Pie In The Sky Pizza Cayucos

Pie In The Sky Pizza Cayucos Naturally Fermented Artisan Pizza by the Beach

Introducing 🍷Thirsty Thursdays🍷 All wine bottles are now half off with pizza purchase on Thursdays! (If you prefer to pr...
05/14/2026

Introducing 🍷Thirsty Thursdays🍷

All wine bottles are now half off with pizza purchase on Thursdays! (If you prefer to pre order your pizza online, no problem! Just ask to add on a bottle when you arrive for pick up)

We have some awesome things from and more right now! Come grab them to get you to Friday 😎

“The Notorious B.B.Q.” hits the shop today! New seasonal special: Sweet & spicy BBQ base, mozzarella, shredded chicken, ...
05/09/2026

“The Notorious B.B.Q.” hits the shop today!

New seasonal special: Sweet & spicy BBQ base, mozzarella, shredded chicken, red onion, cilantro.

Oh, and you’re definitely going to need a side of house made ranch. We recently zhuzh’d it up and it’s 🤌

Starting Saturday we will be open until 8:00pm! We heard you needed more hours in your life to enjoy a pizza by the beac...
04/09/2026

Starting Saturday we will be open until 8:00pm! We heard you needed more hours in your life to enjoy a pizza by the beach, and we happen to agree.

*To make this happen we will be closed tomorrow, 4/9, but we’ll be back with our new hours on 4/10!

03/13/2026

Join us ✨inside✨ the shop starting this weekend!!

You can now come on in and browse our favorite products, stock up on wine bottles, & more coming soon.

We had hoped to reopen this weekend but installation on our new (to us) pizza ovens is taking a bit longer than expected...
01/23/2026

We had hoped to reopen this weekend but installation on our new (to us) pizza ovens is taking a bit longer than expected. We’ll be sure to post as soon as we are ready to welcome you back, we miss serving up your favorite pizza! 🍕

Alright Pizza Pirates! We are getting NEW PIZZA OVENS 🙌 We’re so excited to be increasing the amount of pies we can put ...
01/14/2026

Alright Pizza Pirates! We are getting NEW PIZZA OVENS 🙌

We’re so excited to be increasing the amount of pies we can put out per hour and be able to add more seasonal offerings. We’ll be closed this week for the construction, thank you Cayucos for supporting us so much that we outgrew our oven 🙏

Listen…. We know it’s January and we’re all trying to eat our veggies. But we all know we still want pizza, right?Introd...
01/09/2026

Listen…. We know it’s January and we’re all trying to eat our veggies. But we all know we still want pizza, right?

Introducing “Caesar the Day”, available just in time for dinner tonight.

Use the “order food” link on our page for details.

We will be back & ready for you on 12/26! Wishing you & yours a lot of love, rest, and good food 🎄
12/24/2025

We will be back & ready for you on 12/26! Wishing you & yours a lot of love, rest, and good food 🎄

If you’re looking to send a little love to the pizza lover in your life, we’ve got you covered. We are open this Thursda...
12/18/2025

If you’re looking to send a little love to the pizza lover in your life, we’ve got you covered. We are open this Thursday-Monday to help you finish your stocking stuffing!

December Special has dropped, your favorite neighborhood pizzeria is now open on Thursdays, & it’s gorgeous in Cayucos. ...
12/04/2025

December Special has dropped, your favorite neighborhood pizzeria is now open on Thursdays, & it’s gorgeous in Cayucos. It truly is the most wonderful time of the year 🎄🍕

(Kale ‘em With Kindness: Pesto, Goat Cheese Crumbles, Crispy Kale, Spicy Red Sauce Dollops)

Address

156 1/2 Ocean Front Avenue
Cayucos, CA

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Pie In The Sky Pizza Cayucos posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Pie In The Sky Pizza Cayucos:

Shortcuts

Share

Category