Old City Pizza

Old City Pizza Authentic Neapolitan pizza. Handmade pasta. Premium ingredients, done right. Featuring Spot Coffee ☕
A new concept from the Pearl Street Family.

Buffalo, NY | Now Open!

Thanks Step Out Buffalo for the shout out!
08/29/2026

Thanks Step Out Buffalo for the shout out!

Food & Drink News 12 new Buffalo restaurants to try this fall, from a hidden pizza spot to a celebrity chef steakhouse.

08/20/2026

Just can’t get enough on 1/2 off pizza day! It’s Thursday! You know what that means - all pizzas are 1/2 off after 4pm. Dine in or takeout 🍕

08/18/2026

Guess who's back? Welcome back Janet!

Order up!
08/15/2026

Order up!

08/13/2026

Is Thursday the best day for pizza? Yup. Here is why:

All of our bread and dough is scratch-made with flour from Italy. Authenticity + Deliciousness = 😄
08/11/2026

All of our bread and dough is scratch-made with flour from Italy. Authenticity + Deliciousness = 😄

Everything we make is special. But this is special special.
08/06/2026

Everything we make is special. But this is special special.

08/05/2026

You know what day it is?

Buffalo’s best secret breakfast sandwich - Made with homemade focaccia bread, melted cheese, egg, and savory pancetta. ...
08/04/2026

Buffalo’s best secret breakfast sandwich - Made with homemade focaccia bread, melted cheese, egg, and savory pancetta. In the historic authentic speakeasy celler under the Pearl Street Grill Tuesday-Friday 7am!!

Address

76 Pearl Street
Buffalo, NY
14202

Telephone

+17162742300

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Old City Pizza posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category