Out & Out

Out & Out Cedarburg’s Best Mac & Cheese, Custard, Panini’s & More! Stop by and visit us soon! To stay true to our roots, we incorporated the OUT-doors into our new decor.
(325)

Back in 2006, we founded Out & Out in the vacated Dairy Queen walk-up stand that had occupied this corner for 54 years. Seven years later, we had outgrown the space, and we were offered the opportunity to develop the corner with Commerce State Bank. Many thanks to Joe Fazio and his team of awesome bankers, who have been instrumental to our development of this building. The Out & Out name derived f

rom the fact all the food was take-OUT, you had to stand OUT-side to order, and you had to eat OUT-side. Out & Out has always been a quirky, frugal, and practical place to eat well and eat local. Naturally, we incorporated our quirkiness, frugality, and practicality into the de cor. We believe in free-cycling, repurposing, and reusing everything. The stage is set by the floor-to-ceiling glass walls and the Cedar Creek Park mural painted by local artist Chuck Weber. The plywood butterflies that perch along the vestibule were won at an Earth Day auction held by Anthropologie in the 3rd Ward. (Money raised went to protect and restore America’s forests.) Lab stool tops painted by Out & Out employees Teia, Taylor, and Kim add whimsical OUT-door scenes. Photos by UW–Madison student Ali Brown capture the fox kits born under a campus building in spring of 2014 and complete the nighttime bathroom scene. Lucky Star Workshop's Jake Knox and team helped us build a vision for the dining room using our Craigslist finds. Industrial arts table tops from the Racine School District, classroom chairs from Kenosha School District, outdoor bleacher boards from the Whitefish Bay School District, booths from a bowling alley in Palmyra, table bases from South Milwaukee, and even a barn door from our own barn kept the quirkiness alive and the project costs under control. This year has been a long and winding road. Catering out of the old Barth's building downtown and running a temporary custard stand in the old Towne Barber Shop has proven a real challenge. Thank you for sticking with us—we hope you enjoy the new Out & Out. Eric and Jackie Fix...and our awesome team!

The Masters are on ⛳️Watching at work? Watching at home?Either way… Arnold Palmer with your takeout 🍋🧊outandoutcustard.c...
04/09/2026

The Masters are on ⛳️

Watching at work? Watching at home?

Either way… Arnold Palmer with your takeout 🍋🧊

outandoutcustard.com/order

First ever Out & Out tees are here 👕We finally made shirts—soft, comfortable, and available in blue, gray, or pink.Just ...
04/07/2026

First ever Out & Out tees are here 👕

We finally made shirts—soft, comfortable, and available in blue, gray, or pink.

Just $19.99

Stop in to grab one or DM us and we’ll ship it your way.

Sizes vary by color.

outandoutcustard.com

What a birthday.We had a lot of fun celebrating 20 years with you.Thank you for showing up, sharing stories, and being p...
04/03/2026

What a birthday.

We had a lot of fun celebrating 20 years with you.

Thank you for showing up, sharing stories, and being part of what makes this place special.

We’re really grateful — and we’re excited for what’s ahead.

outandoutcustard.com

20 years doesn’t happen by accident.It starts with someone willing to build something from the ground up — and care abou...
04/02/2026

20 years doesn’t happen by accident.

It starts with someone willing to build something from the ground up — and care about it enough to do it the right way… and the kind of place people wanted to come back to.

Thank you, Eric, for creating Out & Out and trusting the team to carry it forward as employee owners.

We’re grateful for what you built — and we’re proud to carry it forward.

These guys used to hang out here playing checkers and drinking shakes…pretty good chance they’re in college now.20 years...
04/02/2026

These guys used to hang out here playing checkers and drinking shakes…
pretty good chance they’re in college now.

20 years goes fast.

We’d love to hear your favorite Out & Out memory over the years —
share it below and we’ll pick one to win a pan of mac & cheese.

outandoutcustard.com

Last call for Easter!Sides? Cover it with our famous Mac & CheesesHam & glaze? We've got that covered too!Skip the prep ...
04/01/2026

Last call for Easter!

Sides? Cover it with our famous Mac & Cheeses
Ham & glaze? We've got that covered too!

Skip the prep and pickup everything ready to go from Out & Out

Order now before the weekend:
outandoutcustard.com > go to "request catering" tab

Closed Easter Sunday - Pickups on Saturday 4/4

Easter made easy.Take & bake Mac & Cheese — ready when you are 🧀✔️ $34.99 per pan✔️ Perfect holiday side✔️ Pickup Saturd...
03/31/2026

Easter made easy.

Take & bake Mac & Cheese — ready when you are 🧀

✔️ $34.99 per pan
✔️ Perfect holiday side
✔️ Pickup Saturday 4/4

We’ll be closed Easter Sunday (4/5), so plan ahead.

Order now at outandoutcustard.com

From takeout windows… to this.A lot of meals — and memories — have been made here.👇👇👇Who would you share one more with?W...
03/29/2026

From takeout windows… to this.

A lot of meals — and memories — have been made here.

👇👇👇

Who would you share one more with?

We’ll pick a couple responses and treat you both to dinner for two 🍽️

Our 20th Birthday is just around the corner 🎉Do you know how Out & Out got its name?👇👇👇We’ll be sharing the answer (and ...
03/28/2026

Our 20th Birthday is just around the corner 🎉

Do you know how Out & Out got its name?

👇👇👇

We’ll be sharing the answer (and a few surprises) over the next few days.
Tag someone who’s been coming here since the early days.

We couldn’t be more proud to receive our official license plate from Mel's Charities and the artist behind them, Quinn. ...
03/26/2026

We couldn’t be more proud to receive our official license plate from Mel's Charities and the artist behind them, Quinn. These are more than decorations, they are a sign of our ongoing commitment to Mel’s Charities and the communities we serve. Thank you Quinn, this has found a prominent home in our dining room!

Address

W61N305 Washington Avenue
Cedarburg, WI
53012

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 9pm
Tuesday 10am - 9pm
Wednesday 10am - 9pm
Thursday 10am - 9pm
Friday 10am - 9pm
Saturday 10am - 9pm
Sunday 10am - 9pm

Telephone

+12623775515

Website

http://www.outandoutcatering.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Out & Out posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category