07/14/2026
Do you want a chance to win a $250 Mythical Pizza gift card just for sharing your favorite pizza idea? Then you’ll want to be part of our new contest: THE LEGENDARY PIE HUNT: A CRYPTID CREATOR SHOWDOWN! 🏆🍕We’re searching for the NEXT LEGENDARY SIGNATURE PIZZA at Mythical Pizza, and this time, the recipe is coming from YOU, our awesome customers!
Think you can create a pizza worthy of becoming a Mythical legend? Simply comment below with your idea for the BEST PIZZA you can dream up! 🍕
Tell us exactly what goes on it. The sauce, the cheese, the toppings, the finishing touches! You can use any of our current toppings, or think outside the pizza box and suggest something we may not have even considered before.... 🤔
Sweet, spicy, savory, cheesy, meaty, veggie-packed or completely unexpected. We want to see what you’ve got!
There’s no need to name your pizza when you enter. Once the champion is crowned, we’ll give the winning creation its official Mythical Pizza name, and the creator’s name will be permanently featured alongside it on our 2027 menu.
🚨 Please remember that we cannot use shellfish, peanuts or tree nuts due to cross-contamination and allergy concerns.
We’ll keep this post PINNED at the top of our page through August 18th, 2026, the first official day of school for students in Morgan County!
After entries close, our amazing Mythical Crew will review all of your creations and select the TOP 8 PIES to enter the official bracket!
HERE’S WHERE IT GETS REALLY FUN…
The eight finalists will face off in head-to-head matchups, with two customer-created pizzas available for two weeks at a time.
Each pizza will be clearly featured on our menu screens with the creator’s name, such as: Alexander Hamilton’s Signature Creation (You know, provided your name is Alexander Hamilton…and if so, that’s pretty awesome).
The winner of each matchup will be decided by HOW MANY PIZZAS SELL DURING THAT TWO-WEEK PERIOD. Whichever pie has the highest total sales advances to the next round!
That means if your pizza makes the Top 8, you’ll want to tell absolutely everyone!! Share it with your friends, family, nieces, nephews, neighbors, coworkers, workmates, church group, bowling team and anyone else who loves pizza!!
Bring them in! Get them to order your creation! Rally your people and help your pie move forward in the bracket! Online (including DoorDash) and In-Store sales count towards your totals!
Each pizza will only be available during its scheduled two-week matchup unless it wins and advances. The surviving pies will continue battling until only one delicious creation remains!!
Eventually, one pizza will be crowned: 👑 THE LEGENDARY SIGNATURE PIE CHAMPION! 👑
The winning creator will receive:
- 🍕 Their pizza featured on our 2027 Mythical Pizza Menu
- ✍️ Their name permanently featured alongside the winning Signature Pie
- 📸 A permanent picture at Mythical Pizza of them with their winning Signature Pie (seriously, start handing out autographs, because you'll be a celebrity with us!)
- 💳 A massive $250 MYTHICAL PIZZA GIFT CARD (That’s a lot of dough. Literally!)
QUICK FAQ:
Can I submit more than one pizza?
- Absolutely! Submit as many different creations as you’d like. Please place each pizza idea in its own comment so we can keep everything organized.
Do I need to name my pizza?
- Nope! Just give us the full pizza idea and toppings. Once the winner is crowned, we’ll give it its official Mythical Pizza name (and forever keep your name attached to it).
Can I suggest toppings Mythical Pizza doesn’t currently carry?
- Yes! New ingredients may be considered as long as they can be safely sourced, reasonably prepared and properly handled in our kitchen.
Are any ingredients prohibited?
- Yes. We cannot accept recipes containing shellfish, peanuts or tree nuts due to cross-contamination and allergy concerns.
How are the Top 8 selected?
- Our Mythical Crew will review the entries based on creativity, flavor potential, ingredient availability, kitchen practicality and how well the pizza fits the Mythical Pizza menu.
How does each matchup work?
- Two pizzas will be available for two weeks. The pizza with the highest total sales during that period advances.
Is the winner selected through Facebook voting?
- No. Likes, comments and shares do not determine who advances. The bracket is based entirely on actual pizza sales.
How long will each pizza be available?
- Each pie will only be initially available during its scheduled two-week matchup. Winning pizzas (or in the rare case tied entries) will return during the next round until they are eliminated or crowned champion.
Will customers know who created each pizza?
- Absolutely! Each bracket pizza will be clearly displayed on our menu screens with the creator’s name.
What happens if multiple people submit similar pizzas?
- Our crew will consider the complete recipe, creativity and the order in which the ideas were submitted.
Could Mythical Pizza adjust my recipe?
- Possibly. Small changes may be required based on ingredient availability, food safety, preparation requirements or kitchen operations. We’ll keep the original concept as close as reasonably possible.
When do entries close?
- Entries will be accepted through August 18th, 2026. Comments submitted after the deadline may not be considered.
Can I like and share the post?
- Please do! Like it, share it and tag someone who could create the next great Mythical Pizza masterpiece.
And if your pizza makes the bracket, keep sharing. Your pie only moves forward by outselling the pizza it’s battling!
Drop your creation in the comments and help us find the NEXT LEGENDARY SIGNATURE PIZZA! 🍕🔥
