The Pie Maker Bakery

The Pie Maker Bakery Our bakery is located at 17 N. Harrison St, next to City Market, in Cortez, CO. We hand-shape our dough and use only organic butter in all of our pastry treats.

The Pie Maker is a small batch bakery, locally owned and operated since 2012 in Montezuma County, Colorado. We specialize in extraordinary sweet & savory pastries, desserts, and artisan bagels. All of our baked goods are handmade from scratch using high quality ingredients that regularly feature local, seasonal, and organic foods. The bread flour we bake with is organic and unbleached, and our all purpose unbleached flour is purchased right here in Montezuma County from Cortez Milling.

For Summer 2026: After five years of opening the bakery most Saturday mornings, we will be pausing our Saturday baking u...
06/02/2026

For Summer 2026: After five years of opening the bakery most Saturday mornings, we will be pausing our Saturday baking until autumn. We hope to resume walk-in, grab-and-go at the bakery this fall.

~YOU CAN STILL ORDER BAKED GOODS!~
*Where: Pickup every THURSDAY between 5pm-6pm at Bakery
*How: Order online or by phone
*When: Order Deadline is every Wednesday at noon

Weekly Menu Available to Order:
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Ginger Molasses Cookies
GF Carrot Cake Muffins
Berry Cornmeal Muffins
Chocolate Therapy Brownies
Cherry Galettes
Mini Apple Pie
Mini Bourbon Pecan Pie
9” Full Size Pies
Granola
Spinach Feta Handpies
Stuffed Mushroom Handpies
Potato Sour-cream Knish
Breakfast Pies with green chile, egg scramble, roasted potatoes
Quiche with organic and seasonal veggies and cheese

Pie Maker Contact Info:
(970) 560-6039 [phone]
Piemakerbakery.com [online ordering]
[email protected] [email]
CALL to inquire about other pickup days!

This Friday is the first Telluride Farmer’s Market of the season! This will be our tenth season (and eleventh year) brin...
05/28/2026

This Friday is the first Telluride Farmer’s Market of the season! This will be our tenth season (and eleventh year) bringing sweet and savory pies and pastries, as well as nitro cold brew coffee, over the mountain to Telluride. Come see us at the bottom of the market in South Oak St, every Friday through to early October.

Local customers in Montezuma County can pick up preordered pies and pastries at the bakery on Thursday evenings, see our website or give us a call for details.
Walk-in, Grab-and-go at the bakery will resume in the autumn.

05/23/2026
05/23/2026

Come by the bakery today for the last spudnuts until autumn! First come first serve until we sell out.

Today is also the last day with a full bake case for a pop-up, walk-in, grab-and-go. For summer season we will be accepting preorders for pickup on Thursday evenings.

Join us Friday and Saturday, 8-2 at The Pie Maker Bakery for a delicious Memorial Weekend Popup!This will be the last ro...
05/21/2026

Join us Friday and Saturday, 8-2 at The Pie Maker Bakery for a delicious Memorial Weekend Popup!

This will be the last round until Autumn of certain beloved items like Spudnuts, so come enjoy them this weekend.

Menu:
Nitro Cold Brew is back on tap!
Spudnuts
Mini Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
Mini Shoofly Pie
Mini Apple Pie
Blueberry Cream Cheese Galettes
Chocolate Therapy Brownies
GF Carrot Cake Muffins
Berry Cornmeal Muffins
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Ginger Molasses Cookies
Quiche 6” with various veggies and cheese
Savory Spinach Feta Handpie
Savory Stuffed Mushroom Handpie
Potato Sourcream Knish
Breakfast Pie with roasted potato, eggs, green chile

Call ahead for full size pies and to have us hold other items for you!

05/20/2026

Nitro Cold Brew Coffee is back on tap at the bakery!

Way back in 2015 when we first opened the bakery we read about cold brewing coffee, kegging it with nitrogen, and pouring through a stout faucet. Less bitter and less acidic than hot brewed coffee, with a creamy mouthfeel from the nitrogen bubbles. At that time we would have had to travel to Salt Lake City or Denver to try it, so we decided to make it ourselves. Working with Fahrenheit Coffee Roasters in Mancos we developed a good cold brew coffee recipe, and helped us figure out the keg system. That summer we were able to introduce Nitro Cold Brew Coffee to Cortez and The Four Corners.

Still small batch, still made from scratch.
Try it at the bakery this Memorial Day weekend, or Fridays in Telluride at the farmer’s market.

Nitro Cold Brew Coffee is back on tap at The Pie Maker Bakery! Open Saturday 5/16 8-2and Friday 5/22 and Saturday 5/23 8...
05/16/2026

Nitro Cold Brew Coffee is back on tap at The Pie Maker Bakery!

Open Saturday 5/16 8-2
and Friday 5/22 and Saturday 5/23 8-2

Come on over to The Pie Maker Bakery this SATURDAY between 8am-2pm for lots of yummies!Saturday’s Menu includes:Mini Str...
05/13/2026

Come on over to The Pie Maker Bakery this SATURDAY between 8am-2pm for lots of yummies!

Saturday’s Menu includes:
Mini Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
Mini Apple Pie
Blueberry Cream Cheese Galette
Cookies
Brownies
GF Carrot Cake Muffins
Berry Cornmeal Muffins
Granola
Potato Sourcream Knish
Savory Hand Pies
Breakfast Pie with roasted potato, green chile, eggs

As always, you can go online or call to order from our core online menu for pickup every Saturday. Hope to see you all soon!

Stop by this Friday and Saturday, 8am until 2 (or we run out!), for all kinds of tasty treats. Valentines Extravaganza!W...
02/13/2026

Stop by this Friday and Saturday, 8am until 2 (or we run out!), for all kinds of tasty treats. Valentines Extravaganza!

We first opened our doors on Valentine’s Day, 2015.
Thank you to everyone for your support, each and every day since.

Times are hard. Chocolate helps.

Address

17 N Harrison Street
Cortez, CO
81321

Telephone

+19705606039

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Pie Maker Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category