Fat Arnie’s Sandwich Shop

Fat Arnie’s Sandwich Shop Contact information, map and directions, contact form, opening hours, services, ratings, photos, videos and announcements from Fat Arnie’s Sandwich Shop, Restaurant, 4404 Indianola Avenue, Columbus, OH.
(1)

Ohio State vs. Illinois at noon. Rafters. Fat Arnie’s. Apollonia in hand. Drink nearby.We’re pretty sure this is heaven.
09/26/2026

Ohio State vs. Illinois at noon. Rafters. Fat Arnie’s. Apollonia in hand. Drink nearby.
We’re pretty sure this is heaven.

Pork Belly TacoCured and roasted pork belly, green onion and jalapeno Salsa, pickled green apple, onion and cilantro
09/24/2026

Pork Belly Taco
Cured and roasted pork belly, green onion and jalapeno Salsa, pickled green apple, onion and cilantro

Some sandwiches are lunch. La Barbosa is a character arc.
09/23/2026

Some sandwiches are lunch. La Barbosa is a character arc.

This Friday, 5PM–10PM, our man Rob Curtis and Rafters will be throwing a fundraiser supporting The MAGIC Foundation! ❤️T...
09/22/2026

This Friday, 5PM–10PM, our man Rob Curtis and Rafters will be throwing a fundraiser supporting The MAGIC Foundation! ❤️

The MAGIC Foundation is a nonprofit that supports children and adults affected by growth and endocrine disorders, providing education, advocacy, resources, and support to families navigating these conditions.

And we’re putting our empanadas to work. 🥟

Fat Arnie’s will donate $1 for every empanada sold during the fundraiser.

📍 Rafters Beer Pub
🗓️ This Friday
⏰ 5PM–10PM
(Fat Arnie’s will be open until 9)

Come grab some food, have a drink, and support a great organization. We’ll see you Friday! ❤️

Craving an empanada? 🥟Every one is hand rolled, filled, folded, and sealed by our killer team.A lot of work goes into th...
09/22/2026

Craving an empanada? 🥟

Every one is hand rolled, filled, folded, and sealed by our killer team.

A lot of work goes into these little pockets of happiness. Worth every bite.

The Apollonia
09/19/2026

The Apollonia

Watch at Rafters Bee Pub!
09/19/2026

Watch at Rafters Bee Pub!

Pork Belly TacoCured and roasted pork belly, green onion and jalapeno salsa, pickled green apple, onion and cilantroBack...
09/17/2026

Pork Belly Taco
Cured and roasted pork belly, green onion and jalapeno salsa, pickled green apple, onion and cilantro

Back on the menu!

Wednesdays specialChicken Sandwich is back! You guys were definitely not quiet about it when it went away 😂 Adobo marina...
09/16/2026

Wednesdays special
Chicken Sandwich is back! You guys were definitely not quiet about it when it went away 😂

Adobo marinated chicken thigh with radicchio, arugula and cilantro. Chile lime crema and house pickles. Now on a Matija Breads potato bun.

Address

4404 Indianola Avenue
Columbus, OH
43214

Opening Hours

Wednesday 5pm - 9pm
Thursday 5pm - 9pm
Friday 11am - 9pm
Saturday 11am - 9pm
Sunday 11am - 7pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Fat Arnie’s Sandwich Shop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Fat Arnie’s Sandwich Shop:

Shortcuts

Share

Category