Ahlemeyer Bakery

Ahlemeyer Bakery We are a small family bakery that has been in Columbus over 35 years! Ahlemeyer Bakery is a family owned and operated bakery in Columbus, Indiana.
(4)

We sell a variety of pies, cookies, brownies, sweet rolls, breads and other baked goods. We even carry the Indiana state pie- Sugar Cream! Our goal is quality, baking fresh products every day. Because of this we can run out quickly, so please feel free to call and place an order if there is something specific you are looking for. Our number is 812-372-7437. Great for holidays, birthdays, special gatherings, or for no occasion at all!

Oh man…..today is the day to come into the bakery if you want to try some things from our Father’s Day menu!German Choco...
06/17/2026

Oh man…..today is the day to come into the bakery if you want to try some things from our Father’s Day menu!

German Chocolate Pie - whole and in slices
Peanut Butter Pretzel Pie - whole and in slices
Payday Pie - whole and in slices
Fresh Strawberry Pie - whole made to order (only need about 10 minutes to execute)
Key Lime Pie - whole in about 2 hours
Lemon Bars
German Chocolate Brownies

COME SEE US!!!!

Father's Day is NEXT WEEKEND!!!!For us, Father's Day is all about GERMAN CHOCOLATE!!! If you have ever been to the baker...
06/13/2026

Father's Day is NEXT WEEKEND!!!!

For us, Father's Day is all about GERMAN CHOCOLATE!!! If you have ever been to the bakery, you know how much of a staple this frosting is for us.......thick, caramel-y, coconut-y, and filled with pecans!

Our specialty menu this time around has a ton to offer: two extra special pies, lots of cake options, quiche for breakfast, and tangy crumble bars.......in addition to all of our standard menu!

Ways to place an order:
1. Shoot us a message through our page or Instagram page
2. Call the bakery at 812-372-PIES (7437) and make sure to leave a message if we are closed.....Sam will get back to you!
3. Come visit us at the bakery at 2034 17th Street open Tuesday-Saturday

It’s SCONES FRIDAY!!Three flavors available in packs of twoCheddar BaconLemon BlueberryGlazed MapleWhen these are gone, ...
06/12/2026

It’s SCONES FRIDAY!!

Three flavors available in packs of two
Cheddar Bacon
Lemon Blueberry
Glazed Maple

When these are gone, they are GONE FOR THE DAY!!
Always available by order!

Open until 6pm

*Cheddar Bacon Chive Scones are ready!!
06/11/2026

*Cheddar Bacon Chive Scones are ready!!

Happy Thursday!! 🤓We had a special order for our Spring Market Scones... So we made extra!!Lemon Blueberry & Glazed Mapl...
06/11/2026

Happy Thursday!! 🤓
We had a special order for our Spring Market Scones... So we made extra!!
Lemon Blueberry & Glazed Maple are on the shelf now!!

06/10/2026

We are already struggling with the heat and will be closing up early……see you all tomorrow!!

If you love peaches, come see us today!!!Gooey Mini this week is Brown Butter Peach!Rich butter cake filled with homemad...
06/05/2026

If you love peaches, come see us today!!!

Gooey Mini this week is Brown Butter Peach!
Rich butter cake filled with homemade peach compote and drenched in brown butter caramel sauce

We also have Fresh Strawberry Pies and Payday Pies in store available until we run out of berries!

Open Friday 10-6 and Saturday 10-2

06/03/2026

We have only had two customers this morning so we are going to be closing up early.

CLOSING WEDNESDAY 3PM

Happy Slices Wednesday!!!We have some fun things this week to try and stay on theme with fresh strawberries!!Mock Strawb...
06/03/2026

Happy Slices Wednesday!!!

We have some fun things this week to try and stay on theme with fresh strawberries!!

Mock Strawberry Shortcakes - cupcakes filled with fresh strawberries coated in our homemade strawberry goo and covered with homemade vanilla whipped cream
*Available with lemon, vanilla, or chocolate cake*

PB Cream Pie - two peanut butter cookies filled with decadent peanut butter frosting

Cherry Pie - Sam’s favorite! Tart cherries and our traditional pie crust….what more could you want?!?

Open until 6pm

Good morning!! We had *a lot* of cupcakes go out this morning and we have a few left over!! 12 vanilla (white)12 vanilla...
05/30/2026

Good morning!! We had *a lot* of cupcakes go out this morning and we have a few left over!!

12 vanilla (white)
12 vanilla (yellow)
6 funfetti (yellow)
6 chocolate
9 lemon
6 carrot cake

I have white, chocolate, lemon, & cream cheese frostings!

**CALL** to reserve your cupcakes!

812-372-7437
Open until 2pm! ❤️🧁

Address

2034 17th Street
Columbus, IN
47201

Opening Hours

Tuesday 2pm - 6pm
Wednesday 10am - 6pm
Thursday 10am - 6pm
Friday 10am - 6pm
Saturday 10am - 2pm

Telephone

+18123727437

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Ahlemeyer Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category