Ice House Bakery & Dessert Shop

09/26/2026

Guess What ?????? WE HAVE DONUTS TODAY

We had to make 420 Donuts for the Pymatuning State Park Spooktacular this 2026, se we made extra for all of you to come and enjoy… $1.25 ea..

we even made our extremely popular Maple Bacon, quantities are limited, this is a test run and we will definitely have donuts again next Saturday because we have another 420 to make for the Park / Spooktacular Event.

Come Grab some for Breakfast this morning, go enjoy the activities at Pymatuning (Jamestown end) and then hit us up for Dinner tonight and save with our $10.00 specials… see Ice House Pizza page… best deals around by far!!!

Have a wonderful Saturday all of you!!
814-213-0076 to place orders

09/21/2026

It’s never to early to start talking Party Trays with the fast approaching holiday/festive season ahead.

Halloween, Thanksgiving, Christmas, New Years,
Columbus Day, Veterans Day, Hanukkah, and many others that are not listed…

What ever your Event, we want to plant the seed now for you to consider letting us make your trays this year.

We will soon have our Christmas Cookies setup done for those of you that want to buy cookies by the pound and add them to your own trays.. or to just have and snack on… we are happy to say we can hold our price from last year at $12.99 per lb.

Here’s some pics of Trays to refresh you Memory, we do all kinds of Trays..

Cookies, Cake n Cookies, Brownies n Cookies, Cake Roll n Cookies, Fruit, Fruit n Cookies, Veggie, Veggie n Cheese, Meat n Cheese, Meat-Cheese n Veggie, Fruit-Veggie n Cheese or any combination you can think of, we love a challenge,… there are lots of pics below.. so take a seat and scroll through them.. this is a fraction of what we have done and can do for you…

So, start your planning now and let us help you out… order early is recommended also..

Call us at 814-213-0076, we would love to help!!

05/22/2026

If you need Dessert this weekend, stop in at Ice House in Conneaut Lake… we are LOADED!!!

Pies, Brownies, Lava Cakes, Square Cakes
Cake Bombs, CheeseCake like Crazy
Cookies, More Pies, Cream Pies, Fruit Pies,
Mini Pies, Baklava, Lemon Bars, Cannolis

Check out the work we did on the Catering side the last 2 days… and lots lots more going out tonight and all weekend….

https://www.facebook.com/share/p/176ZMr4kDy/?mibextid=wwXIfrl

So let us at Ice House put the Dessert on your table and plate this weekend, and you can just sit back and relax during the holiday weekend..

Call us at 814-213-0076 for yummy stuff or stop in and be blown away with our selection.

390 Water Street, Conneaut Lake, Pa. 16316

04/19/2026

04/05/2026

We had lots of fun helping the Buckles & Breeches 4H group with an event they participated in on Saturday 04/04 in Crawford County..

If you’re ever in need of goodies that you can sell to make money on for your group or organization, let us know and we will help you out too…

Thank Buckles & Breeches 4H for letting us help you!!! It was a lot of fun for us to be here for you!

04/03/2026

Happy Easter in advance everyone..

We baked/made a bunch of Pies for this weekend, and we are having an Easter 🐣 Pie Sale for YOU!

* Dutch Apple
* Cherry
* Strawberry Rhubarb
* Peach
* Cinnamon Apple
* Blueberry
* Southern Pecan
* Banana Cream
Chocolate Cream
Boston Cream
* Coconut Cream
* Peanut Butter Cup Cream (w/ Chocolate)
(Also in Gluten Free)
Peanut Butter Explosion (no Chocolate)
(Also in Gluten Free)
* French Chocolate Silk
* Lemon Cream


$16.00 per Pie… while they last… we will make some more tomorrow, but no promised tour flavor flavor will be here, but you can call ahead and ask us to save you a flavor.

We are also making several Gluten Free Pie Flavors for our Gluten Free Friends

We also Baked lots and lots of Gourmet Cookies today.. for your Dessert Pleasure and Snacks

Call us 814-213-0076 or stop in at Ice House Bakery in Conneaut Lake, Pa. Downtown