Born Again Baking

Born Again Baking NY style bagels 🥯 / Bread 🥖/ Pastries / Donuts 🍩/ Hand Pies / Cookies 🍪/ Custom Cupcakes🧁! New Market, VA.

Apple cider donut season is right around the corner! Available September through November
08/24/2026

Apple cider donut season is right around the corner! Available September through November

Cupcakes for a princess 👸
08/23/2026

Cupcakes for a princess 👸

Planning a special event? Let us make your desserts! We make custom cupcakes, cookies, and lots of other treats to make ...
08/18/2026

Planning a special event? Let us make your desserts! We make custom cupcakes, cookies, and lots of other treats to make the day extra sweet.

Would you like NY bakery style bagels this weekend, fresh out of the oven? 🥯😍Order by Thursday at 9 p.m. for fresh bagel...
08/17/2026

Would you like NY bakery style bagels this weekend, fresh out of the oven? 🥯😍

Order by Thursday at 9 p.m. for fresh bagels on Saturday!

Pick up at your convenience. Located in New Market near the golf course.

What do you put on your bagel?
08/12/2026

What do you put on your bagel?

Hey friends! We're getting back into the swing of baking here. Now taking orders for pickup on Tuesdays & Saturdays.Plac...
08/11/2026

Hey friends! We're getting back into the swing of baking here. Now taking orders for pickup on Tuesdays & Saturdays.

Place your order at least 48 hours before pick up, choose to pickup on Tuesday or Saturday.

🥯Whole wheat bagels
🥯Classic bagels (toppings optional)
🧁Custom cupcakes with buttercream (vanilla, chocolate, pumpkin, caramel, oreo, strawberry, carrot, banana)
🫐🍌🥕Muffins (Blueberry, banana, carrot, or zucchini)
🥧Fruit hand pies/pop-tarts
🍪Chocolate chip cookies
🍫Brookies
🥔Potato rolls
🥖Multigrain dinner rolls
Oatmeal Cream Pies

Scroll through the pictures to see examples of menu items

Everything is made special for you!
And everything is dye-free!

We will be taking a short break from custom orders as we prepare for a new addition to our family in the next couple of ...
05/20/2026

We will be taking a short break from custom orders as we prepare for a new addition to our family in the next couple of weeks!

I will post updates once we are ready to begin taking orders again

In the meantime, you may see me share some of the things I am making for our family 💗
(Like these organic blueberry muffins and organic banana chocolate chip muffins)

Stromboli! A traditional family favorite. We love to make this for holidays and celebrations.
05/20/2026

Stromboli! A traditional family favorite. We love to make this for holidays and celebrations.

All set up enjoying the morning at Mayor's Park in Mount JacksonCome on by for some freshly baked food
05/09/2026

All set up enjoying the morning at Mayor's Park in Mount Jackson

Come on by for some freshly baked food

Fresh Sunday morning bagels with a side of chewy chocolate chip cookies 🍪 🥯
05/03/2026

Fresh Sunday morning bagels with a side of chewy chocolate chip cookies 🍪 🥯

Address

New Market, VA

Telephone

+18622738908

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Born Again Baking posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Born Again Baking:

Shortcuts

Share