1886 GRILL

1886 GRILL Link for Restaurant Rebranding Vote:

https://forms.gle/g9Bfs3xc5Xga5cND6

06/17/2026

1886 Grill

A new name inspired by Elwood’s history. A tradition worth preserving.

Named after the year natural gas was discovered in Elwood, 1886 Grill celebrates the hardworking spirit and rich heritage that helped shape our community. Located in one of Elwood’s most iconic restaurant locations, we’re proud to carry forward a tradition that generations of families have enjoyed.

At the heart of our menu is the legendary traditional onion burger, prepared in a way that pays tribute to the restaurant’s earliest days as Williams in 1926.

Over the decades, recipes and techniques naturally evolve, but our goal is to honor the tradition that made this location a local favorite for generations. Our onions are carefully prepared before being pressed directly into the beef on the flat-top grill, where they slowly caramelize and become one with the burger as it cooks.

Before the burger leaves the grill, it’s finished with a generous portion of onions slowly cooked in beef tallow, adding another layer of rich flavor that complements the caramelized onions already worked into the beef. It’s a simple touch, but one that reflects the care and attention that made the original onion burgers so memorable.

The result is the rich, savory, unmistakable flavor that longtime customers remember and new customers will come to appreciate. It’s not about reinventing the onion burger—it’s about returning to the craftsmanship, simplicity, and quality that made it special in the first place.

At 1886 Grill, we’re not creating a new tradition—we’re bringing back a taste of Elwood’s history, one onion burger at a time.

Pair it with our signature fries, cooked to deliver the perfect balance of a crispy golden exterior and a tender, fluffy center, just the way great fries should be.

More than a restaurant, 1886 Grill is a gathering place where history, community, and great food come together.

Community chosen. History inspired. Tradition served daily.

04/02/2026

WOW, Elwood… thank you.

We are incredibly grateful for the amazing response to our “Help Us Name Elwood’s Historic Restaurant Contest”. The creativity, pride, and love this community has shown for this historic location has been truly overwhelming.

We received so many thoughtful and meaningful name ideas, each one reflecting the rich history, traditions, and spirit of Elwood. From our railroad roots to our industrial heritage and community pride, your submissions reminded us just how special this place really is.

Now comes the difficult part.

We have assembled a cross-functional group of local citizens and community voices to help us carefully review every submission and narrow the list down to our finalists. This won’t be easy, because there are so many fantastic ideas to consider.

We’re excited for the next step and can’t wait to continue this journey with all of you as we work together to help name Elwood’s most historic restaurant.

Stay tuned for the next phase, where the community will once again help shape the future of this iconic location.

Thank you again for being part of something so special.

Brad & Alisa Gibson

03/21/2026

***** FOR THOSE WHO HAVE SUBMITTED NAMES TO THE ORIGINAL POST MADE THEY WILL BE HONORED******

Make sure you follow the current Tasty Burger page to participate and stay updated on the voting round.
Help Us Name Elwood’s Next Restaurant!
We recently acquired a historic restaurant location in Elwood that has served the community for over 100 years and has gone by many different names over the decades, but Tasty Burger is the most recent.
Now we want the community to help decide the next name!
To help manage the contest and keep everything in one place, all entries must be submitted through the Tasty Burger page. This page will morph into the new restaurant as we progress with the reopening.
Grand Prize: $500 Cash
How To Enter
Submit your restaurant name idea in the comments on this official contest post on the Tasty Burger page.
⚠️ Important:
• This contest is being managed only through the Tasty Burgerpage
• No other submissions will be accepted
Entry Requirements
• Must be 18 years of age or older
• Must submit your entry in the comments on this post and “written” inspiration on why you believe the name would represent this restaurant
• Must provide your name and contact information via private message to the page after submitting
• Limit 2 entries per person
• Names must be original and suitable for trademark registration
Submissions will start March 21st at 8:00 am until 5:00 pm March 31st
Selection Process
1. After submissions close, a panel of local community members will review all entries and narrow them down to five finalists.
2. The community will then vote to determine the winning name.
3. Finalists must sign a release granting all naming rights to the restaurant owners before their entry can move forward. This ensures the name can be legally used and trademarked.
Inspiration
Ideas inspired by the history of Elwood are encouraged, including themes related to:
The historic railroad depot and crossroads of the city
The tin mill and glass industry
The Indiana Gas Boom
The tomato canning heritage and Red Gold
Local history and community traditions
We’re excited to see the creativity from this community and find a name that honors the history of Elwood while building something great for the future.
👇Drop your name ideas on the Tasty Burger page.

Tasty Burger Sold
02/06/2026

Tasty Burger Sold

Address

1537 So A
Elwood, IN
46036

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 7pm
Tuesday 11am - 3pm
Wednesday 11am - 3pm
Thursday 11am - 3pm
Friday 11am - 7pm

Telephone

+17655529051

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when 1886 GRILL posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share