Shuga Pie Shop

13/06/2026

Sorry folks, I didn’t realize the What’s Left post didn’t go thru! There’s still a handful of flavors left & we’ll be open till 7pm while we clean up, see comments for available flavors…

13/06/2026

13/06/2026

Happy Saturday! Open till 6:30, 631-669-1069 to order ahead

Cookies & Cream
Funfetti
NY B-Ball
Snickerdoodle w/cookie butter creme
Vanilla Choc Chip Crumb aka Entenmann’s style
Red Velvet
Lemon Blueberry Pinwheels
Raspberry Choc Chip Cheesecake
Vanilla Coffee Cookies & Cream
Mostess
Death By Chocolate
Phony Bones (peanut butter)
Chocolate Brownie S’mores

12/06/2026

Go Knicks! 🏀

12/06/2026

Happy Friday! Open till 6:30, 631-669-1069 to order ahead

NY B-Balls
Raspberry Choc Chip Cheesecake
Cookies & Cream
Apple Crumb
Death By Chocolate
Funfetti
Red Velvet
Phony Bones (peanut butter)
Mostess
Chocolate Raspberry
Brown Sugar Chocolate Chip w/cookie butter creme
Vanilla Coffee Cookies & Cream
Mint Chocolate Chip

11/06/2026

Happy Hot as Satan’s butt crack Thursday 🥵 more importantly, did you see that Knicks comeback? I didn’t but heard it was amazing….come down here & reenact the last 2 quarters and maybe there’s a Shuga Pie in it for you 😉 here’s ya flavors….open till 6:30, 631-669-1069 to order ahead

Vanilla Coffee Cookies & Cream
Death By Chocolate
Chocolate Raspberry
Funfetti
Cookies & Cream
Red Velvet
Vanilla Pistachio
Banana Pudding Pie
Mostess
Blueberry Crumb
Phony Bones (peanut butter)

10/06/2026

We’ll have NY B-balls & more! Flavor list will post before opening, see ya tomorrow 🏀

08/06/2026

The raccoon on your roof at dusk probably has kits in your attic. And this is the exact week people discover them and make the one mistake that kills the babies.

Raccoon kits are born in April and May. By now, they're old enough to start climbing out of the den site — following the mother along rooflines and down fences at dusk in a single-file line behind her 🌿

The problem: this is when people find the entry point and seal it. If the kits are sealed inside while the mother is out foraging, they starve in the wall or attic. It happens every spring.

🐾 What to do instead:

- Listen before you seal anything. Kits make a chattering, chirping sound, especially when the mother is out. If you hear it, there are babies inside

- Wait until late summer. By August, the kits are fully mobile and leaving with the mother every night. Once they're all exiting together, seal the entry point behind them after they leave for the evening

- If you need them out sooner, a one-way exclusion door lets raccoons leave but not re-enter — but only use this after confirming the kits are mobile enough to follow the mother out. A professional wildlife operator can install one

- If a kit falls from a den site, place it in a box at the base of the entry point. The mother retrieves it after dark. If not retrieved by morning, contact a licensed rehabber

She chose your attic because it's warm, dark, and safe. She'll leave on her own once the kits are grown. Give her the summer.

06/06/2026

Happy Saturday, open till 6:30, 631-669-1069 to order ahead

Brown Sugar Choc Chip Cookie Butter
Funfetti
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Cookies & Cream
Raspberry Chocolate Chip Crumb
Boston Creme
Red Velvet
Strawberry Cheesecake Crunch
Death By Chocolate
Original
Lemon Lime Swirl
Double Banana aka Entenmann style

Coming up…

NY B-balls
Chocolate Coffee Caramel
Mint Chocolate Chip