Matt Carlin Unique Cheesecake Baker

Matt Carlin Unique Cheesecake Baker Store is closed. In my spare time I still create for myself unique cheesecakes of original recipes, including cakes inspired to look and taste like candy bars.

My cakes are homemade—I'm mom and self-taught, and not a professional! Check out my photos.

Quintuple Chocolate  —The chocoholic’s dream: chocolate cheesecake with mini-chocolate chips— which gives it a subtle cr...
02/14/2023

Quintuple Chocolate —The chocoholic’s dream: chocolate cheesecake with mini-chocolate chips— which gives it a subtle crunch—drenched with chocolate ganache, garnished with chocolate whipped cream, with a homemade chocolate wafer cookie crust

Maple Bacon  : Sweet maple syrup vanilla bean cheesecake, spiced with cinnamon, smothered in caramel maple glaze, and ga...
12/18/2022

Maple Bacon : Sweet maple syrup vanilla bean cheesecake, spiced with cinnamon, smothered in caramel maple glaze, and garnished with maple candied bacon, with a maple bacon fat shortbread cookie crust

Triple Berry Explosion  : Tangy berry compote cheesecake with layers of blueberry, strawberry and raspberry, smothered w...
09/30/2022

Triple Berry Explosion : Tangy berry compote cheesecake with layers of blueberry, strawberry and raspberry, smothered with a sumptuous triple berry compote, and topped with fresh blueberries, strawberries and raspberries, with an orange shortbread cookie crust

Peanut Butter & Jelly  : Rich crunchy peanut butter (can be made smooth) cheesecake, layered  with grape jelly (could be...
09/29/2022

Peanut Butter & Jelly : Rich crunchy peanut butter (can be made smooth) cheesecake, layered with grape jelly (could be any flavor) cheesecake, coated with a beautiful white chocolate mirror glaze, with a peanut butter cookie crust

Mint Chocolate Chip Brownie  Inspired by the first thing I ever baked, a refreshing mint chocolate chip cheesecake, flav...
07/04/2022

Mint Chocolate Chip Brownie
Inspired by the first thing I ever baked, a refreshing mint chocolate chip cheesecake, flavored with homemade peppermint syrup, smothered with fluffy chocolate mousse and garnished with candied mint leaves, with a thick mint brownie crust

Cosmopolitan  :For adults only: Tangy orange, lemon, lime and cranberry cheesecake, topped with citrus vodka-infused whi...
06/22/2022

Cosmopolitan :
For adults only: Tangy orange, lemon, lime and cranberry cheesecake, topped with citrus vodka-infused whipped cream, garnished with dried cranberries, with an orange shortbread cookie crust

05/25/2022

Coming Soon—Cosmopolitan Cheesecake:
For adults only: Tangy orange, lemon, lime and cranberry cheesecake topped with citrus vodka-infused whipped cream, garnished with fresh cranberries, with a shortbread cookie crust

My second commission! Caramel Irish Cream  : My first creation and, according to my mom, Miriam, “the best cheesecake ev...
05/15/2022

My second commission! Caramel Irish Cream : My first creation and, according to my mom, Miriam, “the best cheesecake ever”: Lucious Irish Cream vanilla bean cheesecake topped with a rich combination of Irish Cream and sweetened sour cream, and smothered in caramel buttercream frosting, with a shortbread cookie crust

My first officially commissioned cake! I am now accepting commissions. Message me for details! White Chocolate Macadamia...
05/10/2022

My first officially commissioned cake! I am now accepting commissions. Message me for details!
White Chocolate Macadamia
My most indulgent creation: roasted macadamia (in my opinion, the king of nuts) white chocolate cheesecake, topped with smooth white chocolate ganache and halved macadamia nuts, with a macadamia shortbread cookie crust

05/10/2022

I grew up watching my mom, Miriam, bake many wonderful creations in our Prospect Heights, Brooklyn apartment; she continued baking well into her 70s and remains my inspiration. Her cheesecakes were always my favorite. She started teaching me to bake when I was a tween, starting with mint brownies. I made many cakes, pies, cookies, blondies, etc., over the years, but never made a cheesecake until 2011—a 30th birthday cake for a work colleague, who I am still close friends with today.
Every one of my cakes is a unique creation you can’t find anywhere else (unless someone is using my recipe!). I originally started with recipes online and made alterations to make them my own, and now write my own recipes based on experience. Currently, there are 17 cakes in my repertoire, one of which is savory. Plus 4 are "coming soon" (I've written the recipe but not tested it out yet). My cakes are homemade—and look it. I am not a professional, especially when it comes to decoration. If you are looking for something that came from a bakery, I’m not for you. Thank you for your interest in commissioning a cake from me.

05/07/2022

My Cheesecake Repertoire:
1. Caramel Irish Cream 

My first creation and, according to my mom, Miriam, “the best cheesecake ever”: Lucious Irish Cream vanilla bean cheesecake topped with a rich combination of Irish Cream and sweetened sour cream, and smothered in caramel buttercream frosting, with a shortbread cookie crust
2. White Chocolate Raspberry

Decadent white chocolate raspberry compote cheesecake covered with silky white chocolate ganache and fresh raspberries, with a shortbread cookie crust
3. Pumpkin

Pumpkin cheesecake with lemon zest, cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger and a touch of cardamom, garnished with spiced whipped cream, with a snickerdoodle (cinnamon cookie) crust
4. Chocolate Ganache Pumpkin

Same as Pumpkin, but generously covered with spiced chocolate ganache, with a chocolate wafer cookie crust
5. Cinnamon Cafè Latte

Rich espresso cheesecake gently layered with creamy vanilla bean cheesecake, topped with cinnamon whipped cream, with a snickerdoodle crust
6. White Chocolate Macadamia
My most indulgent creation: roasted macadamia (in my opinion, the king of nuts) white chocolate cheesecake, topped with smooth white chocolate ganache and halved macadamia nuts, with a macadamia shortbread cookie crust
7. Maple

Sweet maple syrup vanilla bean cheesecake smothered in caramel maple topping, with a maple leaf cookie (not homemade) crust

8. Quintuple Chocolate

The chocoholic’s dream: chocolate cheesecake with mini-chocolate chips— which gives it a subtle crunch—drenched with chocolate ganache, garnished with chocolate whipped cream, with a chocolate wafer cookie crust
9. Birthday Cake

Cake flavored vanilla bean cheesecake, topped with a thin layer of confetti cake (the only thing I make from a mix), iced with vanilla bean buttercream, with a shortbread cookie crust (includes writing in icing “Happy Birthday” and the name of the recipient)
10. Blueberry Lemon

My second favorite: Sweet and tangy, blueberry and lemon compote cheesecake, topped with lemon zest flavored sweetened sour cream and fresh blueberries, with a shortbread cookie crust
11. Hazelnut Chocolate Chip
Creamy toasted hazelnut cheesecake with crunchy chopped hazelnuts and mini-chocolate chips, smothered with whipped cream, and topped with chopped hazelnuts and mini-chocolate chips, with a hazelnut shortbread cookie crust
12. Chocolate Ganache Strawberry

Three cups of strawberries in one cake: Refreshing strawberry compote cheesecake, covered with smooth chocolate ganache, topped with fresh strawberries, with a chocolate wafer cookie crust

“Candy Bars”:
Candy-based cheesecakes usually incorporate the actual candy in the recipe—My “candy bar” cheesecakes are intended to look and taste like the real thing
13. Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup 
(inspired by Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup®)

My favorite: a thin layer of chocolate cheesecake, topped with a thick creamy layer of no-bake peanut butter cheesecake, covered with chocolate ganache, including ridges to make it look like the candy, with a chocolate wafer cookie crust

14. Chocolate Caramel Peanut Nougat Candy Bar 
(inspired by Snickers®)

A thin layer of chocolate cheesecake, topped with a thick layer of fluffy peanut butter nougat no-bake cheesecake, smothered with caramel and peanuts, covered in chocolate ganache, with a chocolate wafer cookie crust—baked in a square pan

15. Chocolate Coconut Almond Candy Bar (inspired by Almond Joy®)

A thin layer of chocolate cheesecake, topped with a thick layer of no-bake cream of coconut and shredded coconut cheesecake, topped with almonds, and covered with chocolate ganache, with a chocolate wafer cookie crust—baked in a square pan

16. Peppermint Bark

For the Christmas season: Creamy white chocolate cheesecake with a slight crunch from bits of peppermint candies, covered with peppermint candy white chocolate ganache, with a chocolate wafer cookie crust—baked in a square pan


Savory
:
17. Roasted Garlic Pesto Grilled Chicken

For those without a sweet tooth (or someone who wants their meal and dessert to be cheesecake), it’s exactly as it’s named, topped with pickled red onions, with a panko crust—thigh or breast meat

Coming Soon:
18. Orange Vanilla Bean Cardamom
Like a creamsicle with a twist: Orange zest cheesecake swirled with vanilla bean cheesecake, spiced with cardamom, topped with candied oranges, with a shortbread cookie crust
19. Mint Chocolate Chip
Refreshing mint chocolate chip cheesecake, flavored with homemade fresh peppermint syrup, smothered with fluffy chocolate mousse and covered in fresh mint leaves, with a chocolate wafer cookie crust
20. Peanut Butter & Jelly
Rich peanut butter cheesecake (crunchy or smooth), topped with grape jelly no-bake cheesecake, covered with a beautiful white chocolate mirror glaze, with a peanut butter cookie crust—I grew up with grape jelly, but any fruit jelly can be substituted
21. Cosmopolitan
For adults only: Tangy orange, lemon, lime and cranberry cheesecake topped with citrus vodka-infused whipped cream, garnished with fresh cranberries, with a shortbread cookie crust

Hazelnut Chocolate Chip  Creamy hazelnut cheesecake with crunchy mini-chocolate chips, smothered with whipped cream mixe...
05/02/2022

Hazelnut Chocolate Chip
Creamy hazelnut cheesecake with crunchy mini-chocolate chips, smothered with whipped cream mixed with chopped hazelnuts and mini-chocolate chips, with a hazelnut shortbread cookie crust

Address

Corona, NY
11372

Telephone

+19172924619

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Matt Carlin Unique Cheesecake Baker posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share

Category