Nicholas Creamery

Nicholas Creamery Nicholas Creamery makes homemade, small batch ice cream using natural dairy and the purest of ingredi Cash only
(450)

They said bring back the cannoli…so we did. 🤌 Then we folded it into the creamiest, dreamiest ice cream you’ve ever tast...
08/28/2026

They said bring back the cannoli…so we did. 🤌 Then we folded it into the creamiest, dreamiest ice cream you’ve ever tasted. Cannoli Shells & Cannoli Cream + lotsa chocolate chips all swirled into a small batch of unforgettable homemade ice cream. One bite and you’ll be saying fuhgeddaboudit.

Scooping at ALL 7 Nicholas Creamery locations!
🍨Wall (2435 Route 34)
🍨Tinton Falls (1201 Sycamore Ave)
🍨Atlantic Highlands (84 First Ave)
🍨Fair Haven (585 River Rd)
🍨Long Branch (444 Ocean Ave)
🍨Middletown (1500 Route 35)
🍨North Brunswick (224 Grand Ave)
Open every day until 10pm.

Pick your player. 🍦Cookie Dough ➡️ Housemade Oatmeal Crumble.
08/26/2026

Pick your player. 🍦
Cookie Dough ➡️ Housemade Oatmeal Crumble.

Nicholas Creamery Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownie (RESTOCKED!) + Lemon Pie- drop these flavors in a warm, made from scra...
08/21/2026

Nicholas Creamery Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownie (RESTOCKED!) + Lemon Pie- drop these flavors in a warm, made from scratch waffle cone and make this Jersey Shore weekend count!!! Walk in, Doordash or Uber Eats😎

🍋 Lemon Pie: Homemade lemon sweet cream ice cream with a lemon curd swirl and yummy shortbread pieces.

🍫 Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownie: Homemade Valrhona dark chocolate ice cream with peanut butter and crushed brownies.

More flavors:
🍅 Jersey Tomato
🌿 Basil Vanilla
🌽 Jersey Corn
🍉 Watermelon Chocolate Chunk
🍑 Peach
🥭 Mango Lassi
🤎 Root Beer Float
🩵 Cotton Candy
💜 Black Raspberry Chocolate Chunk
🍪 Brown Sugar Cookie Dough
🥃 Bourbon Coffee Chocolate Chunk
🍫 Vegan Chocolate
🌿 Mint Chocolate Chunk
🍦Tahitian Vanilla
🍫 Good Old Fashioned Chocolate
🥜 Peanutbutterpalooza
☕️ Hudson Cafe Coffee Crunch
🍒 Cherry Vanilla
💖 Pink Lemonade Sorbet
🌈 Rainbows & Clouds
And more!

📍Long Branch (444 Ocean Ave N)
📍Fair Haven (586 River Road)
📍Atlantic Highlands (84 First Ave)
📍Middletown (1500 Route 35)
📍Tinton Falls (1201 Sycamore Ave)
📍Wall (2435 Route 34)
📍North Brunswick (224 Grand Ave)

Another PEAK Jersey summer weekend at Nicholas Creamery. In homemade, small batch ice cream form. 🌿Basil Vanilla- Summer...
08/14/2026

Another PEAK Jersey summer weekend at Nicholas Creamery. In homemade, small batch ice cream form.

🌿Basil Vanilla- Summer basil meets our crafted vanilla base in a slow steeped infusion that's all about no short cuts and balance.

🍅Jersey Tomato- Homemade Tomato Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Heirloom Tomato Marmalade

🌽Jersey Corn- Homemade Sweet Cream ice cream + a sweet Jersey corn pudding swirl. It's almost gone... so hurry!

🍉Watermelon Chocolate Chunk- Pureed Watermelon, Sweet Cream Ice Cream + handfuls of chocolate chunks.

🍑Peach- Homemade Peach Sweet Cream ice cream + a jammy peach swirl.

Local. Seasonal. Housemade in Jersey.

Open until 10pm tonight.

Small Batch Flavor Lineup:
Basil Vanilla
Jersey Tomato
Peach
Watermelon Chocolate Chunk
Jersey Sweet Corn
Butter Pecan
Black Raspberry Chocolate Chunk
Brown Sugar Cookie Dough
Bourbon Coffee Chocolate Chunk
Vegan Chocolate
Cookies N Cream
Mint Choc Chunk
Hudson Coffee Crunch
Rainbows & Clouds
Tahitian Vanilla
Old Fashioned Chocolate
Peanutbutterpalooza
and more!

Who is ready to take a flight… to DELISH TOWN!!???? 4 HOMEMADE, small batch scoops means 4 different flavor journeys. Bu...
08/10/2026

Who is ready to take a flight… to DELISH TOWN!!???? 4 HOMEMADE, small batch scoops means 4 different flavor journeys. Buckle up kids... it’s a helluva ride!! ✈️

Flavors include:
🌽 Jersey Corn
🍉 Watermelon Chocolate Chunk
🍑 Peach
🍫 Ole Fashioned Chocolate
🥜 PeanutButterPalooza
🤎 Brown Sugar Cookie Dough
✨ Vegan Chocolate
☕️ Hudson Cafe Coffee Crunch
💚 Mint Chocolate Chunk
🤍 Tahitian Vanilla
🖤 Cookies N Cream
🌈 Rainbows & Clouds
🥃 Bourbon Coffee Chocolate Chunk
🍓 Strawbrries N Cream
💖 Pink Lemonade Sorbet
& more!

Middletown (1500 Route 35), Tinton Falls (1201 Sycamore Ave), Long Branch (444 Ocean Ave N) Atlantic Highlands, 84 First Avenue), Fair Haven (586 River Road), Wall (2435 Route 34) are open every day at 11am-10pm! North Brunswick opens at Noon.

Jersey summer. In ice cream form. 🍉🍑🌽We took the Garden State’s greatest hits and made them scoopable.🍉 Watermelon Choco...
08/07/2026

Jersey summer. In ice cream form. 🍉🍑🌽
We took the Garden State’s greatest hits and made them scoopable.

🍉 Watermelon Chocolate Chunk — Watermelon, Sweet Cream + handfuls of chocolate chunks.

🍑 Jersey Peach — Peach Sweet Cream + a jammy peach swirl.

🌽 Jersey Corn — Sweet Cream + a sweet Jersey corn pudding swirl. Freaked out? Trust us on this one… it’s our most requested flavor.

Local. Seasonal. Homemade in Jersey.
Because the Garden State understood the assignment. 🫶

Open 11am–10pm at all 7 scoop shops.

SHUCK YEAH... Nicholas Creamery JERSEY CORN ice cream is BACK BABY! 🌽🍨You want “homemade” and “made from scratch” ... yo...
07/31/2026

SHUCK YEAH... Nicholas Creamery JERSEY CORN ice cream is BACK BABY! 🌽🍨

You want “homemade” and “made from scratch” ... you got it! This is as ALL NATURAL as it gets.... we sauté Jersey Corn in butter and salt and make it into corn pudding. Next up- we whip up a HOMEMADE Sweet Cream ice cream, stir in the corn pudding, give it a spin and BIPPITY- BOPPITY BOO... JERSEY CORN ice cream lands at ALL LOCATIONS.

Open 11am-10pm every day🍦
📍Fair Haven (586 River Road)
📍Atlantic Highlands (84 First Ave)
📍Middletown (1500 Route 35)
📍Tinton Falls (1201 Sycamore Ave)
📍Long Branch (444 Ocean Ave N)
📍Wall (2435 Route 34)
📍North Brunswick (opens at 12 at 224 Grand Ave)

Spoons up for Sunday. 🥄☀️ The sweetest way to spend this beautiful Summer day? Homemade, small-batch ice cream with your...
07/26/2026

Spoons up for Sunday. 🥄☀️ The sweetest way to spend this beautiful Summer day? Homemade, small-batch ice cream with your favorite people. ❤️

Grab a spoon and make your Sunday a little sweeter.

Open 11am-10pm in Middletown, Wall, North Brunswick, Long Branch, Fair Haven, Atlantic Highlands, and Tinton Falls.

Made from scratch ice cream that’s chocolatey, peanut buttery, and fudgy… let’s do it!!!!!🍫🥜 Chocolate Peanut Butter Bro...
07/24/2026

Made from scratch ice cream that’s chocolatey, peanut buttery, and fudgy… let’s do it!!!!!🍫🥜 Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownie is here!

Our HOMEMADE Valrhona dark chocolate ice cream with peanut butter and crushed brownies. If chocolate is your love language, this is gonna be your soulmate. 🥰

Spoons up in Atlantic Highlands, Long Branch, Tinton Falls, Fair Haven, Middletown, Wall, and North Brunswick. Open 11am-10pm every day!

NATIONAL ICE CREAM DAY = FREE SCOOPS, BABY! 🍦🎉 TODAY ONLY, order a LARGE at any Nicholas Creamery location… If your cup ...
07/19/2026

NATIONAL ICE CREAM DAY = FREE SCOOPS, BABY! 🍦🎉 TODAY ONLY, order a LARGE at any Nicholas Creamery location… If your cup has the Nicholas Creamery logo sticker on the bottom, your ice cream is 100% FREE.

1) Order a Large
2) Check the bottom of the cup
3) If you see a Nicholas Creamery logo sticker- your cup is FREE!

There’s 10 sticker cups in each location. Yes, really. Yes, every store. Yes, you better run.

Open 11am-10pm!
🍦Wall: 2435 Route 34
🍦Middletown: 1500 Route 35
🍦Fair Haven: 560 River Rd
🍦Atlantic Highlands: 84 First Ave
🍦Tinton Falls: 1201 Sycamore Ave
🍦Long Branch: 444 Ocean Ave
🍦North Brunswick: 224 Grand Ave

Address

84 1st Avenue
Atlantic Highlands, NJ
07716

Opening Hours

Monday 12pm - 9pm
Tuesday 12pm - 9pm
Wednesday 12pm - 9pm
Thursday 12pm - 9pm
Friday 12pm - 10pm
Saturday 12pm - 10pm
Sunday 12pm - 10pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Nicholas Creamery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Nicholas Creamery:

Shortcuts

Share

Category