Toasted Turtle Tavern

Toasted Turtle Tavern Contact information, map and directions, contact form, opening hours, services, ratings, photos, videos and announcements from Toasted Turtle Tavern, Restaurant, 51425 State Road 19, Elkhart, IN.

What’s your must have with biscuits & gravy? Crispy bacon or sausage 🥓
07/18/2026

What’s your must have with biscuits & gravy?
Crispy bacon or sausage 🥓

We’ve officially been open 4 months already! Whats one item we can’t take off the menu? The Turtle Stack? Butter Basted ...
07/17/2026

We’ve officially been open 4 months already! Whats one item we can’t take off the menu? The Turtle Stack? Butter Basted Perch? Randy Miller (Troyer Carpets), or Crabby Cam’s Benedict… Blueberry Stuffed French Toast? Fair Doughnuts? Let me hear your favorite?

What's the one homemade dessert that has absolutely zero self-control around?Christi's Carrot Cake is made with love, la...
07/16/2026

What's the one homemade dessert that has absolutely zero self-control around?

Christi's Carrot Cake is made with love, layered with cream cheese frosting, and every bit as good as it looks. ❤️

What's your go-to summer Salad?This heat has us craving something fresh.Our Caprese Salad is the perfect light, refreshi...
07/16/2026

What's your go-to summer Salad?

This heat has us craving something fresh.

Our Caprese Salad is the perfect light, refreshing side with juicy tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, and a balsamic drizzle.

You asked for more seafood... we listened.Fresh crab-stuffed walleye, perfectly seared, served with roasted vegetables, ...
07/15/2026

You asked for more seafood... we listened.

Fresh crab-stuffed walleye, perfectly seared, served with roasted vegetables, creamy mashed potatoes, and our lobster cream sauce.

Now Open Wednesday-Sundays at 8AM for breakfast/brunch and dinner! You are invited!
07/08/2026

Now Open Wednesday-Sundays at 8AM for breakfast/brunch and dinner!
You are invited!

Red, White & Brunch. 🇺🇸Happy Fourth of July Weekend!
07/05/2026

Red, White & Brunch. 🇺🇸

Happy Fourth of July Weekend!

Chef Casey has made fresh crab rangoons for the weekend. They’re every bit as good as they look!
07/04/2026

Chef Casey has made fresh crab rangoons for the weekend.

They’re every bit as good as they look!

Our Amazing Turtle crew got up extra early this morning to make sure we are ready to serve you by 8 AM!! Weare opened an...
07/04/2026

Our Amazing Turtle crew got up extra early this morning to make sure we are ready to serve you by 8 AM!! Weare opened and you are invited!
Happy Independence Day…

You are Invited! Come start your 4th of July celebration of Independence at the Toasted Turtle today! We open at 8AM…!
07/04/2026

You are Invited! Come start your 4th of July celebration of Independence at the Toasted Turtle today! We open at 8AM…!

Address

51425 State Road 19
Elkhart, IN
46514

Opening Hours

Wednesday 8am - 9pm
Thursday 8am - 9pm
Friday 8am - 9pm
Saturday 8am - 9pm
Sunday 8am - 8pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Toasted Turtle Tavern posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category