Carissa's Bakery

Carissa's Bakery James Beard Award-winning bakery.

We bake breads, viennoiseries, cakes, and pies, and serve a daily kitchen menu around the farms and fisheries of Long Island's East End.

FOR A SWEET NEW YEAR Our Rosh Hashanah menu returns with dairy free challah, late summer corn soup, our signature salmon...
09/08/2026

FOR A SWEET NEW YEAR

Our Rosh Hashanah menu returns with dairy free challah, late summer corn soup, our signature salmon and chicken dinners, and Apple Honey Cake - a recipe passed down from our pastry chef’s grandmother, made with caramelized apples and honey.

Pre-orders are now open through our Catering + Pre- Orders page online.

Holiday pickups are available Friday and Saturday only at Sag Harbor and Pantigo.

A labor of love, our peach + calamint tart is made for sharing at August dinner parties and long summer lunches.Availabl...
08/19/2026

A labor of love, our peach + calamint tart is made for sharing at August dinner parties and long summer lunches.

Available daily at all three locations, or pre-order online with 24 hours’ notice.

Carissasthebakery.com 🍑

The greatest thing since sliced bread.Our gluten-free seeded bread has quickly become one of the most beloved loaves we ...
08/06/2026

The greatest thing since sliced bread.

Our gluten-free seeded bread has quickly become one of the most beloved loaves we make.

Naturally leavened with our in-house gluten-free starter and generously coated in sesame, pumpkin, sunflower, chia, and poppy seeds, it has a deeply flavorful crust, a satisfying crunch, and a chewy interior.

Toast it and spread it with good butter. Top it with eggs. Build your favorite open-faced sandwich. Or simply enjoy a slice on its own 😉

Available daily in our bakeries and now shipping nationwide on Goldbelly

We’ve been making jams for nearly a decade, when Carissa’s was one small bakery on Newtown lane. We only use as little s...
07/31/2026

We’ve been making jams for nearly a decade, when Carissa’s was one small bakery on Newtown lane. We only use as little sugar as needed to preserve the fruit’s natural flavor, sourcing from family owned Long Island farms whenever possible, with organic fruit whenever it’s available. Whether it’s Four Berry, Beach Plum, Strawberry Rhubarb, or Fig, each jar is a little snapshot of the season. 

Take one home for tomorrow’s toast, bring one as a host gift, or tuck a few into your suitcase as a souvenir of summer Out East. 

Can’t make it to the Hamptons? Our jams ship nationwide on Goldbelly 

Which flavor is your favorite?

Summer, swirled.New at our 3 Bay Street shop in Sag Harbor.House-made vanilla bean gelato and vegan blueberry sorbet sof...
07/15/2026

Summer, swirled.

New at our 3 Bay Street shop in Sag Harbor.
House-made vanilla bean gelato and vegan blueberry sorbet soft serve. Available individually or as a twist.

Seasonal flavors will rotate throughout the summer. Stop in for a sample before this pairing disappears 🫐

The first heirlooms of the season have arrived. This early summer harvest comes from our friends at . We brought them i...
07/02/2026

The first heirlooms of the season have arrived. This early summer harvest comes from our friends at . We brought them in special to mark the beginning of tomato season, while we wait for our neighboring farms on the East End to begin harvesting.

A few of our favorite ways to enjoy these beauties…

The Heirloom Tomato Tart with goat cheese is back. Bring it to a barbecue, a luncheon, or enjoy it standing over your kitchen counter. No judgment.

Our chilled Heirloom Tomato Gazpacho has returned as well. Bright, refreshing, and made for hot summer afternoons. Take home a pint from any location.

Also returning to our Pantigo and Sag Harbor spaces is the Heirloom Tomato Sandwich: buttered, toasted Pullman loaf, basil-balsamic mayo, vine ripe tomatoes. Simple. Delicious.

To drink: a Bloody Mary, or add tequila for a Bloody Maria. Finished with a spicy yuzu salt rim and celery juice ice cubes. Prefer yours without spirits? Order it as a juice.

Nothing says summer like an heirloom 🍅

Our Signature Blend coffee has a new look, but the beans inside remain the same coffee you love.This beloved blend combi...
06/05/2026

Our Signature Blend coffee has a new look, but the beans inside remain the same coffee you love.

This beloved blend combines specialty-grade, single-origin coffees from Peru, Ethiopia, and Brazil. We spent over a year tasting and refining, working with trusted roasting partners and family-owned farms across three coffee-growing regions to create a blend that is both approachable and complex.

A medium-dark roast with notes of cream, dark chocolate, and cherry.

Available in our cafés and shipped nationwide on ☕️

CHERRY BLOSSOM Each spring, our team forages local cherry blossoms everywhere from our yards to our parking lot. We suga...
05/30/2026

CHERRY BLOSSOM

Each spring, our team forages local cherry blossoms everywhere from our yards to our parking lot.

We sugar-preserve the blossoms to adorn cakes and pastries throughout the season, and save a small portion for our annual cherry blossom syrup.

Soft pink in color, it’s sweet and delicate, with subtle floral notes and a gentle almond flavor.

Add it to an iced latte or matcha while it lasts 🌸

MEMORIAL DAY WEEKENDThe lobster roll is back: house-picked lobster on our buttery rolls, every one finished with a claw ...
05/20/2026

MEMORIAL DAY WEEKEND

The lobster roll is back: house-picked lobster on our buttery rolls, every one finished with a claw on top. Some say it’s the best in the Hamptons. You can be the judge.

Also returning for summer: our blueberry lemon poppyseed layer cake. Poppy seed cake layers with blueberry marmalade and lemon curd.

Open all weekend + Monday
8:30am–4pm

YOGURT BOWLSheep milk yogurt with our house granola, almonds, dried cherries, blueberries, fresh berries, fresh flowers,...
05/16/2026

YOGURT BOWL
Sheep milk yogurt with our house granola, almonds, dried cherries, blueberries, fresh berries, fresh flowers, and lace tuile. Served with honey on the side.
Available now in our Pantigo restaurant for the spring and summer.

Address

221 Pantigo Road
East Hampton, NY
11937

Opening Hours

Monday 8:30am - 3pm
Thursday 8:30am - 3pm
Friday 8am - 3pm
Saturday 8am - 3pm
Sunday 8:30am - 3pm

Telephone

(631) 879-7179

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Carissa's Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Carissa's Bakery:

Shortcuts

Share

Category