My Sweet Valentine Bakery

10/04/2026

A little pink vintage birthday cake for Rayne’s 7th birthday! 🎀💗

We had so much fun with all the pretty pinks, vintage piping, roses, pearls and that sweet little bow! 🥰

Happy 7th Birthday, Rayne! We hope you had the sweetest birthday! 💕🎂

✨ Made by My Sweet Valentine Bakery ✨

Looking for a custom cake for your next celebration? Send us a message — we’d love to make something special for you! 💗

10/02/2026

A little sneak peak.. 🧁👻 Stop by and get your treats tonight at Bessie Benson Park in Carroll.

10/02/2026

🎃 A LITTLE WEATHER UPDATE FOR TONIGHT! 🎃

Unfortunately, due to the weather and park conditions, the full Pumpkins & Painting Under the Stars event may not be able to happen tonight. 😭

BUT — we still have ALL the treats we made, and we’re bringing them with us! 💕 So we will still be at Bessie Benson Park from 6:00–6:30 PM with our bakery table set up!

We’ll have:

🧁 Specialty Cupcakes
🍪 Frosted Sugar Cookies
🍪 Holiday Sprinkle Chocolate Chip Cookies
🥨 Bags of 3 Pretzel Sticks

$3 each or 3 for $8 — while supplies last!

These treats will be available for pickup at the event today, or if you can’t make it out tonight, we can arrange a scheduled pickup in Pickerington or Thornville.

We’ve been baking all day getting everything ready, so we would LOVE to see some friendly faces and send these goodies home with you! 🩷

Thank you so much for supporting our little mom-and-daughter bakery. We appreciate you more than you know! 🎃💕

10/01/2026

COOKIE CAKE SEASON IS HERE! 🍪

Football birthdays, game days, team parties… we’ve got you covered! 🏈

This chocolate chip cookie cake was made for a football-loving birthday boy, complete with all the football details. And yes, the entire thing is a giant, soft, chocolate chip cookie. 😍

Cookie cakes can be customized for any theme, team, birthday or celebration!

09/20/2026

Made for a special cause 🤎
Auctioned to benefit Ride for FairHope Hospice.

09/20/2026

Okay THIS cake 😍

Chocolate cake + peanut butter buttercream + Hershey chocolate shavings + our specialty Buckeyes?! Omg. This one is a chocolate & peanut butter lover’s dream. 🤎🥜

And we love that this cake was auctioned off by one of our customers to help raise money for Ride for FairHope Hospice. What a sweet way to enjoy some cake while supporting such a meaningful cause. ❤️

Thank you for choosing My Sweet Valentine Bakery to be a part of it! 🧁

09/20/2026

A couple from a recent order 💜🩷

Banana cake with cheesecake buttercream and a chocolate chip cookie cake with buttercream. Two totally different flavors, but both turned out SO good!

I love getting to make these for our customers, and I’m always up for trying something new. If you have a birthday, celebration, or just need an excuse for cake, send us a message!

09/14/2026

🎃✨ WE’LL SEE YOU UNDER THE STARS! ✨🎃

My Sweet Valentine Bakery is so excited to be a vendor at Pumpkins & Painting Under the Stars hosted by Realty ONE Group Refined! 🍂🎃

Join us Friday, October 2nd at 6 PM at Bessie Benson Park in Carroll for a FREE evening of fall family fun!

We’ll be there with a table full of Halloween-inspired sweet treats available for purchase! 🧁👻 Think specialty cupcakes, decorated sugar cookies, and chocolate-covered pretzels. 🍫🎃

Enjoy an evening of pumpkin painting and an outdoor showing of Disney’s Halloweentown once the sun goes down! 🍿✨

📍 Bessie Benson Park | Carroll, Ohio
📅 Friday, October 2nd
⏰ Festivities begin at 6 PM
🎟️ FREE event — RSVP required

Come grab a sweet treat from us, paint a pumpkin, and enjoy a fun fall night with the family! 🧡🎃

We can’t wait to see you there!
💕 My Sweet Valentine Bakery

09/12/2026

💗 A little ordering update from us! 💗

We’ve always asked that orders be submitted through our order form, but we’ve typically used Messenger to communicate back and forth after receiving an order.

With the crazy amount of spam and fake accounts messaging our page lately, we’re making one small change:

✨ Moving forward, ALL orders and order inquiries need to go through our order form. ✨

For the time being, we will not be responding to order requests through Messenger. Once you submit the form, we’ll communicate with you from there!

This will help us keep everything organized, make sure we don’t miss an order, and most importantly, help protect our customers from the spam accounts that have been reaching out.

Thank you for being patient with us and for always supporting My Sweet Valentine Bakery! 🧁💕 We appreciate you more than you know!

Please click the link to complete this form.

09/11/2026

🎃 OUR HALLOWEEN MENU IS HERE! 👻

We’re bringing back some spooky favorites just in time for Halloween! 🧡

HALLOWEEN MENU
🧁 Halloween-themed cupcakes
🍪 Halloween sugar cookies
🍪 Chocolate chip cookies with Halloween-colored sprinkles
🥨 Large chocolate-covered pretzels decorated with Halloween colors & sprinkles

WANT TO ADD A LITTLE EXTRA?
🍪 Chocolate Chip Cookie Cups — chocolate chip cookie cups topped with Halloween buttercream and festive decorations. Available as an add-on to your order!

🎃 LIMITED-TIME FLAVOR
Pumpkin Spice Cupcake with Cheesecake Buttercream
Available through November 30th!

📩 Message us for pricing & ordering details!
To place your order, fill out our order form and we’ll get back to you with the details.

Cupcake photos shown are from last year. Designs and decorations will vary this year!