Mythical Pizza

Mythical Pizza At MYTHICAL PIZZA, we have a passion for pizza.
(1)

Our flash-fired pizza brings a new feeling to the quick-dine experience, and it allows our mythical customers to take full control!

OOOOH, the BATTLE is in full swing, and this matchup is too close to call! 🍕⚔️Will Beth Smith’s Jersey Devil Italian Sta...
09/03/2026

OOOOH, the BATTLE is in full swing, and this matchup is too close to call! 🍕⚔️

Will Beth Smith’s Jersey Devil Italian Stallion charge to victory? Featuring garlic oil, Sasquatch seasoning, mozzarella, provolone, ham, salami, pepperoni, cherry tomatoes, onion, black olives, and banana peppers, then finished with Arcadian lettuce and an Italian dressing drizzle.

Or will Mary Karol’s Chupacabra Cantina claim the crown? Built with taco sauce, chopped garlic, pulled pork, mozzarella, cheddar-jack, green peppers, red onions, and diced tomato, then topped after bake with basil and red pepper flakes.

This BATTLE is EPPPPPPPIC, head-to-head, and your dinner vote matters! You only have today, tomorrow, and Saturday to try one before a winner in this bracket is crowned. Bring the crew, grab a slice, and help make this a LEGENDARY showdown!

WELCOME SEPTEMBER! 🍂🍕Oh man, it’s that time of year when we start saying goodbye to Summer.... We’ll still have some war...
09/01/2026

WELCOME SEPTEMBER! 🍂🍕Oh man, it’s that time of year when we start saying goodbye to Summer.... We’ll still have some warm days, and Fall technically doesn’t start until September 22nd, but the nights are cooler, the air is crisper, and the pizza is ON POINT.

That means one thing... it's time for a NEW SEASON. NEW OBSESSION!!

We’ve added some seriously LEGENDARY new menu items, starting with our brand-new BREAKERS. 🔥 Not a sandwich. 🔥 Not a pizza. 🔥 Something gloriously in-between.

Build your Breaker exactly how you want it and we’ll serve it hot and fresh!

We’ve also added new sauces like Canadian Spice, our spicy-maple-style sauce, Mango Habanero, and Sweet Vidalia Onion. Use them on pizza, pasta, Breakers, wings and more.

And by popular request... DRY RUBS are here! These include:

🦶 Sasquatch Seasoning
🥔 Cryptid-Craving Home Fry
🍯 Tangy & Sweet Vinegar
🦀 Old Bay
🍋 Lemon Pepper

You can even add them to your pizza edge!!

New toppings include breaded chicken, buffalo-tossed diced breaded chicken, cheese & garlic croutons, and post-bake Arcadian lettuce.

And yes... we went wild with stuffed crust too.

🔥 Buffalo-tossed diced chicken
🔥 Smoked turkey burnt ends & barbecue

Dessert is getting ridiculous too:

🍎 MONSTER Apple Caramel Crisp Cookies
🍌 Cookie Butter Banana Cheesecake (Back by CUSTOMER DEMAND!)
🥕 Grandma Bigfoot’s Ice Carrot Cart (Another CUSTOMER FAVORITE!)
🥧 Tatzelwurm’s Bavarian Custard Apple Pie
🎃 Grafton Monster Pumpkin Patch Cheesecake

BUT THAT’S STILL NOT ALL... We’re now serving 7" FRENCH-BREAD LOAF PIZZAS AND GARLIC BREADS.

OHHHH THESE ARE EPPPPIC. 🔥🍕🥖 So get in here (or order online) and start enjoying your new obsession today!!

While ROUND 2 starts today, we know what you’re really wondering... Who won the first bracket of ROUND 1?! 👀🍕Was it 🦋 Pe...
08/31/2026

While ROUND 2 starts today, we know what you’re really wondering... Who won the first bracket of ROUND 1?! 👀🍕

Was it 🦋 Peyton McCoy’s Mothman’s Mac Attack, loaded with pulled pork, bacon, mac & cheese, and crispy fried onions?

Or was it 🐍 Rebecca Kern’s The Basilisk Parm, which basically tasted like a fresh chicken parmesan dinner on a pizza with ricotta, fresh mozzarella, and breaded chicken?

Well...

With 64% of last week’s purchase votes...

🥁🥁🥁

The winner is...
..
..
..
..
..

🦋 PEYTON MCCOY’S MOTHMAN’S MAC ATTACK!! 🍕🔥

That means Peyton’s LEGENDARY creation will be back again in a few weeks once the other three brackets have been decided, and Mothman’s Mac Attack will face a brand-new competitor for a shot at the championship!

Who will ultimately reign supreme?

That part is up to YOU, because your purchases decide the winner.

Now... on to ROUND 2! 👀🍕

IT’S THE LAST DAY OF ROUND 1 IN THE LEGENDARY PIE HUNT!! 🍕🏆Who’s taking home this bracket’s victory?Will it be Peyton Mc...
08/29/2026

IT’S THE LAST DAY OF ROUND 1 IN THE LEGENDARY PIE HUNT!! 🍕🏆

Who’s taking home this bracket’s victory?

Will it be Peyton McCoy’s MOTHMAN’S MAC ATTACK? Or will Rebecca Kern’s THE BASILISK PARM claim the win?!

AHHH! WE CAN’T TAKE THE BACK AND FORTH EXCITEMENT!! One pie takes the lead, then the other lands a one-two punch the very next day!

This battle is coming down to YOU. YOUR ORDERS DECIDE THE WINNER!

Order your favorite TODAY, rally your team, and give your pie the final push it needs to advance!

What does YOUR perfect Friday night pizza look like? 🍕🔥Classic pepperoni? Every topping you can fit? A bold drizzle and ...
08/28/2026

What does YOUR perfect Friday night pizza look like? 🍕🔥

Classic pepperoni? Every topping you can fit? A bold drizzle and a LEGENDARY crust finish?

Whatever you’re craving, bring the whole crew to MYTHICAL PIZZA tonight and MAKE YOUR PIZZA A REALITY!

No cooking. No dishes. Just YOUR pizza, YOUR way!!

Tell us your favorite Mythical Pizza in the comments! 👇

It's almost time for ROUND 2!! 🍕🏆The next head-to-head battle runs Monday, August 31st through Saturday, September 5th. ...
08/28/2026

It's almost time for ROUND 2!! 🍕🏆

The next head-to-head battle runs Monday, August 31st through Saturday, September 5th. The pizza with the most purchases during the sales week advances to the next round!

And keep an eye out next week because we’ll announce the Round 1 winner!

This week’s battle:

Jersey Devil Italian Stallion by Beth Smith
(garlic oil, sasquatch seasoning, mozzarella, provolone, ham, salami, pepperoni, cherry tomato, onion, black olives, and banana peppers. Finished with Arcadian lettuce and an Italian dressing drizzle)

VS.

Chupacabra Cantina by Mary Karol
(taco sauce, shredded pork, mozzarella, cheddar, green peppers, onions, diced tomato, garlic, basil, and red pepper flakes)

Beth and Mary, it’s time to rally your friends, family, neighbors, coworkers, teachers, pastors, and every pizza lover you know. Shares and support matter!

Who will advance in the LEGENDARY Pie Hunt? Come hungry and cast your vote with every pie!! 👀🍕

ROUND 1 of The LEGENDARY Pie Hunt is ON FIRE, and YOU get to decide which creation survives the hunt. 🔥We’ve been making...
08/26/2026

ROUND 1 of The LEGENDARY Pie Hunt is ON FIRE, and YOU get to decide which creation survives the hunt. 🔥

We’ve been making these beasts all week, and they’ve been FLYING out the door.

Peyton McCoy’s Mothman’s Mac Attack has alfredo, mozzarella, cheddar-jack, pulled pork, bacon, and mac and cheese, then gets finished with crispy fried onions and a ranch drizzle.
.. and that's up against ...

Rebecca Kern’s The Basilisk Parm brings marinara, breaded chicken, ricotta, mozzarella or fresh mozzarella, garlic oil, and basil.

Customers who have summoned both agree that choosing a favorite is TOUGH!

Every purchase counts as your vote. You have until close of business Saturday to order your favorite and help send it into the next round.

Will you follow Mothman’s cheesy call, or stare down the Basilisk?

Are you Team Mac Attack or Team Chicken Parm? 👀🍕

We’re kicking off ROUND 1 of The LEGENDARY Pie Hunt with an exciting week of head-to-head pizza battles, and YOU get to ...
08/24/2026

We’re kicking off ROUND 1 of The LEGENDARY Pie Hunt with an exciting week of head-to-head pizza battles, and YOU get to decide who moves on to the next round! 🍕🔥

This week’s showdown:

🦋 Peyton McCoy’s Mothman’s Mac Attack vs. 🐍 Rebecca Kern’s The Basilisk Parm!!

These two truly LEGENDARY creations are available starting TODAY through Saturday, August 29th ONLY!

And this one is completely in your hands... Your purchases are your votes! Every time you order one of these competing pies, you’re helping decide which creation moves on to the next round of The LEGENDARY Pie Hunt!

So which pie are you backing this week!?

Come hungry. Pick your pie. Help crown a LEGEND!! 🍕🔥

08/22/2026

We found a lost, scared, and VERY hungry turtle outside today… swimming in a suspicious pool of green ooze. 🐢☢️

And if our childhood taught us anything about adolescent turtles, it’s that we’re pretty sure they like pizza….. 🤔

Turns out, this one DEFINITELY does!! 🍕😂

So be like this turtle and come enjoy some TOTALLY RADICAL pies today at Mythical Pizza!!

Cowabunga, dudes! 🐢🍕

Address

1855 Valley Road, Suite #200
Berkeley Springs, WV
25411

Opening Hours

Monday 11:30am - 9pm
Tuesday 11:30am - 9pm
Wednesday 11:30am - 9pm
Thursday 11:30am - 10pm
Friday 11:30am - 10pm
Saturday 11:30am - 10pm

Telephone

+13044026984

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Mythical Pizza posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category