Peggy Jean's Pies

07/23/2026

You Have No Idea.

Maybe earlier this week, you saw on social media that we dropped Jeanne off for her summer vacation with her twin sister Janie. A few people have stopped by the stores this week to ask how she’s faring and I’m here to basically say that she is THRIVING. She reports that they purchased 10 cases o...

07/19/2026

We dropped Jean off this week for summer vacation with her twin sister! (And by summer vacation, we mean drinking 12 Diet Cokes a day and chasing down Internet conspiracies via YouTube🤷‍♀️)
***
Let’s hope she decides to come back in a week or two. Fall baking season will be here soon!
***

07/16/2026

We fully bake all of our fruit😉
***

07/16/2026

We fully bake all of our fruit😉
***

07/10/2026

Ingredients in our Broccoli Cheddar Quiche: Whole Eggs, Heavy Whipping Cream, Cheddar Cheese, Broccoli, Onion (and for the crust: Water, Salt, Shortening, All Purpose Flour).
***
Ingredients in La Terra Fina Broccoli Cheddar Quiche (sold nationwide in mass market retailers): Egg Whites, Whole Milk, Enriched Wheat Flour, Broccoli, Mild Cheddar Cheese, Palm Oil, Water, Onion, Canola Oil, Sharp Cheddar Cheese, Corn Starch, Cane Sugar, Sea Salt, Butter, Isolated Oat Fiber, Dried Garlic, White Pepper, Black Pepper, Nutmeg, Cayenne Pepper.
***
We make our quiche from scratch and place it in our merchandising freezers at both stores. You purchase and bake at home! In just one hour, you have a completely from-scratch meal on your table, completely free of palm oil and sugars❤️
***
Available in Broccoli Cheddar, Bacon Cheddar, Sausage Cheddar, and Vegetable (spinach, mushroom, onion) at both locations in both the six-inch and nine-inch sizes.
***

07/07/2026

July Pie of the Month: BANANA CREAM! We layer freshly sliced bananas in our from-scratch vanilla custard and finish it with fresh whipped cream. Banana Cream is a perennial favorite amongst the PJP fan base. And Curious George endorsed, obviously😉
***
Artist: Ellery Miller (follow her work the_ellery_edition )
***

06/29/2026

Happy Birthday, America! To celebrate our 250th, we are doing TWO celebration themed pies this week🇺🇸
***
American Flag Pie: our iconic White Chocolate Strawberry Pie with the addition of fresh strawberries and blueberries to create the flag pattern. Available in nine-inch only (gluten free modification available.)
••
Francis Scott Key Lime Pie: Key Lime with blueberry and raspberry purée to create the flag and white chocolate stars. Available in nine-inch or six-inch (gluten free modification available). Bonus points if the pun made you as happy as it made us.
***
Store availability will be limited this busy week, so please consider pre-ordering online or via phone to ensure availability! We are open regular hours this week, but closed on Saturday, July 4th❤️
***

06/24/2026

GOOSEBERRIES ARE BACK!🎉💯💕. We’ve been waiting literal MONTHS for these boys to be back in town and we couldn’t be happier to have them back in our stores.
***
(A heartfelt thanks to our food rep Justin from Sysco Foodie who scoured the ends of the continental United States for this popular but outrageously difficult fruit to find. You can’t even guess the serious business behind sourcing gooseberries. Netflix US should call me.)
***
Gooseberry pie on shelves in stores for, well…forever🤞
***

06/22/2026

She’s beauty, she’s grace…well, she’s the best pie in the United States! Our nationally recognized White Chocolate Strawberry pie goes patriotic with the addition of fresh blueberries and strawberries for the loveliest addition to your holiday celebration🇺🇸
****
Order the American Flag pie now online by phone for pickup at either location for your July 4th festivities. To allow for the fresh fruit decoration, this pie is only available in the nine-inch size. It is available gluten-free and/or with a vegan crust but is not available sugar-free. The cost is $30.
****
We are just certain this pie will be the best addition to your holiday dessert table! We can’t wait to see you soon!
****

06/17/2026

Don’t forget dad this weekend! Secure his favorites by ordering now online or by phone for pickup on Friday or Saturday at either of our two Columbia locations!
***
Full menu available online!
***
Graphic: Ellery Miller
***