The Better Butter Cookie Company

The Better Butter Cookie Company Our mission is simple: to elevate the joy of everyday moments with pure butter cookies. Greetings! That's why I'm deeply committed to making a difference.
(3)

Visit my hotplate storefront https://www.hotplate.com/betterbuttercookiecompany I take immense pride in my roots as a native of Detroit, Michigan, where I was nurtured by the warmth of a family-run restaurant, renowned for my mother's delectable cookies. From an early age, I, along with my brother and childhood friends, ventured into the world of entrepreneurial spirit by selling cookies door-to-door, instilling in me a strong work ethic. My lifelong journey with a passion for baking ignited when I received a cookbook and an easy-bake oven as a memorable Christmas gift. These experiences nurtured my love for crafting sweet delights. Today, I've evolved into an Autoimmune Health Coach, specializing in the Autoimmune Protocol—an advanced elimination diet. My role involves empowering clients to create their own sweet treats while ensuring complete transparency about their ingredients. Being a person with an autoimmune disease myself, I understand firsthand how challenging it can be to go to places and find no gluten-free or vegan options. At the Better Butter Cookie Company, I offer not only our classic pure butter cookies but also gluten-free and vegan options, ensuring that everyone can savor the magic of our treats. We also provide diabetic-friendly cookie choices for those who need them. One pivotal moment that changed my life was when my neighbors invited me to showcase my mom's old-fashioned, homemade, pure butter cookies at a local fair. To my astonishment, they became an instant sensation, marking the inception of the Better Butter Cookie Company. Our brand is a delightful tribute to the 1950s, reminiscent of beloved TV shows like "I Love Lucy," "Andy Griffith," and "Dick Van Dyke." My fascination with the fashion and nostalgia of simpler times is deeply ingrained in our brand's ethos. As they say, life is sweeter with cookies, and everything is better with butter! I invite you to indulge in the timeless joy of Better Butter Cookies. Place your order today, and I eagerly anticipate sharing the magic of these classic treats with you!

Cookeville is my home base—but Auntie Tee is taking the cookies on the road! 🍪Once I’m back home and have cookie stock r...
09/28/2026

Cookeville is my home base—but Auntie Tee is taking the cookies on the road! 🍪

Once I’m back home and have cookie stock ready, I want to visit one nearby town each month. Cookeville will still have its own dedicated cookie day.

So where should I go first: Sparta, Crossville, Gainesboro, or another town close to Cookeville?

I can bring the cookie camper or set up a simple table inside a local store. Tag a business that might like to host me, or send me a message if it’s yours.

I’m making my list from your suggestions!

09/27/2026
09/27/2026

Throwback Sunday.
Found this in the archives. 😂 When my husband and I were first building Better Butter Cookie Company, we made our own little vintage commercial. Two years later, so much has changed—but apparently Auntie Tee was already Auntie Tee.

09/26/2026

A little Sabbath check-in from Washington. The meal is made, Sukkot is on my heart, and I’m still deciding whether this cold rain is going to let us sit outside. 😅

And to everybody who’s reached out asking when Better Butter cookies are coming back: I hear you, and I miss y’all too. I’m looking at the second week of October. Once I get home, I’ll need time to make dough and rebuild my stock—there isn’t a cookie waiting on the shelf!

I’ll keep you posted. Have a safe weekend.

09/25/2026

While I’m away, the owner of Longhorn Coffee Trailer is holding down the cookie conversation for me! She tried three Better Butter cookies, and I’m sharing her honest review with you.

I’ll be back soon—and yes, I’ve seen your messages saying you’ve got a hankering for cookies. I’ve missed y’all too. Just give Auntie Tee a minute when I get home: I don’t have one cookie sitting around. I’ve got dough to make before I can open back up!

In the meantime, watch her try all three. Which one would you pick?

09/24/2026

My mother-in-law had already put many important things in order. Her wishes were clear, her children trusted one another, and they worked together beautifully.

But even when someone has prepared, there can still be practical details to locate, belongings to sort through, and decisions nobody thinks about until they are standing in the middle of a loved one’s home.

We worked everything out as a family, but the experience opened my eyes. It showed me a few things I want to handle differently in my own life—while I am healthy, clearheaded, and able to explain my wishes myself.

This video is not about criticizing what anyone did or did not do. And I’m certainly not trying to be morbid. These are simply things I didn’t fully understand until I lived through the process.

So I’m sharing what I learned in case you haven’t thought about it either.

Because none of us enjoys thinking about these things—but putting them off doesn’t make them disappear.

Watch the video in full on YouTube caption in comments, then tell me: What is one thing you know you need to put in order?

09/24/2026

You usually see me in the kitchen, but right now I’m away from home, helping my family and finding my way through a very different kind of work. I’m still here. Still creating. Still building Better Butter.

And when I get back to that kitchen? Oh, we’ve got stories to tell—and cookies to bake.

Address

17 W. Spring Street
Cookeville, TN
38501

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 5pm
Wednesday 11am - 5pm
Thursday 11am - 5pm
Friday 11am - 5pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Better Butter Cookie Company posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Better Butter Cookie Company:

Share

Category