M and M's Sweet Retreat

09/19/2026

Brave enough to face the weather today? You’ve earned a treat! 🌧️✨

Warm up and treat yourself to:

🍫 Cocoa Krispie Treats
🧁 German Chocolate Cupcakes
🍪 Oatmeal Cream Pies

Come grab yours before they're gone!

09/18/2026

If you haven't tried their crab rangoon pizza, tonight is the perfect night for it!

🎶 Live Music & Friday Night Football Tonight! 🏈

Looking for the perfect Friday night plans? We’ve got you covered!

Join us tonight from 6:00 PM – 8:00 PM for incredible live acoustic tunes with the amazing Allie Ryan! 🎤🎸

Stick around or pull up a chair because the Eastside vs. Fairfield game will be streaming LIVE on our TVs starting at 7:00 PM! 📺🔥

Come hungry, come ready to relax, and check out tonight's specials:

-The Everyday Special: Two of our famous sausage rolls for just $19.99! 🥖

-Drink Special: Domestic buckets starting at just $15!
🍻

📍 133 S. Broadway St., Butler
📞 260-337-0222
🌐 eatcheesy.com

09/18/2026

The pie hype has been real this week! 🥧
Freshly restocked in the case right now:

🍎 Apple Crumble
🍑 Peach Crumble

Grab a slice (or a whole pie) before they vanish again! ✨

09/16/2026

Sweet news for your Wednesday: the case is fully stocked and calling your name! 🥧✨

Here is what is ready and waiting for you today:

Pies: Peach Crumble, Blueberry, and Peanut Butter

Bars & Brownies: Cranberry Bars and Cream Cheese Brownies

The Classics: Our usual cookie lineup + our selection of ice cream!

Drop by, pick your favorite treat, and make your day a little sweeter.

What are you grabbing first? 😋

09/13/2026

Back to our regularly scheduled programming today, but the sweet lineup hasn't changed! 🍪✨ We still have treats waiting for you—stop by today for something delicious!

09/12/2026

☀️ Bright & Early News! We’re opening two hours early today at 9 AM (instead of 11) to host our friends from The Refuge Community Church until noon! We can’t wait to hang out and see everyone.

Because it's a special morning, we loaded up the display case with extra goodies:

Special Treats: Chocolate Strawberry Puppy Chow & Cookie Butter Brownies are BACK!

New Additions: Classic Sugar Cookies & a Cherry Pie in the case.

Bonus: We are serving COFFEE today only (just a little preview until our permanent machine arrives later this month)!

Plus, we still have some favorites ready to go:

Banana Nut Muffins
Banana Pudding Parfaits
Cherry Cheesecake
Custard Pie

Stop by, say hi, grab your morning caffeine, and treat yourself! ☕✨

📍 Open today starting at 9 AM!

09/10/2026

Did you know our cookies are T-Rex approved? Well, they are! 😁🦖

09/10/2026

Looking forward to being a part of this community outreach event with The Refuge Community Church !

09/09/2026

🍁 The "BRRR" months are officially here, and the cozy treats are calling! 🍁

Here’s what’s fresh in the case this week:

🍌 Banana Pudding Parfaits (They’re BACK!)
🥧 Creamy Custard Pie
🍒 Rich Cherry Cheesecake
🧁 Banana Nut Muffins (loaded with real walnuts!)
🥣 Cinnamon Toast Crunch Treats (Limited leftovers—grab 'em fast!)

Plus, our usual lineup of cookies and ice cream is fully stocked.

✨ Drop by today and grab your favorites before they’re gone!

09/05/2026

Butler, you’ve been asking for milkshakes since Day 1—and we listened! 🥤✨

This weekend, we’re running a special test batch! Made with the same ice cream you love, ice cold milk, and some of our toppings blended right in, they’re guaranteed to sweeten up your weekend.

Here’s what else is stocked in the case today:

✨ Cinnamon Toast Crunch Treats
🍪 Our Signature Cookie lineup
🥧 Cherry & Apple Pie Slices (limited left!)
🧁 Plus more sweet treats

Stop by this weekend, snag your favorite treat, and let us know what you think of the shakes! 👇