Papa Jimmy's Pizzeria

Papa Jimmy's Pizzeria Papa Jimmy's is a family-owned pizzeria serving Cottage Grove and the surrounding area since 1995. Dine in, Carry Out, or have your food delivered!

We feature pizza, subs, pasta, Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream, and more! Join PJ’s Mail to receive emails containing news,special offers and exclusive promotions for PJ’s Mail subscribers only. It’s FREE and it just takes a few minutes to sign up. Visit www.papajimmys.com

03/19/2026

March Madness = handled. 🍕🏀
Bundles from $33.99 that feeds 2-8 fans.
Order now -> papajimmys.weborder.net

02/13/2026
02/13/2026

We argue. Dad judges. Pizza solves it. ❤️ Heart-shaped pizzas available Saturday.🍕

If you need us for the Super Bowl, get your favorite 16” pizza then add our small breadsticks for FREE! 🍕🥖Use code: FREE...
02/08/2026

If you need us for the Super Bowl, get your favorite 16” pizza then add our small breadsticks for FREE! 🍕🥖
Use code: FREESTICKS at checkout -> www.papajimmys.com

01/26/2026

TEMPORARY HOURS UPDATE (1/26 - 2/1)

Due to staffing adjustments, Papa Jimmy’s will operate with modified hours next week.

Monday–Thursday: 4PM–9PM
Friday & Saturday: Closed
Sunday: 11AM–9PM

Thanks for your continued support. ❤️

We’ll be back to normal hours the following week!

01/26/2026

TEMPORARY HOURS UPDATE

Next week only (1/26 - 2/1), due to staffing adjustments, Papa Jimmy’s will operate with modified hours.

Monday–Thursday: 4PM–9PM
Friday & Saturday: Closed
Sunday: 11AM–9PM

Thanks for your continued support. ❤

We’ll be back to normal hours the following week!

01/09/2026

Cold day? We’ve got the cure.
The NEW Red Hot Rancher is here to warm you up 🔥🍕
Available now.

30 years. Same family. Same ovens. A whole lot of memories. 🍕From kids growing up in the shop to generations of customer...
12/22/2025

30 years. Same family. Same ovens. A whole lot of memories. 🍕
From kids growing up in the shop to generations of customers walking through our doors — Papa Jimmy’s has been home since 1995.
Thank you to every customer, employee, friend, and family member who’s been part of the story.
Here’s to the past, the present, and whatever’s cooking next. 🥂❤️

12/17/2025

Christmas classics are back 🎄🍦🎅🏻
Only around for a limited time - don’t miss it!

10/23/2025

🎃 Will you try Snap-O-Lantern or Caramel Apple Pie first?
Fall flavors available for a limited time! 🍦

09/19/2025

Address

224 W Cottage Grove Rd
Cottage Grove, WI
53527

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 9pm
Tuesday 11am - 9pm
Wednesday 11am - 9pm
Thursday 11am - 9pm
Friday 11am - 11pm
Saturday 11am - 10:30pm
Sunday 12pm - 9pm

Telephone

+16088393102

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Papa Jimmy's Pizzeria posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Papa Jimmy's Pizzeria:

Shortcuts

Share

Category