Coyle's Ice Cream

Coyle's Ice Cream The best homemade ice cream and cakes since 1985! Sit in one of our booths or at our soda fountain -
(503)

Islip Location - 509 Main Street, Islip, NY 11751 (indoor/outdoor seating)
Bay Shore Location - 75 Howells Rd., Bay Shore, NY 11706 (indoor)

07/10/2026

Welcome to Long Island’s first-ever late-night homemade ice cream shop, right here in downtown Bay Shore. Serving fresh, homemade ice cream long after the dinner plates (and maybe a few cocktails 😉🍸) are cleared.

Don’t worry, our original Bay Shore shop is still serving up all your favorites. This is simply one more place to grab a homemade scoop — until MIDNIGHT on weekends!

Because the best nightcap might just come in a waffle cone 🍦🌙🪩

07/08/2026

Our newest Coyle’s location is opening this FRIDAY, July 10 — and it’s open til MIDNIGHT Fridays-Sundays! 🪩🍨💥

📍17 E Main St, Bay Shore
🗓️ July 10, 2026
⏱️ 12:00PM

Thanks to all who came out for Cops n Cones! We can’t wait to see you at the next one! 🚔🍦⭐️🔜🧯
07/07/2026

Thanks to all who came out for Cops n Cones! We can’t wait to see you at the next one! 🚔🍦⭐️🔜🧯

07/02/2026

COPS N CONES
🗓️ July 7, 2026
⏰ 12:30-2:30pm
📍Coyle’s Lindenhurst
🍦 Children 12 and under get free soft serve ice cream. Meet your local police officers and explore their vehicles!

See you there 😉🚔

Coffee on the way to the beach…ice cream on the way home ☕️🦌🍦Our July Flavor of the Month was created with our friends a...
07/01/2026

Coffee on the way to the beach…ice cream on the way home ☕️🦌🍦

Our July Flavor of the Month was created with our friends at Kismet Coffee, Kitchen & Cocktails, inspired by their Brown Butter Toffee Cookie Latte. A rich, brown butter coffee-infused base, layered with crunchy Heath Bar pieces and Biscoff cookies.

It’s everything we love about summer on Long Island: local spots, familiar faces, and the little traditions that somehow become the memories you keep coming back to.

Available all July.

Summer hours start TODAY, which means more time for post-beach cones, after-dinner sundaes, and the little ice cream tra...
06/29/2026

Summer hours start TODAY, which means more time for post-beach cones, after-dinner sundaes, and the little ice cream traditions that make a Long Island summer feel like 🍨🏖️🇺🇸🤸🏽‍♀️🍒

Cops n Cones is back! Come down to Coyle’s Lindenhurst on Tuesday, July 7 for some summertime fun. Rain or shine!🍦🚔🌞 ...
06/28/2026

Cops n Cones is back! Come down to Coyle’s Lindenhurst on Tuesday, July 7 for some summertime fun. Rain or shine!🍦🚔🌞

06/24/2026

Our new coloring pages are here at our Islip location, giving little artists something fun to enjoy between bites of their favorite scoop 🎨🍨💛

Because a trip to Coyle’s is about more than just ice cream. It’s about making memories in the little moments.

Our homemade Monster Mash is a wild combination of chocolate ice cream, creamy peanut butter, fluffy marshmallow, carame...
06/22/2026

Our homemade Monster Mash is a wild combination of chocolate ice cream, creamy peanut butter, fluffy marshmallow, caramel swirls, and crunchy waffle cone pieces...try it and tell us what you think! 🧇🍫🥜

Address

75 Howells Road
Bay Shore, NY
11706

Opening Hours

Monday 3pm - 10pm
Tuesday 12pm - 10pm
Wednesday 12pm - 10pm
Thursday 12pm - 10pm
Friday 12pm - 11pm
Saturday 12pm - 11pm
Sunday 12pm - 10pm

Telephone

+16316662229

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Coyle's Ice Cream posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category