥰 I’ve been too hard on myself lately. Comparing m...
06/09/2026

This week, I’m working on Teacher Appreciation cookies!

📝✏️ ☕️ 👩🏼‍🏫👨🏻‍🏫🥰

I’ve been too hard on myself lately.

Comparing my one year of decorating to someone else’s ten years probably isn’t fair.

I’ve made some pretty good progress. Learning to give myself a little grace. 💜☺️

A little peek at my decorating setup! 🫣I always check expiration dates before starting an order. Today I actually paid a...
06/08/2026

A little peek at my decorating setup! 🫣

I always check expiration dates before starting an order.

Today I actually paid attention to the ingredients in TheSugarArt.com natural colors line. Idk why I just assumed they swapped out the "bad dyes" and called it a day 😂 Turns out they really do use natural "stuff" to make these colors! 🥰

A few weeks ago, I watched a video with a cookie decorator and she showed her entire "cookie decorating area". It was an entire office 😯 But one of the things she had was a bowl for "garbage". So that's what the little bowl is for. All the tiny triangles when I cut my piping bags 🙃

My husband and I just finished a show on Amazon called It's Not Like That, and it was sooo good! 🥰They celebrated Christ...
06/06/2026

My husband and I just finished a show on Amazon called It's Not Like That, and it was sooo good! 🥰

They celebrated Christmas in one of the episodes, and it got us BOTH excited for Christmas… baking, Christmas Eve church service, cozy lights, and all the things! ❤️💚🎄✨

…except snow 🙃

🥰 One of our friends from church made this deeelicious jalapeño cheddar loaf for us, and my GRACIOUS… it is SO good! Som...
06/04/2026

🥰 One of our friends from church made this deeelicious jalapeño cheddar loaf for us, and my GRACIOUS… it is SO good! Somehow it’s even better grilled 😋

I’ve attempted bread making exactly once, and it just wasn’t as fun for me as cookies and cupcakes 😂

I think I’ll happily leave the bread baking to Melissa Matteson 🥰

Thank you again for thinking of us and sharing this deliciousness! 💜

🍋 When I was a kid, lemon desserts never stood a chance against chocolate! Now I find myself reaching for the lemon cake...
06/02/2026

🍋 When I was a kid, lemon desserts never stood a chance against chocolate! Now I find myself reaching for the lemon cake first 🥰
Funny how your taste changes as you get older 💛

05/28/2026

One of my favorite decorating techniques 😊

05/27/2026

A little behind the scenes of my cookie process 🍪🙂

Each dough ball gets weighed to make sure it’s at least 3oz, but not over 3.03oz 😅

Getting it exactly on the first try doesn’t happen too often 😂

I make all my dough one day, refrigerate the dough balls, and bake another day so everything feels a little more manageable 🙂

So grateful to have been asked to create these cupcake pull-apart cakes for the Erie Cemetery Association’s 175th annive...
05/20/2026

So grateful to have been asked to create these cupcake pull-apart cakes for the Erie Cemetery Association’s 175th anniversary 🥹🪦

Thank you for allowing me to help celebrate such a special occasion.

I never take these opportunities for granted, and I’m always thankful for the ways God continues to open doors through something I truly love doing 💜

Address

Erie County, PA
16506

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 5pm
Tuesday 8am - 12pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 8am - 12pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Fifty37 Sweets posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category