Stuft Catering, Afton, WY (2026)

10/17/2026

Do you want to blow everyone’s mind at Thanksgiving this year?

Cranberry. Jalapeño. Citrus. Chutney.

Yes, you read that right! This is an amazing twist on something that might otherwise feel old and tired. Pour it over a brick of cream cheese and serve it with chips for an extra-special appetizer. Enjoy it over your favorite meat, or eat it straight from the jar. There’s no wrong way to devour it!

Each quart is filled with fresh, homemade deliciousness that’s sure to make you famous with your family and friends. It also makes a wonderful gift—and don’t worry, we won’t tell anyone you didn’t make it yourself!

I’ll be making fresh batches every week throughout November and December. The first batch will be available for pickup on November 5.

It’s $25 per quart, just as it has been for the past six years. However, if you order and prepay by the end of October, you’ll pay only $20 per quart! No limit!

Payment can be made through Apple Pay or Venmo.

This special offer ends when Halloween is over, so be sure to place your order by October 31!

I only make this chutney during November and December, making it a truly special seasonal treat. It also freezes beautifully, so stock up while you can!

Message me here or call/text (307) 886-4486 to order yours.

10/11/2026

🥥🍋‍🟩 NEW FROM STUFT CATERING! A DESSERT YOU HAVE TO TASTE TO BELIEVE! 🍫

Every once in a while, an experiment in the kitchen turns into something truly extraordinary. A couple of days ago, I decided to try something a little different, and the result was honestly one of the most incredible desserts I’ve ever tasted. And believe me, I’ve eaten my fair share of desserts!

Introducing my NEW Roasted Coconut Key Lime Pie with Chocolate Crust & Salted Caramel!

Imagine a rich, decadent chocolate cookie crust filled with a silky, creamy key lime filling infused with delicious roasted coconut. The perfect combination of sweet, tangy, tropical flavors and rich chocolate.

And because I couldn’t leave well enough alone, each pie comes with a side of luscious salted caramel sauce to drizzle over the top.

The combination is absolutely phenomenal! The tartness of the key lime, the nutty sweetness of the roasted coconut, the richness of the chocolate, and that buttery salted caramel create something truly unforgettable.

🥧 9-inch pies — JUST $20 EACH!

📅 ORDERING DETAILS:

* Preorders: Now through Monday at 10 PM
* Pickup: Wednesday in Afton
* Price: $20 per pie
* Payment: Venmo, Facebook Pay, or Apple Pay

💚 Prepayment is required to guarantee your order.

I’m genuinely excited to share this creation with everyone. I’ve made a lot of desserts over the years, but this one has immediately earned a spot among my all-time favorites!

Don’t miss your chance to try one! Send me a message to reserve yours before Monday night’s deadline.

Stuft Catering — Made from scratch. Made with love. Made to be remembered. 💚

10/10/2026

🍰 CHEESECAKE LOVERS, THIS ONE’S FOR YOU! 🍓🍫

Stuft Catering is now taking preorders for homemade cheesecakes!

Rich, creamy, decadent, and made from scratch, these cheesecakes are the perfect treat to share with family and friends. Or keep one all to yourself. We won’t judge! 😉

🍰 THIS WEEK’S CHEESECAKE MENU 🍰

🍫 9” Chocolate Cheesecake — $20
Rich, creamy chocolate cheesecake nestled in a delicious chocolate crust.

🍮 9” Salted Caramel Swirl Cheesecake — $20
Classic creamy cheesecake with a luscious salted caramel swirl, all in a chocolate crust. The perfect combination of sweet and salty!

🍓 9” Strawberry Cheesecake — $20
Delicious strawberry cheesecake in a rich chocolate crust. A match made in dessert heaven!

🍰 10” Classic Cheesecake — $20
Smooth, rich, traditional cheesecake with a buttery graham cracker crust. Sometimes you just can’t beat a classic!

🍓 10” Strawberry Cheesecake — $22
Creamy strawberry cheesecake nestled in a buttery graham cracker crust. Absolutely delicious!

📅 ORDERING & PICKUP DETAILS

⏰ Order Deadline: Sunday night at 10 PM

👨‍🍳 Freshly Made: Monday

📍 Pickup: Tuesday in Afton, near the Kodiak!

💳 PREPAYMENT REQUIRED

To guarantee your cheesecake, payment must be made when ordering. This allows me to prepare exactly what has been ordered, ensuring everything is fresh and made just for you!

Accepted Payment Methods:
• Venmo
• Facebook Pay
• Apple Pay

❤️ Every cheesecake is homemade with care, because you deserve something delicious!

📩 Send Stuft Catering a message to place your order!

Don’t wait until the last minute! Get your order in before Sunday at 10 PM and treat yourself to a little slice of happiness!

STUFT CATERING
Homemade. Delicious. Made with Love.

10/10/2026

A party without cake is just a meeting.
-Julia Child

10/09/2026

Hey everyone. I had several people reach out for catering for June and July of next year, and I told them no because I had other people looking for the same date. I had a couple people ghost me, so those days are now available. If you were still looking for something, please reach out and let me know.
I’m working on changing the way I do booking, so this doesn’t happen anymore
Thanks for understanding.

10/07/2026

🚨 BOOK NOW & DESSERT IS ON ME! 🍰

If you’ve been thinking about booking Stuft Catering for an upcoming event, now is the time!

From now through October 15, any catering event that is booked and paid in full will receive FREE DESSERT FOR EVERYONE AT THE EVENT! 🎉

And I mean any event you book — it doesn’t have to happen this month or even this year. If your event is on my calendar and paid in full by October 15, I’m taking care of dessert for your entire crowd.

Wedding next summer? ✅
Family reunion? ✅
Company party? ✅
Holiday gathering? ✅
Birthday, retreat, anniversary, or just a really good excuse to feed a bunch of people? Absolutely. 😏

My calendar is already filling with events well into 2027, and I intentionally limit the number of events I take each week so I can give every one of them the attention they deserve. Once those dates are gone, they’re gone.

So if you already know you have an event coming up, don’t wait to get on the calendar.

📅 Book & pay in full by October 15
🍰 FREE dessert for your entire party
🗓️ Your event can be anytime I still have availability

You bring the people. I’ll bring the food… and this time, dessert is on me. 😎

Stuft Catering
Great food. Generous portions. No surprise fees.

10/05/2026

🍂 IT’S ALMOST CRANBERRY CHUTNEY SEASON! 🍂

I just realized we’re getting close to one of my favorite times of the year… homemade cranberry chutney season! ❤️

I absolutely LOVE this stuff — and apparently, so does the rest of the valley, because I make and sell a LOT of it every year! 😂

If you’ve had it before, you already know. And if you haven’t… this might be the year to find out what all the fuss is about!

Fresh, homemade, sweet, tart, and packed with flavor, it’s absolutely perfect for the holidays — especially with turkey, ham, pork, or, if you’re like me, just sneaking a spoonful straight from the jar. No judgment. 😉

I’ll be opening up preorders soon, so keep an eye on the page. Every year this stuff goes like crazy, and I have a feeling this year will be no different!

🍁 Cranberry chutney season is coming! 🍁

10/03/2026

🍋🥥 KEY LIME PIE & TART ORDERS ARE OPEN AGAIN!

I made these at the beginning of this week, and honestly… the response was WAY bigger than I ever anticipated! Apparently, I’m not the only one who has a serious weakness for Key Lime. 😂

And I have to say it: the Roasted Coconut Key Lime Pie has officially become my new favorite pie. The combination of that bright, tangy Key Lime with the rich, toasted coconut is absolutely phenomenal. It just works. 🤤

So, by popular demand, I’m taking orders again!

🍋 12” Classic Key Lime Pie — $20

🥥🍋 10” Roasted Coconut Key Lime Pie — $20
My new favorite! Roasted coconut throughout the pie with that perfect Key Lime tang and a buttery crust.

🥥🍋 6 Roasted Coconut Key Lime Tarts — $15
Six individual little bites of Key Lime and roasted coconut goodness.

⏰ I’m taking orders through Monday night at 10:00 PM.

Everything will be made fresh Tuesday morning, with pickup available Tuesday afternoon or Wednesday morning in Afton.

💰 Venmo, Facebook Pay, or Apple Pay will guarantee your order.

After the response this week, I’m expecting these to go quickly, so if you missed out last time, this is your chance!

🍋🥥 Seriously… that roasted coconut + Key Lime combination is something special. It may just be my favorite pie I’ve ever made.

10/03/2026

🌶️ FRESH SALSA IS BACK! 🌶️

I’m taking orders now for fresh-made, seriously delicious salsa from Stuft Catering! Whether you like it mild, hot, or somewhere in between, I’ve got you covered. 🔥

Choose from:

🥑 Guacasalsa — Mild to Hot
🌿 Salsa Verde — Mild to Hot
🍅 Salsa Roja — Mild to Hot
🔥 Taqueria Salsa — HOT ONLY!

💰 $20 per quart

📅 Orders are open now through Tuesday at 10:00 AM.
📍 Pickup: Wednesday–Thursday in Afton
🚗 Delivery: Available anywhere in Star Valley with a minimum purchase.

This is the good stuff — fresh, homemade, packed with flavor, and made in small batches. Perfect for tacos, chips, burritos, eggs, grilled meats… or honestly, just eating straight out of the container with a bag of chips. 😂🌶️

Message me to place your order! I can take Venmo, Apple Pay, Facebook Pay, or cash to guarantee yours. Once Tuesday at 10:00 AM rolls around, the salsa-making train leaves the station! 🚂🔥

Stuft Catering — Big flavor. Real food. No boring salsa.

09/30/2026

🥧🔥 KEY LIME PIE THURSDAY! AND THESE ARE A LITTLE DIFFERENT… 🔥🥧

I’m making another batch of my homemade Key Lime Pies tomorrow, Thursday, and I decided to have a little fun with them this time!

These are 9-inch pies for $20 each, and you get to choose your flavor:

🍫 CHOCOLATE KEY LIME PIE
Creamy, tangy Key Lime filling in a rich chocolate cookie crust, finished with a generous sprinkle of Oreo cookies on top. 🤤

🥥 ROASTED COCONUT KEY LIME PIE
A classic graham cracker crust filled with Key Lime goodness, coconut cream and roasted coconut, then topped with lightly roasted coconut for that extra toasted flavor. 🥥🔥

And yes… I’m already thinking that choosing between these two is going to be the hardest part. 😂

💲 $20 EACH

These are a little smaller than my regular pies, but I wanted to keep them at the $20 price point while adding some extra ingredients and flavors to make these versions something special.

🚨 IMPORTANT — ORDERS CLOSE AT 11:00 PM TONIGHT! 🚨

I’m taking prepaid orders only so I know exactly how many pies to make and don’t end up with a bunch of extras that don’t get picked up.

💳 Payment options:
💜 Venmo
🍎 Apple Pay
📱 Facebook Pay

Message me tonight to reserve yours! Once I hit my limit or the clock strikes 11:00, orders are closed.

Don’t wait until tomorrow and then tell me, “I should have ordered one!” 😜

🥧 $20 — 9-inch pie — tomorrow only — orders close at 11 PM tonight!

Stuft Catering

10/17/2026

10/11/2026

10/10/2026

10/10/2026

10/09/2026

10/07/2026

10/05/2026

10/03/2026

10/03/2026

09/30/2026

Address

Website

Alerts

Contact The Business

Shortcuts

Share

Category

Listing takedown request