Fine Fellows Creamery

Fine Fellows Creamery Blending creamery+artistry; offering a unique twist on frozen creations. Try our Liege Waffle! Yum Fine Fellows Creamery: blending creamery and artistry.
(263)

OPENED MAY 2015

Fine Fellows is the creation of Dustin Piccolo and David Kinsey. We bring the feeling of the traditional soda fountain shop and marry it with a modern perspective. Inspired by bringing people together, we have endeavored to make ice cream our vehicle for creating memorable experiences. Our premium ice cream has been hand crafted for over 160 years at America's oldest ice cream com

pany, Bassetts Ice Cream in Philadelphia. We are excited to bring this creamy goodness to our customers. Supplementing our Bassetts offerings are a variety of non-dairy, gluten free and vegan options. We think ice cream should be enjoyed by everyone. We develop unique seasonal sundae creations inspired by honest ingredients and whimsical themes. Fill your bowl & your soul.

Stop by today at 6pm to meet congressional candidate Zack Mullock and get the scoop on his vision for South Jersey. Happ...
05/31/2026

Stop by today at 6pm to meet congressional candidate Zack Mullock and get the scoop on his vision for South Jersey.

Happy to provide a forum for honest dialogue with voters and citizens. Rock that vote.

Another artistic expression and utilitarian device created by our very own chief scooper. Cones cones cones.
05/15/2026

Another artistic expression and utilitarian device created by our very own chief scooper. Cones cones cones.

Grab your yum this weekend. You know you love local honey 🍯 and heath bar sprinkled on top of raspberry truffle. You’ll ...
05/08/2026

Grab your yum this weekend. You know you love local honey 🍯 and heath bar sprinkled on top of raspberry truffle. You’ll be blown away by this delicious treat.

Always great to see our fellow business owner friends. David and I always visit this Stone Harbor favorite at the start...
05/01/2026

Always great to see our fellow business owner friends. David and I always visit this Stone Harbor favorite at the start of the season. Always a great meal, always wonderful service. Our season kickoff tradition continues. Thanks for the delicious meal John. See you again in September. 😆

Today we celebrated the April birthdays in our family. Excited to have the Piccolo, Silver, & Piccolo-Kinsey clan all at...
04/19/2026

Today we celebrated the April birthdays in our family. Excited to have the Piccolo, Silver, & Piccolo-Kinsey clan all at FineFellows today. Happy birthday fam. 🎂 🎆 💕

04/18/2026

Update: This event was canceled due to the weather and all those with tickets got an email and a refund.
Attention all animal lovers! 🦉🦁🦜🐸

Join us for a quiet, crowd-less walk through the Cape May County Zoo! You will have the chance to chat with some zookeepers and zoo docents, and gain insight about your favorite zoo animals.

Check out the link below for tickets. This event will take place on April 25th from 6pm to 8pm; tickets are required for entry. All proceeds benefit the Cape May County AAZK Chapter, which is dedicated to providing the zoo animals with enrichment, promoting zookeeper continued education, and raising money for animal conservation around the world!

TIX: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/critter-crawl-tickets-1986085374820?aff=oddtdtcreator
Or visit Eventbrite.com and search for "Critter Crawl"

04/18/2026

☀️🏖Only 5 weeks until Memorial Day Weekend! Cape May days, ocean breezes, and summer memories are right around the corner. Perfect time to plan your Cape May MAC trolley rides and tours.
Visit capemaymac.org to purchase your tickets today!

I promise there’s enough to go around.
04/17/2026

I promise there’s enough to go around.

There’s a triple threat for you. Only at fine fellows.
04/10/2026

There’s a triple threat for you. Only at fine fellows.

Big thanks toMargaret Mary, Allan Ramnath, Holly Epstein Ojalvo, Peter C. Burkefor all your support! Congrats for being ...
11/01/2025

Big thanks to

Margaret Mary, Allan Ramnath, Holly Epstein Ojalvo, Peter C. Burke

for all your support! Congrats for being top fans on a streak 🔥!

Address

313 Beach Avenue
Cape May, NJ
08204

Opening Hours

Monday 1pm - 8pm
Thursday 4pm - 9pm
Friday 1pm - 9pm
Saturday 12:30pm - 10pm
Sunday 12:30pm - 8pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Fine Fellows Creamery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Fine Fellows Creamery:

Shortcuts

Share

Category