Mullet's Dining, LLC

Mullet's Dining, LLC Authentic, down home Amish cooking prepared and served by Merlin and Mary Lou Mullet and family. Authentic Amish cooking prepared and served by the Mullet family.

Served in a relaxed atmosphere under the cozy glow of gas lanterns on the family farm. Open Tuesday thru Saturday, by reservation only. Serving groups of 10-110. Smaller groups may be accommodated, call ahead for details. Breakfast Menu: Breakfast Haystack available for groups of 25 or less. Breakfast Buffet: (groups of 25 or more) 2 meats, hashbrowns, scrambled eggs, french toast, biscuits and gravy. All breakfasts served with juices, coffee, fresh fruit and homemade rolls. Lunch: Choice of soup: Cheddar Chowder or Vegetable Beef Chicken, bacon club sandwich Salad with homemade dressings Coffee, tea, water Pie Dinner Menu: Tossed salad with homemade dressings Fresh dinner rolls served with homemade jam or apple butter Meats (choice of 2): meatloaf, ham, swiss steak, chicken, or roast beef Noodles OR dressing (both at an additional cost) Mashed Potatoes & gravy Vegetables, provided fresh when in season: green beans, corn, peas, or mixed vegetables Coffee, tea, or water Homemade Pies: Dutch Apple, Apple, Apricot, Blueberry, Cherry, Blackberry, Chocolate, Pecan, Peanut Butter, Vanilla Crumb, Old Fashioned Cream, Coconut Cream, Raisin Cream, Buttercream, Pumpkin, Rhubarb, Strawberry, Peach, Banana Cream, lemon, custard, butterscotch Also great for wedding rehearsals, class reunions, birthday dinners, tour groups, Sunday school and church groups, Holiday parties.

Payment Options:   Cash

Price Range: ££

Attire: Casual


Happy Fall Y'all! Everyone enjoying the beautiful Autumn colors? Don't forget to make your reservations on your next visit to Nappanee!

Some upcoming Nappanee events.

Some upcoming Nappanee events.


Prayers for all in the path of the recent storms!


Thank you for all of the recent likes! Don't forget to call us for your dinner reservations. Hope to see you soon!


Hope everyone is keeping warm out there. Bundle up! And don't forget to call us for your dinner is cold outside but warm under the glow of our gas lamps :)


Don't forget to make your holiday party reservations! Let Mullet's Dining do the cooking!

This weekend in town!
Nappanee Apple Festival

This weekend in town!

The Nappanee Apple Festival is proud of our family-friendly atmosphere and Midwestern hospitality that attracts over 65,000 people and has become one of the largest festivals in the State of Indiana! More than 150 people from the Nappanee community volunteer to help with this festival each year and…


Well, the cooler weather is here! If you are craving some good ole homemade Amish comfort food, make your reservations for dinner today! Looking forward to serving you soon :)

Nappanee Chamber of Commerce

Nappanee Chamber of Commerce

Coming soon!

Timeline Photos

Timeline Photos

....and for good food, make your reservations soon!

....and for good food, make your reservations soon!

Timeline Photos

Timeline Photos


If you are in town doing some shopping and checking out local attractions this summer, don't forget to call us for your dinner reservations! Looking forward to cooking for you!


Celebrating a graduation and need somewhere that can accommodate a large group? Let us do the cooking! Call for reservations!

If you are gonna be in town checking out this event, don't forget to call us for reservations!
Wakarusa Maple Syrup Festival

If you are gonna be in town checking out this event, don't forget to call us for reservations!

PRE-ORDER T-Shirt HERE!Want to Volunteer! FESTIVAL FAVORITES! LIONS CLUB: All-You-Can-Eat Pancake & Sausage Meal with Fresh Maple Syrup WAKARUSA PTO: All-You-Can-Eat BBQ Meal at Nelson's CRAFT & COMMERCIAL BOOTHS CAMEL & PONY RIDES "NEW" PHOTO CONTEST!! $100 Best of Show! Rules Here"Wakarusa's Got T…


Well, I think Spring is finally making an appearance! If you plan on being in the area checking out all of the fine shops in the Nappanee/Shipshewana area, come check us out!


If you will be visiting the Nappanee area, don't forget to call us for reservations! Choose from 2 of the following main dishes: roast beef, oven fried chicken, ham, swiss steak, meatloaf complimented with all of our sides.....and don't forget our yummy pie for dessert! Looking forward to seeing you soon!


Birthday parties, class reunions, family reunions, graduations, whatever occasion you are celebrating, keep us in mind for a delicious home cooked meal.....let us do the cooking. Call for reservations.


Come in and escape the frigid temps under the warm glow of our gas lanterns while enjoying some tasty, homemade, comfort food! Call to make your reservations!


Don't forget to call us for your special events!


Hope everyone is keeping warm in this weather! If you have to go out, dress warmly and be prepared for the weather :-)


Hope you all had a VERY MERRY CHRISTMAS! We wish you a happy & healthy 2014!

If you are trying to decide which cookies to bake this weekend, here is a link to some goodies!  Stay in & stay warm :)
Christmas Cookie Recipes - The Knit Wit by Shair

If you are trying to decide which cookies to bake this weekend, here is a link to some goodies! Stay in & stay warm :)

Make These Yummy Treats I love baking this time of year! So I have collected 40 Christmas Cookie Recipes (or bar or baked good) for you to try th ...


Happy December 1st! Hope everyone had a wonderful Thanksgiving with their loved ones!

Timeline Photos

Timeline Photos


Thanks for all of the "likes"! Don't forget to tell your friends about Mullets Dining! Perfect for your holiday parties.


Have a great weekend! Stay warm everyone!


One week until Thanksgiving! I love this time of year. A time for family and a time to reflect on all of the blessings that have been given to us. What are you most thankful for this year?


Thanks for all of the "likes"! Don't forget to share us with your friends!

Mullet's Dining, LLC's cover photo

Mullet's Dining, LLC's cover photo


On behalf of my friends, the Mullets, I have created this page to help promote and advertise their business on social media. I am not an employee or representative, just an admin of this page. Please "like" and "share" this page with your friends. If you are ever planning on being in the area, consider calling ahead and taste for yourself some of the best home style cooking around! You will not be disappointed.

Dinner Service

Dinner Service


72280 County Road 100
Nappanee, IN


(574) 773-2140


  • Catering
  • Groups
  • Reserve


  • Breakfast
  • Dinner
  • Lunch


Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Mullet's Dining, LLC posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Nearby restaurants

Other American restaurants in Nappanee

Show All