Nicholas Creamery

Nicholas Creamery Nicholas Creamery makes homemade, small batch ice cream using natural dairy and the purest of ingredi Cash only
(450)

🍒 THIS IS NOT CHERRY GARCIA 🍒 The Nicholas Creamery homemade, small batch version is the hotter, richer, realer cousin- ...
06/06/2026

🍒 THIS IS NOT CHERRY GARCIA 🍒

The Nicholas Creamery homemade, small batch version is the hotter, richer, realer cousin- loaded with bing cherries and Valrhona chocolate… you don’t want to miss it. 🍒🍫🍨

Scooping at all locations Noon-10pm.

📍Wall: 2435 Route 34, Manasquan
📍Middletown: 1500 Route 35
📍Fair Haven: 560 River Rd
📍Atlantic Highlands: 84 First Ave
📍Tinton Falls: 1201 Sycamore Ave
📍Long Branch: 444 Ocean Ave
🥄 North Brunswick Coming Spoon!

Hey North Brunswick! Love ice cream and want to be the best part of someone’s day? Now hiring:FULL TIME (year-round) Shi...
05/26/2026

Hey North Brunswick! Love ice cream and want to be the best part of someone’s day?

Now hiring:
FULL TIME (year-round) Shift Leads &
SCOOPER positions

Please email your resume to: [email protected].

All Nicholas Creamery locations are OPEN today from 12PM-10PM with fresh waffle cones, fully stocked To Go freezers, and...
05/25/2026

All Nicholas Creamery locations are OPEN today from 12PM-10PM with fresh waffle cones, fully stocked To Go freezers, and all your favorite homemade small batch flavors ready to make your Memorial Day a little sweeter. ❤️

📍 Wall: 2435 Route 34, Manasquan
📍 Middletown: 1500 Route 35
📍 Fair Haven: 560 River Rd
📍 Atlantic Highlands: 84 First Ave
📍 Tinton Falls: 1201 Sycamore Ave
📍 Long Branch: 444 Ocean Ave
🥄 North Brunswick Coming Spoon!

This weather is just rude ☔️🫣… but luckily fresh waffle cones and homemade, small batch Nicholas Creamery ice cream exis...
05/24/2026

This weather is just rude ☔️🫣… but luckily fresh waffle cones and homemade, small batch Nicholas Creamery ice cream exist!🍦😋

Today’s Flavors:
🍋 Lemon Blueberry
💚 Baklava
🥮 La Mondina Olive Oil Cake
🐐 The GOAT
🦁 Lions Roar
🫒 Porta Ricotta & Olive Oil
🍌 MegThings Banana Split
🌈 Taliercio’s Italian Rainbow Cookie
🍫 Good Ole Fashioned Chocolate
🤍 Tahitian Vanilla
🍪 Brown Sugar Cookie Dough
💚 Mint Chocolate Chunk
☕️ Hudson Cafe Coffee Crunch
🥜 Peanutbutterpalooza
🥃 Bourbon Coffee Chocolate Crunch
🖤 Cookies N Cream
🍒 Cherry Vanilla
🍓 Strawberries N Cream
💖 Pink Lemonade Sorbet
🤎 Vegan Chocolate

Walk in from Noon-10pm. We can’t wait to see you walk through the door!!🍦❤️🍦
📍Middletown, 1500 Route 35, NJ
📍Fair Haven, 586 River Road, NJ
📍Long Branch, 444 Ocean Ave, NJ
📍Atlantic Highlands, 84 First Ave, NJ
📍Tinton Falls, 1201 Sycamore Ave, NJ
📍 Wall, 2435 Route 34, NJ
🥄 North Brunswick Coming Spoon!

🚨RAINY MDW EMERGENCY ALERT🚨 Our #1 most-requested flavor heard the rain forecast and said “don’t worry, I got this.” 🌧️...
05/23/2026

🚨RAINY MDW EMERGENCY ALERT🚨 Our #1 most-requested flavor heard the rain forecast and said “don’t worry, I got this.” 🌧️🍪🌈 Italian Rainbow Cookie is BACK and officially carrying Memorial Day Weekend on its delicious little shoulders. One spoonful and suddenly the weather doesn’t even matter anymore. 😌

Available noon-10pm at all locations- Wall, Atlantic Highlands, Tinton Falls, Middletown, Fair Haven, and Long Branch. North Brunswick Coming Spoon in June!

Too cozy to leave the couch? DoorDash + UberEats are ready to deliver happiness directly to your front door. 🥰

📸

If anything can emotionally support the Jersey Shore through ANOTHER rainy Memorial Day Weekend… it’s Megthings Banana S...
05/22/2026

If anything can emotionally support the Jersey Shore through ANOTHER rainy Memorial Day Weekend… it’s Megthings Banana Split & Taliercio's Italian Rainbow Cookie!

Taliercio's Italian Rainbow Cookie
Almond sweet cream ice cream with handfuls of Italian rainbow cookies, chocolate chunks and a raspberry swirl.

Meg Things Banana Split
Housemade Banana sweet cream ice cream with roasted pineapple, maraschino cherries, walnuts & chocolate chunks.

Grab your ice cream scoop squad and kick off the summer with us.

Nicholas Creamery
Open 7 days a week/
11am- 10pm
📍Wall: 2435 Route 34
📍Middletown: 1500 Route 35
📍Fair Haven: 560 River Rd
📍Atlantic Highlands: 84 First Ave
📍Tinton Falls: 1201 Sycamore Ave
📍Long Branch: 444 Ocean Ave
📍North Brunswick (Coming Spoon- in June!)

A little behind-the-scenes truth from the Creamery…The cost of premium chocolate has freaking exploded over the last cou...
05/21/2026

A little behind-the-scenes truth from the Creamery…

The cost of premium chocolate has freaking exploded over the last couple years. (Seriously… google it.)

After mixing, tasting (and cringing 😵‍💫) at test batches made with lower-quality chocolate… we said absolutely not.

We refuse to downgrade the chocolate in our beloved 20-year-old hot fudge recipe. No fillers. No weird shortcuts. No “good enough.” We’re KEEPING the ridiculously rich, small-batch fudge you guys are obsessed with. ❤️

But here’s the rub: at today’s chocolate prices, when we pour hot fudge on your sundae… we literally make NO money on it. ZILCH.

And to sell “to-go” cups at the price we’d actually need to charge to cover costs? Let’s just say… even WE had sticker shock.

So for now, hot fudge is staying an in-store-only experience. It’s our way of protecting the quality you love while still keeping sundaes magical.

At Nicholas Creamery, quality will always win over cutting corners. 🫶🏻🍦

The temps are rising and there’s only one way to handle it… Nicholas Creamery handspun milkshakes!☀️🥤 Each one is made w...
05/18/2026

The temps are rising and there’s only one way to handle it… Nicholas Creamery handspun milkshakes!☀️🥤 Each one is made with our homemade ice cream, blended to creamy perfection, and totally customizable with your favorite toppings.

Cool off, shake things up, and treat yourself to a little taste of sunshine bliss! 😎

Wall (2435 Route 34), Tinton Falls (1201 Sycamore Ave), Fair Haven (586 River Road), Long Branch (444 Ocean Ave), Middletown (1500 Route 35) and Atlantic Highlands (84 First Ave) are locked and loaded with hand spun milkshakes and open till 10pm! North Brunswick Coming Spoon!

Be like Kelly… get the La Mondina Olive Oil Cake ice cream this weekend at Nicholas Creamery. 😉🍊🍰Our Small Batch Cinnamo...
05/16/2026

Be like Kelly… get the La Mondina Olive Oil Cake ice cream this weekend at Nicholas Creamery. 😉🍊🍰

Our Small Batch Cinnamon Orange Mascarpone sweet cream ice cream is loaded with chunks of La Mondina’s HOUSEMADE olive oil cake… weekend plans officially made. 🤗

Wall (2435 Route 34 Manasquan), Middletown (1500 Route 35), Long Branch (444 Ocean Ave N), Atlantic Highlands (84 First Ave), Fair Haven (586 River Road), and Tinton Falls (1201 Sycamore Ave).
🥄 North Brunswick Coming Spoon!

Address

84 1st Avenue
Atlantic Highlands, NJ
07716

Opening Hours

Monday 12pm - 9pm
Tuesday 12pm - 9pm
Wednesday 12pm - 9pm
Thursday 12pm - 9pm
Friday 12pm - 10pm
Saturday 12pm - 10pm
Sunday 12pm - 10pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Nicholas Creamery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Nicholas Creamery:

Shortcuts

Share

Category