My Sugar Pie

My Sugar Pie The ‘My Sugar Pie’ pie list includes more than 50 different pies--all handmade, with a light, crispy pastry crust Accepting pie orders - NOW OPEN
(232)

Starting October 15th you can order your pies for Thanksgiving Week on our website www.mysugarpie.com ! Limited Pie Menu...
04/10/2026

Starting October 15th you can order your pies for Thanksgiving Week on our website www.mysugarpie.com !
Limited Pie Menu: Apple Lattice, Dutch Apple, Cherry Lattice, Dutch Cherry, Hoosier Sugar Cream, Pumpkin, and Pecan.
#15

03/10/2026

BOO-Berry Pie for October Only a Spooky Little Treat!

BOOOOO-Berry Pie! We are kicking off our October Boos and Brews Pies with this delicious Ghost Blueberry! Call shop to o...
03/10/2026

BOOOOO-Berry Pie! We are kicking off our October Boos and Brews Pies with this delicious Ghost Blueberry! Call shop to order!

27/09/2026

Thanks to the Zionsville Chamber of Commerce for a fun night at the 2026 Zionsville Street Dance!
#2026

27/09/2026

Had the BEST time welcoming the Zionsville Kindergarteners to My Sugar Pie! What wonderful kiddos, teachers and parents! So Fun!

Zionsville Street Dance until 10pm! Pie Slices, Apple Dumplings and Bottled Waters! Let’s Dance! ...
26/09/2026

Zionsville Street Dance until 10pm! Pie Slices, Apple Dumplings and Bottled Waters! Let’s Dance!

26/09/2026

This Saturday from 6-10pm on Main Street in downtown Zionsville, join My Sugar Pie for some Pie Slices and Dancing on the Brick Street!

26/09/2026

Saturday Breakfast? Pie Slices, Pinwheels, Whole Pies, Pumpkin Scones, Apple Dumplings and Free pumpkin pie samples!

25/09/2026

Zionsville Street Dance is this Saturday, September 26th, 6-10pm! See you there Pie Peeps! Let’s Dance!

This Saturday, September 26th, 8am-11:40am is the last Saturday for the Summer Carmel Farmers Market! Thanks to our ama...
25/09/2026

This Saturday, September 26th, 8am-11:40am is the last Saturday for the Summer Carmel Farmers Market! Thanks to our amazing team for doing the market every early Saturday morning! Also Thanks to the Carmel Farmers Market volunteers who make it all happen! Great job everyone! See you next year!

Address

40 East Pine Street
IN

Opening Hours

Tuesday 10:00 - 16:00
Wednesday 10:00 - 16:00
Thursday 10:00 - 16:00
Friday 10:00 - 16:00
Saturday 08:00 - 16:00

Telephone

+13177338717

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when My Sugar Pie posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to My Sugar Pie:

Shortcuts

  • Want your business to be the top-listed restaurant?

Share