What are the opening hours?

Monday 5pm - 10pm Wednesday 5pm - 10pm Thursday 5pm - 10pm Friday 12pm - 10pm Saturday 12pm - 10pm

Extra Extra

New York style Pizzeria

10/27/2026

heavy hitters featured on our current menu: drink # 65, pizza # 28, and the fall salad

check our the rest of our new menu in person or to go 5-9 today!! (can't believe none of you have ordered a cherry cola yet!!!)

10/26/2026

Extra Small appreciates all of our topping offerings: today it's vegan pepperoni

See you all later for Bottle Monday Madness

10/22/2026

a little love for pizza #27💋

this is a new signature pie that feels like a familiar hug: vodka sauce, aged mozz, pesto, and ricotta

pull up a seat 5-9 tonight (or take it to go--bed pizza is good for the soul)

10/20/2026

the scariest ghost you know is probably just a damp polishing rag

or the poorly stickered faces of your local pizza co-op workers😱

(not ai)

10/15/2026

day 4 of New Menu week: Extra Small is here and they're trying some new menu items

Japanese sweet potato + salted maple twist

Pizza # 27 (vodka sauce, aged mozz, ricotta pesto) + pizza # 28 (white sauce, sausage, delicata squash, kale, hot maple)

Come on in 5-9 today and check out other new offerings like our fall cocktail list and a new by-the-glass w**e!

10/13/2026

who wants a pizza party??

host your next event, cater a lunch, or see us at a large scale function: ✨extra extra does it all✨ we offer customizable food + bev menus (have you heard about our ice cream bar??), intimate and memorable vibes, with personal touches for each occasion🫶

bonus: dates are still available for 2026 holiday parties but they fill up quickly so let us know!!

to learn more, check out our website and fill out an inquiry under the Private Events + Catering tab!

10/12/2026

ok ok here's a pic of the fall salad that isn't a screenshot

kale, delicata squash, pumpkin seeds, maple vinaigrette

10/11/2026

new pizzas new drinks new ice cream new lamp new everything

🍕pizza # 27 vodka sauce, aged mozz, pesto, ricotta
🍕pizza # 28 white sauce, aged mozz, spicy sausage, delicata squash, kale
🥗kale + squash salad (yes, we added another salad!!)
🍹new fall cocktails + new Fancy Lemonade: CHERRY 👋we're saying goodbye to ginger + passionfruit lemonade

check back in digitally or IRL this week for closeups of our new menu starting with Bottle Monday tomorrow!!!

10/09/2026

hello we have new soft serve flavors

japanese sweet potato + maple (or a twist of the two if you know what's good for u)

stay with us for more new menu things in the coming week🫨

10/05/2026

another day of LGBTQ+ history month, another top tier q***r-made product we want to highlight🌩️

we've had SUPERGAY SPIRITS 🍸💕✌🏻 organic craft vodka on our top shelf for a while now but it's always worth a revisit!! Supergay vodka is made from 100% organic corn from local producers in small batches and filtered through activated coconut charcoal. smooth, clean, supergay💋

Supergay is a q***r owned and operated distillery in Yonkers, New York. Not only are their spirits joyful, organic, and crafted with care, they also commit a percentage of their profits to local LGBTQI+ organizations 🤝

While it is still Bottle Monday (yes come get ur lil bottles of w**e at 50% off menu price), order a vodka soda, cosmopolitan, or vodka martini to start (or end) your night😘

Address

549 West Utica
Buffalo, NY
14213

Opening Hours

Monday	5pm - 10pm
Wednesday	5pm - 10pm
Thursday	5pm - 10pm
Friday	12pm - 10pm
Saturday	12pm - 10pm

Website

http://Www.extraextrapizza.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Extra Extra posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Extra Extra:

Want your business to be the top-listed restaurant in Buffalo?