Mario's Italian Restaurant

Mario's Italian Restaurant New owners Aubrey and Benjamin Van Galder - Rinehart bringing back an Edgerton area favorite, Mario's Italian Restaurant.

Expect the well-known pizza attached to Mario's accompanied by a significant change in concept and fantastic new menu.

05/15/2026

Mario's Italian Restaurant is Temporarily Closed...
(Cont. reading)

This announcement comes suddenly, and it is with great sadness that we share it. We have endured many challenges and changes throughout our journey of owning a restaurant. The past four weeks have been especially difficult, severely limiting our ability to operate and disrupting our service. Unfortunately, this has resulted in this prompt yet disappointing disclosure.

Our intention is to resolve the strain that is currently obstructing us and reopen for full service as soon as possible. While time is a significant factor, we are actively developing a plan to move forward. We will share updates as we make progress. Thank you for your continued understanding and support.

05/01/2026

To Our Guests,

This weekend we will be open for all facets of business \PICKUP/DINE-IN/DELIVERY/

My Surgery from last week (Chef Ben) has made it near impossible to recover quickly enough to be at 100% for Friday's dinner service, and as a result we will be:

-Assembling PIZZA Items
-Assembling FRIED Items (excluding fish/shrimp dinners)
-Pushing ourselves to give you the best service times possible.

We realize our customers have come to expect delicious Italian dishes of all varieties, which is why we will be working our HARDEST to ensure that this is the last week of a partial menu service.

We hope to see you this weekend, Stop by, or Call.
(608) 561-6312 // (608) 561-6324

Thanks, Chef Aubrey & Chef Ben

The Specialty Pizza for this weekend will be a little something to "Taco" Bout, we will have Taco Pizza's available this...
04/30/2026

The Specialty Pizza for this weekend will be a little something to "Taco" Bout, we will have Taco Pizza's available this weekend, until supplies run out!

Dine in ~ Pickup ~ Delivery
Sizes & Prices
10" $16.99
12" $19.99
14" $23.99
16" $26.99

Call (608) 561-6312 // (608) 561-6324

See you this weekend!!

04/26/2026

Mario’s Italian Restaurant will be open tonight, dine-in, pickup, and delivery.

PIZZA ITEMS ONLY!

Chef Ben is undergoing an appendectomy, and will be absent from working for at least one week’s time. As previously posted, the health concerns preventing us from operating at full capacity were very real.

During this difficult time we would appreciate continued understanding and grace, as our amazing staff, and my incredible wife Aubrey run the establishment to the best of their abilities.

Close time 8pm

Give us a call, Line 1: 608 561 6312
Line 2: 608 561 6324

Thanks!
Chef Ben.

04/25/2026

Do you have a date for prom night?? (Prom in town tonight) We have a date with double disaster!!

Today, Saturday April 25th, PICKUP & DELIVERY ONLY
AND
PIZZA ONLY

Chef Ben is going into the ER and some of the staff members are experiencing Family related medical emergencies.

This causes a massive amount of trouble when operating Mario’s Italian Restaurant at full capacity.

Terribly late notice as all this happened today and the causes are emergencies.

We post to inform and ask for understanding and grace.

Closing at 8pm tonight, as well, as I will be going to the hospital to be with my Husband,

~Chef Aubrey

04/18/2026

OPEN for Pickup & Delivery
Saturday April 18th & Sunday April 19th

Our dining room sustained a little storm damage; the cause has been found and resolved. However, the dining room cannot be served in this weekend.

It is okay to come in through the front door, and if you didn't know, the back door is accessible for guests to use!

Call for pickup & delivery orders!

Call (608) 561-6312 // (608) 561-6324

Send a message to learn more

04/17/2026

Mario's Italian Restaurant CLOSED TONIGHT - Friday April 17th due to extreme weather.

Everybody knows our area has been receiving severe and damaging storms this week & another impeding big storm is starting now. The rain is great, but the twisted tornadoes, hail & flooding are risky. Too risky for us to serve tonight, unfortunately.

An update will be posted tomorrow. Thanks for reading &, if possible, share with your friends & neighbors about our cause of closure tonight. We're grateful to those who would've come to dine or ordered for home from us, and we're sorry to hinder any dinner plans.

~ Chef Ben & Aubrey
We'll be making our dinner at home tonight.

Send a message to learn more

Mario's Italian Restaurant will be closed Easter Sunday. We will be with our Family this day.Have dinner with us Friday ...
04/03/2026

Mario's Italian Restaurant will be closed Easter Sunday. We will be with our Family this day.

Have dinner with us Friday or Saturday 4pm to 10pm!

Instead of eggs, find our recently posted DAILY DEALS and save on your order!

Mario's Italian Restaurant launching DAILY DEALS like the Artemis llPICKUP on Fridays: purchase a 16" pizza & get a 10" ...
04/03/2026

Mario's Italian Restaurant launching DAILY DEALS like the Artemis ll

PICKUP on Fridays: purchase a 16" pizza & get a 10" two topping pizza FREE!

DINE IN with us on Saturdays: order an appetizer, you'll get an appetizer!

DELIVERY on Sundays: spending $40+ on your order will get you a Garlic Cheesy Bread AND a 2Liter of soda!

*Must mention deal to apply*
*Limit one per order*

This Deal is no April Fool's Joke!Another Amazing Monthly Money Saver @ Mario's Italian Restaurant! When you place your ...
04/02/2026

This Deal is no April Fool's Joke!

Another Amazing Monthly Money Saver @ Mario's Italian Restaurant!

When you place your order, mention this DEAL, available the entire month of April. Save money, support local

Address

205 W. Fulton Street
Edgerton, WI
53534

Opening Hours

Friday 4pm - 10pm
Saturday 4pm - 10pm
Sunday 4pm - 9pm

Telephone

+16085616312

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Mario's Italian Restaurant posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share