My Tomato Pie

09/11/2026

Friday night = wings on the table. 🍗
Grab our Single Wings (10) and pick your sauce: Hot, Medium, Mild, BBQ, Hot BBQ, Garlic Parmesan, Sweet Chili, Sweet Teriyaki, or House Spicy Cajun.
Make dinner easy and get your wings started now.
Order online:

09/08/2026

We’re Closed Until 4 PM Today for Dine In. Take Out still available.

My Tomato Pie is currently closed for a private event. We’ll reopen at 4:00 PM for regular service.

We apologize for any inconvenience and appreciate your understanding. We look forward to serving you this evening! 🍕❤️

See you after 4!

09/04/2026

Dinner plans for the long weekend? We’ve got you.
Swing by My Tomato Pie on Niagara Falls Blvd & East Robinson for homemade-dough pizzas, pasta, wings, and a full bar for Mom & Dad.
Bring the kids too—our place is child-friendly with a kiddie menu.
Reserve your table now:

09/02/2026

Need a non-pizza lunch today? Try our Cranberry Walnut Chicken Salad Sandwich.
All white meat chicken salad with cranberries, walnuts, celery, mayo, and lettuce on a croissant—fresh, filling, and full of flavor.
Order online now:

08/26/2026

Midweek comfort craving? 🍝 Mama Rose’s Restaurant Spaghetti hits the spot—tossed in our homemade tomato sauce and perfect when you want something beyond pizza.

Swing by My Tomato Pie on Niagara Falls Blvd for a cozy, satisfying plate today.

Order online:

08/19/2026

Build-your-own pizza night starts here 🍕
Pick your size (7", 12", or 16"), choose Red Tomato Sauce or White Oil & Herb, then load up your favorite toppings.
Perfect for an easy midweek dinner at My Tomato Pie on Niagara Falls Blvd & East Robinson.
Order online tonight:

08/11/2026

🍕 LOOKING FOR YOUR FIRST JOB? WE’LL TEACH YOU TO MAKE PIZZA! 🍕

$16–$20/HR | NO EXPERIENCE NEEDED!

My Tomato Pie in Amherst is hiring an Entry-Level Pizza Maker and we’ll train you from day one!

This is a great opportunity for high school or college students looking for a first job that works around school, sports, and activities.

🍕 Learn to stretch dough & make pizzas
👨‍🍳 No experience necessary, we train you!
💰 $16–$20 per hour
📚 Flexible scheduling around school & sports
🙌 Fun, fast-paced team environment
📈 Opportunity to learn other kitchen positions & grow with us
➕ Extra weekday shifts may be available

AVAILABILITY NEEDED:
🌙 Weekend nights
☀️ Sundays

If you’re reliable, have a positive attitude, and are ready to learn, we want to meet you!

👉 APPLY TODAY:
https://www.ziprecruiter.com/job/8308f725

PARENTS: Know a student looking for a great first job? Tag them or send them this post! 🍕🙌

06/19/2026

Join Us for an Unforgettable Summer W**e Pairing Dinner at Freedom Run W**ery!

On Friday, June 26th, My Tomato Pie and Freedom Run W**ery invite you to enjoy a spectacular 5-Course Summer W**e Pairing Dinner featuring chef-crafted cuisine perfectly paired with Freedom Run's award-winning w**es.

From a refreshing Caprese Skewer paired with Dry Riesling to a decadent Chocolate Lava Cake paired with Recioto, each course has been thoughtfully designed to highlight the flavors of both the food and w**e.

🍽️ Featured Pairings Include:
• Caprese Skewer & 2024 Dry Riesling
• Crab-Stuffed Haddock & 2024 Oaked Chardonnay
• Creamy French Onion Tortellini & 2017 Pinot Noir
• Herb-Marinated Pork Tenderloin Medallions & 2023 Cabernet Franc
• Chocolate Lava Cake & 2024 Recioto

🌿 Beautiful w**ery setting
🍷 Award-winning w**es
👨‍🍳 Chef-curated menu
🎟️ Limited seating available

This intimate event is expected to sell out, so don't wait to reserve your seat!

📅 June 26th
📍 Freedom Run W**ery

RSVP today and join us for an evening of exceptional food, w**e, and great company.

❤️ Please do us a favor and SHARE this post with your family and friends to help spread the word. We can't wait to see you at Freedom Run W**ery!

https://www.freedomrunw**ery.com/events-1/summer-w**e-pairing-5-course-dinner

**ery **ePairingDinner **eDinner **eCountry **e

06/11/2026

Friends, Family & Loyal Customers — We Need Your Help!

My Tomato Pie has been proudly serving Western New York for over 28 years, and we're honored to be included in the Buffalo News Best of Buffalo Readers' Choice Awards!

If we've ever catered an event, hosted a banquet, made your favorite pizza, served you a Friday Fish Fry, or simply been your go-to neighborhood restaurant, we'd be grateful for your vote.

We're hoping to bring home a win in categories like:
🍕 Best Pizza
🐟 Best Fish Fry
🍽️ Best Caterer
🎉 Best Banquet Facility
❤️ Or any category you feel we've earned!

Please take a minute to vote and support a locally owned family business that's been serving WNY for generations.

Vote Here:
https://buffalonews.com/exclusive/readerschoice/ballot-2026/

Thank you for your continued support, loyalty, and friendship. We couldn't do this without you!

05/19/2026

Porcini Tortellini Pasta is calling 🍝✨ Come savor the special at My Tomato Pie! https://share.google/xNSWV4xj4Kvb8LkAK

Please see https://developers.cloudflare.com/support/troubleshooting/http-status-codes/cloudflare-1###-errors/error-1015/ for more details.