Betty Kaye Bakery

Betty Kaye Bakery We offer a variety of items ranging from homemade breads, cookies, cupcakes, and our famous brownies. We are Carroll County's oldest and finest bakery.

Weekends features- peach bars, lemon bars, lemon and raspberry bars, and salted caramel brownies, old fashioned maple, m...
08/28/2026

Weekends features- peach bars, lemon bars, lemon and raspberry bars, and salted caramel brownies, old fashioned maple, maple nut or cinnamon rolls, giant cinnamon rolls, lemon cream pies, chocolate raspberry , red velvet, and maple cupcakes, burnt almond tortes, and assorted twist breads

It’s Tuesday again and we hope everyone had a great weekend! Our Tuesday features are- sourdough and multigrain breads, ...
08/25/2026

It’s Tuesday again and we hope everyone had a great weekend! Our Tuesday features are- sourdough and multigrain breads, lemon raspberry, chocolate covered strawberry, caramel apple, salted caramel, red velvet, and raspberry chocolate chip brownies

Weekends features- chocolate covered strawberry, caramel apple, salted caramel, and red velvet brownies, banana, cappucc...
08/21/2026

Weekends features- chocolate covered strawberry, caramel apple, salted caramel, and red velvet brownies, banana, cappuccino, and lemon cupcakes, assorted football cutouts, and assorted decorated cakes. This is just a SMALL sampling of what we have to offer this weekend. Stop in and check out the rest

Weekends features- lemon blueberry delights, old fashioned maple, giant cinnamon rolls, raspberry filled donuts, peanut ...
08/14/2026

Weekends features- lemon blueberry delights, old fashioned maple, giant cinnamon rolls, raspberry filled donuts, peanut butter iced cream sticks, white and chocolate haystacks, fresh peach bars, and mini croissants

Happy weekend everyone! Fresh peach bars are back! White brownies with fresh peaches and a light cinnamon sugar icing ...
08/13/2026

Happy weekend everyone! Fresh peach bars are back! White brownies with fresh peaches and a light cinnamon sugar icing

Weekends features- fresh peach crisp (we had this on Wednesday and it flew out of here fast), lemon, lemon raspberry, An...
08/07/2026

Weekends features- fresh peach crisp (we had this on Wednesday and it flew out of here fast), lemon, lemon raspberry, Andes mint, and cookies n cream brownies, peanut butter iced cream sticks, old fashioned cinnamon and maple rolls, giant cinnamon rolls, sour dough bread, and back to school cutouts

Thursday’s features- back to school cookies and fresh peach bars with a light vanilla icing topped with cinnamon and sug...
08/06/2026

Thursday’s features- back to school cookies and fresh peach bars with a light vanilla icing topped with cinnamon and sugar

Wednesday feature- Fresh peach crisp! I made it last night at home for a trial run, and let me tell you it is out of thi...
08/05/2026

Wednesday feature- Fresh peach crisp! I made it last night at home for a trial run, and let me tell you it is out of this world delicious!! It’s already baked, all you need to do is warm it up and grab some ice cream

If you have ever thought that working at a bakery would be fun, here’s your chance- We are looking for a baker! Applican...
08/04/2026

If you have ever thought that working at a bakery would be fun, here’s your chance- We are looking for a baker! Applicants need to be available to work everyday Tuesday- Saturday (midnight shift), have some baking experience, and be a team player. Pay is based on experience. Stop in anytime Tuesday-Saturday 7:30-5 and fill out an application if you are interested.

It’s Tuesday and we are happy to be back for the week! Our features today include- 4” lemon, chocolate, strawberry, and ...
08/04/2026

It’s Tuesday and we are happy to be back for the week! Our features today include- 4” lemon, chocolate, strawberry, and white cakes, as well as a 7” white cake with red raspberry filling and our mock cream icing

Address

72 West Main Street
Carrollton, OH
44615

Opening Hours

Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm
Saturday 9am - 5pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Betty Kaye Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Betty Kaye Bakery:

Shortcuts

Share

Category