Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe

Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe Bagel Island specializes in New York Style Bagels made fresh daily along with a full line of breakfast and lunch options.

POV: your camera roll after visiting Bagel Island 🥯🌴A little sunshine, a lot of bagels, and approximately 47 pictures of...
09/17/2026

POV: your camera roll after visiting Bagel Island 🥯🌴

A little sunshine, a lot of bagels, and approximately 47 pictures of your food.

Come hungry. Leave with content.

09/15/2026

We will be closed 16th-18th
We will be back to normal hours for the weekend!
🥯🏝️☀️🛳️

Bagels, good vibes, and the occasional… rooster? 🐓 You never know what you’re gonna find in the Keys. 😂🌴Come hungry, lea...
09/15/2026

Bagels, good vibes, and the occasional… rooster? 🐓 You never know what you’re gonna find in the Keys. 😂🌴

Come hungry, leave happy. 🥯

FloridaKeysEats

💕💕💕
09/09/2026

💕💕💕

We are thrilled to announce the grand opening of Beach Bliss Beauty Salon! Come soak in the serene atmosphere and discover your new go to spot for all things BEAutiful!

Stop in and check us out today or book online at- squareup.com/u/U1HTJLZR

5800 Overseas Hwy
Suite #33 (next to Anthony’s)
305-393-0450
We can’t wait to see you!


Triggering the cravings one sandwich at a time. 🤤🥓🥯Come to Bagel Island and grab yours! 🌴☀️
09/08/2026

Triggering the cravings one sandwich at a time. 🤤🥓🥯

Come to Bagel Island and grab yours! 🌴☀️

🇫🇷🥯 Bonjour, France!Bagel Island has officially made it into the **Routard French travel guide**! 🇫🇷✨From the Florida Ke...
09/03/2026

🇫🇷🥯 Bonjour, France!

Bagel Island has officially made it into the **Routard French travel guide**! 🇫🇷✨

From the Florida Keys to the pages of one of France’s most-loved travel guides — we’re feeling pretty lucky. 🌴🥯

If you’re visiting the keys, come see what all the buzz is about and grab a bagel while you’re here!

📍 Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe
FrenchTravel

09/02/2026

Happy Wednesday!
We will be closed today
We will be back on Thursday!

We LOVE spotting our stickers around town 👀🥯Think you can find one? Consider this your challenge! Find a Bagel Island st...
08/31/2026

We LOVE spotting our stickers around town 👀🥯

Think you can find one? Consider this your challenge! Find a Bagel Island sticker, snap a pic, and tag us so we can see where you found it!

Happy sticker hunting 🌴

Bite into better mornings 🥯🌴Fresh bagels, delicious sandwiches, and all your morning favorites — made for slow mornings ...
08/27/2026

Bite into better mornings 🥯🌴

Fresh bagels, delicious sandwiches, and all your morning favorites — made for slow mornings in Big Pine Key.

Your perfect Keys breakfast starts here.

Address

205 Key Deer Boulevard
Big Pine Key, FL
33043

Opening Hours

Wednesday 7am - 2pm
Thursday 7am - 2pm
Friday 7am - 2pm
Saturday 7am - 2pm
Sunday 7am - 1pm

Telephone

+13058729912

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe:

Shortcuts

Share