PeterPan Diner

PeterPan Diner Contact information, map and directions, contact form, opening hours, services, ratings, photos, videos and announcements from PeterPan Diner, 999 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore, NY.

✅️ OFFICIAL page
📍999 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706
🤳 631-665-1788
🕗 Sun-Thu 8A-10P
Fri & Sat 8A-11P
🗓 Since 1955
❤️ Same heart, new chapter!

Probably the hardest decision you’ll ever have to make 😉1️⃣ Texas Smoke 💨 2️⃣ New Champ 🏆3️⃣ Peter Pan Panini 🧚4️⃣ Chick...
08/23/2026

Probably the hardest decision you’ll ever have to make 😉
1️⃣ Texas Smoke 💨
2️⃣ New Champ 🏆
3️⃣ Peter Pan Panini 🧚
4️⃣ Chicken Avocado BLT Wrap 🥑
5️⃣ Loaded Double Smash Burger 🍔
:
:
:

08/23/2026

We've got different portion sizes for every palette, even Super Sammich Bros 😂

Happy National Potato Day!If you could only eat two of these taters the rest of your life, which ones are you choosing?T...
08/19/2026

Happy National Potato Day!

If you could only eat two of these taters the rest of your life, which ones are you choosing?

The good news is that either way you can still get all of these choices at PeterPan Diner

08/16/2026

What shore is the best shore on Long Island?

We're are so thankful for every customer we've had in our 71 years serving Bay Shore, and we truly love when you share y...
08/13/2026

We're are so thankful for every customer we've had in our 71 years serving Bay Shore, and we truly love when you share your experience by tagging us and checking-in to PeterPan Diner!

08/08/2026

The waiting is over! You can now order delivery on peterpandiner.com with 'toast' or on Uber Eats, Door Dash, and Grubhub 🤳

You can also select pick-up when you order ahead or call 631-665-1788

🥵 Too hot to cook and you want to stay at home in the A/C, but you're craving PeterPan Diner? We can help! Order deliver...
08/06/2026

🥵 Too hot to cook and you want to stay at home in the A/C, but you're craving PeterPan Diner? We can help!

Order delivery with 'toast' on peterpandiner.com or on Uber Eats, Door Dash, and Grubhub 🤳

You can also select pick-up when you order ahead or call 631-665-1788

The countdown is on!
08/05/2026

The countdown is on!

08/02/2026

Should Peter take Nick to see 'Spider-Man: Brand New Day' to make up for ripping his Spider-Man poster as a kid?

Address

999 Sunrise Highway
Bay Shore, NY
11706

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 10pm
Tuesday 8am - 10pm
Wednesday 8am - 10pm
Thursday 8am - 10pm
Friday 8am - 11pm
Saturday 8am - 11pm
Sunday 8am - 10pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when PeterPan Diner posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share